Correctional trades

[quinny88]

Who do I trade Balta to when I already have Moore, Setterfield, Drew and Parker?
Just hold?

Hold. Unless you have someone you can swing forward and grab Duursma down back. I'd rather wait a week before making a call with Balta to be honest. Can see the best option and assese at least

Backs I have Collins, Clarke, Duursma, Hore and Burgess so it's probably only Wilkie I'm missing there that's worth getting but still not sure he's worth it yet

[Mat0369]

Collins might also need replacing

[tor01doc]

For those that have Grundy, what do you see as a trade score vs a hold score?

0-200 hold

Agreed - anything over 200 and rage trade the barbie

[TommyC]

My rookies only

DEF: Duursma, Joyce [Hore, Collins]

FWD: Drew, Parker [Setterfield, Balta]

Getting headaches on what to do.
Should I trade Balta and/or Collins or neither?
Plan was to hold Collins but that was before the Balta omission.

[quinny88]

My rookies only

DEF: Duursma, Joyce [Hore, Collins]

FWD: Drew, Parker [Setterfield, Balta]

Getting headaches on what to do.
Should I trade Balta and/or Collins or neither?
Plan was to hold Collins but that was before the Balta omission.

Hold this week and next week do Collins to Clarke/Wilkie (if they score well enough to justify it)
Balta has no decent replacement. Petruccelle/Schultz/Miers the only that come to mind but they could be dropped at any moment anyway and all have dodgy scoring potential

[bkimm32]

After careful consideration as a collins and balta owner, and someone who doesn't have Parker or Wilkie/Joyce. Im going to hold this week and wait until next. If I need to make both of them trades next week it will give me some pocket change to swap brad crouch > rockliffe after round 3 after pay rises (again if I need to)

I don't think there's any need to make any trades this week unless it calls for very desperate measures (got 3-4 or more rookies wrong)

[TommyC]

My rookies only

DEF: Duursma, Joyce [Hore, Collins]

FWD: Drew, Parker [Setterfield, Balta]

Getting headaches on what to do.
Should I trade Balta and/or Collins or neither?
Plan was to hold Collins but that was before the Balta omission.

Hold this week and next week do Collins to Clarke/Wilkie (if they score well enough to justify it)
Balta has no decent replacement. Petruccelle/Schultz/Miers the only that come to mind but they could be dropped at any moment anyway and all have dodgy scoring potential

Was thinking this.
Thanks!

[ubeaut]

My rookies only

DEF: Duursma, Joyce [Hore, Collins]

FWD: Drew, Parker [Setterfield, Balta]

Getting headaches on what to do.
Should I trade Balta and/or Collins or neither?
Plan was to hold Collins but that was before the Balta omission.

Clark and Duursma are the best back rookies and I have no idea why you'd pick Collins over Clark for 50k more or Joyce or Hore for that matter. Collins was only a good pick playing intercept 3rd defender, not a lock down role.
Collins > Clark is a no brainer unless Joyce is dropped then Joyce > Clark

[jfitty]

Jay Lockhart rumoured to come in for Melbourne, 102k MID/DEF.

Would certainly solve my problems going Balta to him, but what a risk!

[Gigantor]

Jay Lockhart rumoured to come in for Melbourne, 102k MID/DEF.

Would certainly solve my problems going Balta to him, but what a risk!

86k from Collins would be nice!

[TommyC]

My rookies only

DEF: Duursma, Joyce [Hore, Collins]

FWD: Drew, Parker [Setterfield, Balta]

Getting headaches on what to do.
Should I trade Balta and/or Collins or neither?
Plan was to hold Collins but that was before the Balta omission.

Clark and Duursma are the best back rookies and I have no idea why you'd pick Collins over Clark for 50k more or Joyce or Hore for that matter. Collins was only a good pick playing intercept 3rd defender, not a lock down role.
Collins > Clark is a no brainer unless Joyce is dropped then Joyce > Clark

Hindsight is a great thing.
I may do Collins > Clark, leaves me with 80k in the kitty.

[HappyDEZ]

Jay Lockhart rumoured to come in for Melbourne, 102k MID/DEF.

Would certainly solve my problems going Balta to him, but what a risk!

Certainly opens up options. A mature aged $102K DPP. Opens up Balta, Burgess, Atkins, Gibbons & Pet to swap with & gives me the little bit of change I need to upgrade another to Scott. Will probs still go a premo down to Rocky next week tho + worst mid rookie to Scott & wait till Lockhart is on the bubble to offload another dud rookie.

[ubeaut]

Jay Lockhart rumoured to come in for Melbourne, 102k MID/DEF.

Would certainly solve my problems going Balta to him, but what a risk!

Why rush that trade though? Wouldn't have to do it next week either as neither of their price will change.

[HappyDEZ]

Slightly off topic but it is not the correctional trades we need, well most of us anyway. For a lot of the cookie cutter seasoned coaches like myself it is the Grundy/Gawn/Brouch/Libba (+ Oliver for those that have him) combo we need to fire to peg back some of those 20,000 - 30,000 coaches ahead of us.

[bkimm32]

Slightly off topic but it is not the correctional trades we need, well most of us anyway. For a lot of the cookie cutter seasoned coaches like myself it is the Grundy/Gawn/Brouch/Libba (+ Oliver for those that have him) combo we need to fire to peg back some of those 20,000 - 30,000 coaches ahead of us.

You're not a seasoned coach if you want to trade Gawn or Grundy