Who to field - Round 3

[HoleMeal]

so had the E on Clark and Hore on the filed.

Was going to trade Hore - Schrimshaw as im worried Hore wont get much games...no point having a D7-8 whos not generating much cash.

Should i just keep the E on Clark and roll with the 65 or go Hore - Schrimshaw?

Think long term

[dmac07]

Put the E on Clark. Now do I play Scrim or Collins?

I’m banking Clark’s as I can live with that. 60 or above is acceptable from a rookie. If Collins goes 90+ then so be it but a repeat of R1 would piss me off.

I actually cant unless someone from the Sunday games gets dropped, didnt start Hore.

[tkringle]

so had the E on Clark and Hore on the filed.

Was going to trade Hore - Schrimshaw as im worried Hore wont get much games...no point having a D7-8 whos not generating much cash.

Should i just keep the E on Clark and roll with the 65 or go Hore - Schrimshaw?

Think long term

This. A rookie generating $$ is worth way more than a few points potentially lost if Scrim serves up a 50

[ubeaut]

Would play Collins over Clark, but what about Wilkie?

Anyone think Wilkie is a good chance to score over 65?

After the last 2 weeks he will be lucky to hit 50. He is getting bugger all of it, 1st week was saved by a few marks and high DE. Might not even make the cut. Take Clark's score imo.

[ubeaut]

B.Scott (63.5) or Butters (77.5)
Had Butters locked in until I read Scott had gastro last week.

Yeah this is a tough one. Butters been great but has relied on goals/assists vs poorly playing teams. Has a much tougher match up vs Lions at home.
Scott did tonne up in a losing team round 1,but was so bad last week gastro or not (why play him if not fit?)

What about Setterfield VS Parker?
Recent history says Parker, but again has played poor teams.
Setterfield has been disappointing but I think Blues will beat Swans.

[MC]

What about Setterfield VS Parker?
Recent history says Parker, but again has played poor teams.
Setterfield has been disappointing but I think Blues will beat Swans.

I'm taking a punt and fielding Setterfield over Parker this week. Looking at their JLT scores I feel like Parker has 'overachieved' so far, and if they go down to Freo as I expect they will, his cameos might not be worth so many points. Setterfield on the other hand is 'settled' into the midfield... Ba Dum Tsss...

But seriously, I'm backing Setters to beat Parker this week.

[RaisyDaisy]

What about Setterfield VS Parker?
Recent history says Parker, but again has played poor teams.
Setterfield has been disappointing but I think Blues will beat Swans.

I'm taking a punt and fielding Setterfield over Parker this week. Looking at their JLT scores I feel like Parker has 'overachieved' so far, and if they go down to Freo as I expect they will, his cameos might not be worth so many points. Setterfield on the other hand is 'settled' into the midfield... Ba Dum Tsss...

But seriously, I'm backing Setters to beat Parker this week.

I'm with MC on this one - gut says Setters should do alright this week and Parker over in Perth might finally come back down to reality

That said, I'm fielding both anyway because holding Greene (Will use Greene to loop Setters and Petrucelle, although it's probably a futile exercise as Petrucelle I can't see going above 55 vs Pies so anything 60+ from Setters I will take)

[AN1611]

Butters vs Scott for M8?

[frenzy]

What about Setterfield VS Parker?
Recent history says Parker, but again has played poor teams.
Setterfield has been disappointing but I think Blues will beat Swans.

I'm taking a punt and fielding Setterfield over Parker this week. Looking at their JLT scores I feel like Parker has 'overachieved' so far, and if they go down to Freo as I expect they will, his cameos might not be worth so many points. Setterfield on the other hand is 'settled' into the midfield... Ba Dum Tsss...

But seriously, I'm backing Setters to beat Parker this week.

I will be watching Setters role this week and if he's doing the tagging/run with role again just like last week, then I will be giving him the heave ho.

[enzedder]

What about Setterfield VS Parker?
Recent history says Parker, but again has played poor teams.
Setterfield has been disappointing but I think Blues will beat Swans.

I'm taking a punt and fielding Setterfield over Parker this week. Looking at their JLT scores I feel like Parker has 'overachieved' so far, and if they go down to Freo as I expect they will, his cameos might not be worth so many points. Setterfield on the other hand is 'settled' into the midfield... Ba Dum Tsss...

But seriously, I'm backing Setters to beat Parker this week.

I'm with MC on this one - gut says Setters should do alright this week and Parker over in Perth might finally come back down to reality

That said, I'm fielding both anyway because holding Greene (Will use Greene to loop Setters and Petrucelle, although it's probably a futile exercise as Petrucelle I can't see going above 55 vs Pies so anything 60+ from Setters I will take)

I'd back Parker to beat Setters.
He's a beast.
I'm keeping Greene too, looping Setters with Petruccelle, same as you.
-------------------------------------

Butters vs Scott for M8?

Still undecided on this one. Have Butters in there atm but that may change.

[RaisyDaisy]

Butters vs Scott for M8?

Butters vs Scott for M8?

If Anderson and Ahern make the cut, I'd go Butters

If they don't, then I reckon Bailey - Hawks seem to leak SC points to oppo mids

[IntegralX]

Bank Clark's 65 or go for Duursma?

I'm also wondering about Setterfield vs Parker; I'd normally base that on my league matchups but I won't get the luxury of seeing how I'm going since Carlton are up tomorrow arvo.

[tor01doc]

Bank Clark's 65 or go for Duursma?

I'm also wondering about Setterfield vs Parker; I'd normally base that on my league matchups but I won't get the luxury of seeing how I'm going since Carlton are up tomorrow arvo.

Runs on the board

[tor01doc]

I can take two bites of the Setterfield - Petruccelle cherry via the Greene Lou Pole

OR

B Scott??

What you think?

[Jalapeno]

B Scott for me