Post Round 3 Trades

[Thunderbolts]

In AF you can get away with it i reckon, plenty of trades .. be funny if Heeney scores 50 next week and Worpedo goes 100   :-X

It'd be Drew or Setters to Heeney. Wouldn't move on Worpel yet...

Oh yes der

I would be moving Setters before Drew - Drew still has $$ to make

[WhatMate]

Hoping Phillips gets another week, that BE of 25 feels too good to trade out.

Seems like Sheed was playing forward?

I think I'll do something like - Hore and Sheed to Rozee and Stack

[Thunderbolts]

Hoping Phillips gets another week, that BE of 25 feels too good to trade out.

Seems like Sheed was playing forward?

I think I'll do something like - Hore and Sheed to Rozee and Stack

Yeah Sheed was 51% forward in that round... Still attended more centre bounces than Gaff so anything is possible...

[nrich102]

Thinking Scott -> Stack and Dunkley -> Boak.

Don't love it because I'll still have Gibbons, but I think I really need Boak.

[Football Factory]

Sheed with DPP would be pretty handy, i haven't seen how much time he has spent forward in the first 3 rounds. Anyone think he will play forward a bit more now and could play enough to get DPP? Not likely to get DPP by round 6 though.

[crowls]

Went from top 200 to 2800 in one round - huge thanks to Westhoff and whole Port Adelaide side (Unfortunately, I don't have Boak yet).

Worpel and Cousins decided to stink it up this week as well just to finish it all off.

First time under 2000 AF points since the byes last year.....if only I could make more than 2 rage trades this week.

Need to get rid of Westhoff (new role + 2 other rucks is not DT friendly)  - Can anyone talk me out of Rowan Marshall from the Saints?

Also need to trade Balta out to Stack - surely the other guys will do better next week.....

Will Rocky make it back - he didn't look great.

had phillips as r2 and copped donut last week.   rage trade to marshall in time for longer to come back in.   

[jvalles69]

Thinking maybe I should keep Rocky and Witts now.  Moving them to Stack and Mummy leaves me with almost 800K in the bank.  :o  Kelly could out too, bloody sideways trading...

[Ringo]

Actually this trade is for Dream Team but not a lot of action there so what do ytou think of these trades a bit radical though:

Stef Martin to Mumford and Dusty to Macrea.

[Thunderbolts]

Actually this trade is for Dream Team but not a lot of action there so what do ytou think of these trades a bit radical though:

Stef Martin to Mumford and Dusty to Macrea.

Don't mind it and would def do dusty to macrae….

[LaHug]

Actually this trade is for Dream Team but not a lot of action there so what do ytou think of these trades a bit radical though:

Stef Martin to Mumford and Dusty to Macrea.

Don't mind it and would def do dusty to macrae….

Only problem I see is Stef to Mummy likely means you still need to do Mummy to Grundy/Gawn later in the season if you want the top two rucks. That said, if Mummy averages within 15 of one of them, I'd probably trade off the 200 odd points for the cash savings.

[Ringo]

Actually this trade is for Dream Team but not a lot of action there so what do ytou think of these trades a bit radical though:

Stef Martin to Mumford and Dusty to Macrea.

Don't mind it and would def do dusty to macrae….

Only problem I see is Stef to Mummy likely means you still need to do Mummy to Grundy/Gawn later in the season if you want the top two rucks. That said, if Mummy averages within 15 of one of them, I'd probably trade off the 200 odd points for the cash savings.

Thank You - Thoughts with Mummy are if he maintains 85+ average he will rise to 450/500k allowing upgrade after the byes if he stays on park. Risk but worth it in my opinion.  Stef has already lost 55k with a further 30k likely this week so time to consider hence the Mummy option to get the cash to get Macrae in and still have some change.

[LaHug]

Actually this trade is for Dream Team but not a lot of action there so what do ytou think of these trades a bit radical though:

Stef Martin to Mumford and Dusty to Macrea.

Don't mind it and would def do dusty to macrae….

Only problem I see is Stef to Mummy likely means you still need to do Mummy to Grundy/Gawn later in the season if you want the top two rucks. That said, if Mummy averages within 15 of one of them, I'd probably trade off the 200 odd points for the cash savings.

Thank You - Thoughts with Mummy are if he maintains 85+ average he will rise to 450/500k allowing upgrade after the byes if he stays on park. Risk but worth it in my opinion.  Stef has already lost 55k with a further 30k likely this week so time to consider hence the Mummy option to get the cash to get Macrae in and still have some change.

Probably also worth noting that he hasn't averaged over 85 since 2015. As long as you're not expecting more than that, you could be ok. I guess it's no different from downgrading a rookie to a cheaper rookie to help with an upgrade.

[jvalles69]

Struggling big time with trades.  My iffy guys were Rocky and Kelly, but both look like they'll be playing.  Was going to trade Stack in for Gibbons or Scott, but if Ross get's named I might bring him in instead for the extra 20K grab.

As for 2nd trade, the only think I can think of is trade Witts down to Mummy for the cash grab playing the BE game, I do think Witts will score higher, but I would pocket an odd 250K which I think is more important than 10-15 extra points.  Playing the BE game with my rucks until Gawn bottoms out.

Advice?  ???

[Football Factory]

Struggling big time with trades.  My iffy guys were Rocky and Kelly, but both look like they'll be playing.  Was going to trade Stack in for Gibbons or Scott, but if Ross get's named I might bring him in instead for the extra 20K grab.

As for 2nd trade, the only think I can think of is trade Witts down to Mummy for the cash grab playing the BE game, I do think Witts will score higher, but I would pocket an odd 250K which I think is more important than 10-15 extra points.  Playing the BE game with my rucks until Gawn bottoms out.

Advice?  ???

I reckon Witts was a pretty good pick, wish i chose him ahead of Goldy. Mummy can be inconsistent and has brain fades here and there with visits to the tribunal. The cash is nice though and he should go up 100k?

Rooks don't go up all that much straight away, reckon Stack is the way to go and if Ross scores well and get's named for round 2 put him in as well next week.

Who you get rid of to bring them in who knows ? Scott has a higher ceiling than Gibbons but Scott probably needs to play a bit better to keep his spot in the team.

I'm holding Rocky, he looks fine, should bounce back this week i hope. I'm holding Kelly, he should be right and is a top 6 forward surely.

[jvalles69]

Struggling big time with trades.  My iffy guys were Rocky and Kelly, but both look like they'll be playing.  Was going to trade Stack in for Gibbons or Scott, but if Ross get's named I might bring him in instead for the extra 20K grab.

As for 2nd trade, the only think I can think of is trade Witts down to Mummy for the cash grab playing the BE game, I do think Witts will score higher, but I would pocket an odd 250K which I think is more important than 10-15 extra points.  Playing the BE game with my rucks until Gawn bottoms out.

Advice?  ???

I reckon Witts was a pretty good pick, wish i chose him ahead of Goldy. Mummy can be inconsistent and has brain fades here and there with visits to the tribunal. The cash is nice though and he should go up 100k?

Rooks don't go up all that much straight away, reckon Stack is the way to go and if Ross scores well and get's named for round 2 put him in as well next week.

Who you get rid of to bring them in who knows ? Scott has a higher ceiling than Gibbons but Scott probably needs to play a bit better to keep his spot in the team.

I'm holding Rocky, he looks fine, should bounce back this week i hope. I'm holding Kelly, he should be right and is a top 6 forward surely.

Thanks mate, I agree on the holds.

I chose Witts because he had the easiest early draw of any ruckman, now his BE is higher than his average and projection so he's done his job.  Don't trust Mummy, but if it's even for just one week to get that cash will be helpful later.  You're prob right about going Stack as well.  Cheers.