Who to field - Round 3

[pendles93]

Collins or Setterfield (Moore Burgess DPP) ??

[Wanderer]

Collins or Setterfield (Moore Burgess DPP) ??

I went with Setterfield

[tor01doc]

B Scott for me

Even with the loophole?

Yeah - probably right.

Setterfield vs Swans and Petruccelle vs Pies

Edit:  Hang on a minute.....what did Scott score last week?

[SilverLion]

B Scott for me

Even with the loophole?

Yeah - probably right.

Setterfield vs Swans and Petruccelle vs Pies

Edit:  Hang on a minute.....what did Scott score last week?

24, but I'm guessing you knew that ;)

Setterfield for mine, loophole using Greene if you've got him and are holding though.



Scrimshaw vs. Collins

[bkimm32]

ridley vs scrimshaw...

(actually for emergency)

thinking ridley at this stage, just.

[SilverLion]

ridley vs scrimshaw...

(actually for emergency)

thinking ridley at this stage, just.

I'd be playing Ridley on the field if I had him. Definitely ahead of Scrim for emergency though.

[Mat0369]

ridley vs scrimshaw...

(actually for emergency)

thinking ridley at this stage, just.

100% Ridley. Watch him rip out a 90 tonight and I'll cry because I had to trade him last week

[Jalapeno]

B Scott for me

Even with the loophole?

Yeah - probably right.

Setterfield vs Swans and Petruccelle vs Pies

Edit:  Hang on a minute.....what did Scott score last week?

My reasoning is that the Hawks give up a lot of contested possessions to opposition mids. Scott will be back in the guys more and his score last week was due to him sitting at HF. I can't see him playing there again this week.

Especially due to Jed not coming back in.

[no eye deer]

Collins or Duursma? Kinda sux plonking a 189k rookie on the bench.

[SilverLion]

Collins or Duursma? Kinda sux plonking a 189k rookie on the bench.

Duursma

Similar to my predicament, thinking Scrimshaw?

Scrimshaw vs. Collins

[YoungGun]

Loophole setterfield and parker with the C on Macrae or just take parker and keep dangers VC score

[YoungGun]

Loophole setterfield and parker with the C on Macrae or just take parker and keep dangers VC score

considering option 1 even though it's a bit greedy

[tkringle]

Would you start Butters or Scott?

[no eye deer]

Would you start Butters or Scott?

I’ve gone SCOTT. Should be running through the mids again this week, with no Jed Anderson. Apparently he was crook last week as well. Hoping he bounces back to the previous weeks form.