Round 4 Trades

[Wanderer]

... Fyfe > Whitfield via Duursma and Dunkley > Boak ...

I like this one, JM. Fyfe will miss some, and will not be scoring at 100% whenever he comes back. Give yourself 2 chances at low risk, decent value keepers, which the other 2 really never were.

Agree with this trade.......You have corrected the Dunkley mistake (in hindsight now) with a keeper in Boak and you strengthen your defence with another premium in Whitfield. Team structurally looks more solid. Fyfe is going to take some time to recover and will drop in price. Make the trades and don't look back. Could be season defining move.

[tkringle]

Looked at trades and think it's best to do nothing this week.
If Greene doesn't play then I will reassess.

[AaronKirk]

The suspension makes it a lock to happen now but was already considering Dusty to Libba.

May make an upgrade with the cash or wait another week for cows to moo a bit more.

[tommy10]

Looked at trades and think it's best to do nothing this week.
If Greene doesn't play then I will reassess.

Yep thinking this now too

[Judd Magic]

... Fyfe > Whitfield via Duursma and Dunkley > Boak ...

I like this one, JM. Fyfe will miss some, and will not be scoring at 100% whenever he comes back. Give yourself 2 chances at low risk, decent value keepers, which the other 2 really never were.

Agree with this trade.......You have corrected the Dunkley mistake (in hindsight now) with a keeper in Boak and you strengthen your defence with another premium in Whitfield. Team structurally looks more solid. Fyfe is going to take some time to recover and will drop in price. Make the trades and don't look back. Could be season defining move.

Team looks a lot better structured now and solid, agree there.

Fyfe I hope takes a bit to come back to his best so I can get him back on the cheap.

The 3 rookies up forward are a bit of a worry though, have no idea how I will be upgrading them anytime soon.  ???

[Fid]

I might end up going Fyfe to Lloyd via Duursma
and Settlefield to Libba

[bkimm32]

If Fyfe misses he must be traded IMO, he has the 60 in his rolling average & will more than likely have a slowish first game back. Price should hit 550k so can be brought back in if need be. This isn't so much about chasing points, it' about generating cash & shielding the side from under performing rookies.

... Fyfe > Whitfield via Duursma and Dunkley > Boak ...

I like this one, JM. Fyfe will miss some, and will not be scoring at 100% whenever he comes back. Give yourself 2 chances at low risk, decent value keepers, which the other 2 really never were.

Don't mind these trades either.

Really bad advice

[bkimm32]

Lol at trading fyfe - one of the best SuperCoach players in the league - if he misses one game.

It's like you selected him expecting him to play 22 games

[Gandalf123]

If Fyfe misses this week wouldn’t it be possible he misses 2 as the following week is a trip to Sydney?

[Ringo]

If he misses this week wouldn’t it be possible he misses 2 as the following week is a trip to Sydney?

Only concussion nothing to do with his elbow so expecting only a week if he is out.

[Keeper27]

Balta to Daniel.
that's it

If he misses this week wouldn’t it be possible he misses 2 as the following week is a trip to Sydney?

Only concussion nothing to do with his elbow so expecting only a week if he is out.

Hope so.

[Rusty00]

If Fyfe misses this week wouldn’t it be possible he misses 2 as the following week is a trip to Sydney?

Fremantle travel across the country every second week, so not sure that makes as big a difference as for example the Giants giving Kelly an extra week rather than travelling the other way to Perth.

[kilbluff1985]

rowan marshall anyone?

[Wanderer]

Need help!!!
I currently have 28 trades left, is it worth trading Dunkley for Boak or should I save the trade, do we expect Dunkley to start scoring better and Boak to drop to at least 100 or around there???

If your team is pretty much set with nothing else to fix then I would trade Dunkley to Boak. If you don't do it this week then it will cost you an extra $50k. Boak looks like he will be getting more mid time than Dunkley. Boak will end up top 4-6 forward, whereas Dunkley doesn't look like he will be top 10 sitting in the fwd line so you will have to offload him at some point anyway. You would be upgrading a player who isn't looking like a keeper to a keeper, so the trade would be worth it IMO.

Who really knows what the coaches are going to do in the end so there is always a risk with these trades.

[kilbluff1985]

setters with a be of 16 to marshall is happening

will be my f5 and still 150k in the bank