2019 Premium Mids

[js19]

So what the hell do I do with Brayshaw? With $135k in the bank, I can't even afford Walsh and Brayshaw to Macrae and a def premium... Do I just hold him and hope? He ran at less than 50% DE last night and seems to be getting worse every week.

I'd dump Brayshaw before Walsh. Wouldn't be surprised if Walsh tons up next week

I seriously don't get the Walsh love, you'd rather keep a skinny first year rookie with a large BE over a bloke who finished fourth in the Brownlow?

Lol what does his brownlow finish have to do with anything? Every man and his dog knows he wasn't the third best player of the year

I'd be dumping him before Walsh too, he's meant to be a prem and he isn't

And Walsh is? You play the odds from here, Brayshaw a much better chance of scoring better, the notion that Walsh is destined to become the best first year player in history is pie in the sky stuff. Have said it for weeks & still people think he'll break all the rules.

It’s all relative, and depends on the points you’re gaining. Walsh to Neale is the play for me, so an average of 30+ points gained and getting the best player of the year (currently) I cant pass up

[RaisyDaisy]

So what the hell do I do with Brayshaw? With $135k in the bank, I can't even afford Walsh and Brayshaw to Macrae and a def premium... Do I just hold him and hope? He ran at less than 50% DE last night and seems to be getting worse every week.

I'd dump Brayshaw before Walsh. Wouldn't be surprised if Walsh tons up next week

I seriously don't get the Walsh love, you'd rather keep a skinny first year rookie with a large BE over a bloke who finished fourth in the Brownlow?

Lol what does his brownlow finish have to do with anything? Every man and his dog knows he wasn't the third best player of the year

I'd be dumping him before Walsh too, he's meant to be a prem and he isn't

And Walsh is? You play the odds from here, Brayshaw a much better chance of scoring better, the notion that Walsh is destined to become the best first year player in history is pie in the sky stuff. Have said it for weeks & still people think he'll break all the rules.

Walsh is a rookie that we will all be upgrading eventually

Brayshaw as a prem would be putting owners way behind so I'd be dumping him first

Either way they both go

[Bully]

So what the hell do I do with Brayshaw? With $135k in the bank, I can't even afford Walsh and Brayshaw to Macrae and a def premium... Do I just hold him and hope? He ran at less than 50% DE last night and seems to be getting worse every week.

I'd dump Brayshaw before Walsh. Wouldn't be surprised if Walsh tons up next week

I seriously don't get the Walsh love, you'd rather keep a skinny first year rookie with a large BE over a bloke who finished fourth in the Brownlow?

Lol what does his brownlow finish have to do with anything? Every man and his dog knows he wasn't the third best player of the year

I'd be dumping him before Walsh too, he's meant to be a prem and he isn't

And Walsh is? You play the odds from here, Brayshaw a much better chance of scoring better, the notion that Walsh is destined to become the best first year player in history is pie in the sky stuff. Have said it for weeks & still people think he'll break all the rules.

Walsh is a rookie that we will all be upgrading eventually

Brayshaw as a prem would be putting owners way behind so I'd be dumping him first

Either way they both go

Sure but Walsh goes first, there's no justification for trading Brayshaw beforehand.

[PowerBug]

Bye structure and the necessity for the extra cash immediately would be the only reasons I'd trade Brayshaw before Walsh

[AaronKirk]

So what the hell do I do with Brayshaw? With $135k in the bank, I can't even afford Walsh and Brayshaw to Macrae and a def premium... Do I just hold him and hope? He ran at less than 50% DE last night and seems to be getting worse every week.

I'd dump Brayshaw before Walsh. Wouldn't be surprised if Walsh tons up next week

I seriously don't get the Walsh love, you'd rather keep a skinny first year rookie with a large BE over a bloke who finished fourth in the Brownlow?

Lol what does his brownlow finish have to do with anything? Every man and his dog knows he wasn't the third best player of the year

I'd be dumping him before Walsh too, he's meant to be a prem and he isn't

And Walsh is? You play the odds from here, Brayshaw a much better chance of scoring better, the notion that Walsh is destined to become the best first year player in history is pie in the sky stuff. Have said it for weeks & still people think he'll break all the rules.

Walsh is a rookie that we will all be upgrading eventually

Brayshaw as a prem would be putting owners way behind so I'd be dumping him first

Either way they both go

Sure but Walsh goes first, there's no justification for trading Brayshaw beforehand.

Who would you place cash on for the rest of the season to average higher? Brayshaw or Walsh. My cash would be on Brayshaw so cut Walsh first.

Walsh IMO has hit his ceiling price wise and will be upgrading him soon, potentially this week.

[Rusty00]

Is Coniglio taking the piss >:(

[Mat0369]

Walsh has his bye last and he scored 'poorly' with a 70 against the best midfield in the comp that is one of the tougher teams to score points against as they maintain possession and don't let the opposition get it. Brayshaw also has a tougher run to his bye than Walsh does.

And for the talk of him being a 'skinny 18 year old', he also has an insane tank and work rate which allows him to find the pill. If you're going to dump both the common sense thing is to dump Brayshaw who will likely bleed more cash first and then move Walsh around his bye.

[James Pies]

Who would be the best option to bring in? I have Neale, Cripps, Macrae, Treloar, Fyfe, Brayshaw, Walsh

I'll be trading Walsh or Brayshaw, maybe even both but im not sure which premo to bring in. Oliver definitely tempts me but i'm aware of all the headaches he has caused for the owners that have had him. I like Josh Kelly but im worried he may miss a few games here or there. Bont is another option too i guess.

[Mat0369]

Josh Kelly by the Flemington straight. You just can't be sure he won't miss games. Could hit the double ton against the Blues next week

[Judd Magic]

I have no flowering idea what to do with my team.

Ross is my M8 and now injured.

Atkins is injured on my bench too.

Both shower scores so their cash generation is shot.

Have $411,900.00 in the kitty so wondering if I should downgrade Atkins to Stocker and upgrade Ross to Fyfe?  ???

[PowerBug]

It's going to be fun upgrading to two of these premium mids this week! Probably do so from Libba and Duursma. A lot depends on prices first

[enzedder]

https://www.afl.com.au/video/2019-05-12/is-fyfe-in-trouble-for-this-elbow
Maybe I won't be bringing in Fyfe this week.

[jbjimmyjb]

https://www.afl.com.au/video/2019-05-12/is-fyfe-in-trouble-for-this-elbow
Maybe I won't be bringing in Fyfe this week.

The way I see it he's gone.
Intentional, high contact = 1 week.

This week has been a disaster.

[RaisyDaisy]

https://www.afl.com.au/video/2019-05-12/is-fyfe-in-trouble-for-this-elbow
Maybe I won't be bringing in Fyfe this week.

The way I see it he's gone.
Intentional, high contact = 1 week.

This week has been a disaster.

Yeah, it didn't impact Lynch at all which is in his favour but he does appear to have raised his elbow and I think that might get him in trouble

[jfitty]

Lynch got straight back up and kept going.. It's high contact, but surely he doesn't get a week