Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[RoughRed]

Peoples opinions please on the following
Cogs to Treloar/Zorko keep Harris Andrews use 1 tradeor
Cogs to Greene HA to Whitfield 2 trades used currently have 4 left

Option 2 opens up M/F link could also go Robbie Gray and possibly Stewart

IMO Cogs to Treloar/Zorko but pass on Greene

[dylanclements]

IMO Cogs to Treloar/Zorko but pass on Greene

Agree with that. Treloar over Zorko I reckon

[Jimmykidd]

IMO Cogs to Treloar/Zorko but pass on Greene

Agree with that. Treloar over Zorko I reckon

Agree but I'd take zorko. From here brisbane Plays 4 out of 6 at the Gabba, and 3 of those are in a row in SC finals. Since Rd 7 he's averaged 114. (Yes I'm bringing him in this week) haha

[tkringle]

Duncan vs JPK?

[tommy10]

Duncan vs JPK?

Duncan imo. JPK may miss games

[Woppa15]

Duncan vs JPK?

Duncan imo. JPK may miss games

Extending on that Would you pay an extra 50k + for a Shuey or Treloar type over Duncan or Merrett for that matter?

[Samsturmfels]

Duncan vs JPK?

solid question. I am very undecided.
JPK: 13 games, average of 110.5 (excluding his injured affected game of 68), priced at 533k. 2 scores below 94
Duncan: 16 games, average of 106.2, priced at 502.2k, 4 scores under 94 including a 58 two weeks ago.

I am finding JPK more appeal atm because i already have 3 cats players, however may end up going with duncan to free up more cash for my second trade.

[jvalles69]

Duncan vs JPK?

solid question. I am very undecided.
JPK: 13 games, average of 110.5 (excluding his injured affected game of 68), priced at 533k. 2 scores below 94
Duncan: 16 games, average of 106.2, priced at 502.2k, 4 scores under 94 including a 58 two weeks ago.

I am finding JPK more appeal atm because i already have 3 cats players, however may end up going with duncan to free up more cash for my second trade.

I was tossing up between JPK and Mrouch a few weeks back, JPK is better but I went with Mrouch due to the fact the Crows are fighting for finals and Swans most likely will not be so anything can happen re restings/shutdowns.

[tkringle]

Duncan vs JPK?

solid question. I am very undecided.
JPK: 13 games, average of 110.5 (excluding his injured affected game of 68), priced at 533k. 2 scores below 94
Duncan: 16 games, average of 106.2, priced at 502.2k, 4 scores under 94 including a 58 two weeks ago.

I am finding JPK more appeal atm because i already have 3 cats players, however may end up going with duncan to free up more cash for my second trade.

I was tossing up between JPK and Mrouch a few weeks back, JPK is better but I went with Mrouch due to the fact the Crows are fighting for finals and Swans most likely will not be so anything can happen re restings/shutdowns.

Also throwing Taranto into the mix to consider with those two..

[Samsturmfels]

Duncan vs JPK?

solid question. I am very undecided.
JPK: 13 games, average of 110.5 (excluding his injured affected game of 68), priced at 533k. 2 scores below 94
Duncan: 16 games, average of 106.2, priced at 502.2k, 4 scores under 94 including a 58 two weeks ago.

I am finding JPK more appeal atm because i already have 3 cats players, however may end up going with duncan to free up more cash for my second trade.

I was tossing up between JPK and Mrouch a few weeks back, JPK is better but I went with Mrouch due to the fact the Crows are fighting for finals and Swans most likely will not be so anything can happen re restings/shutdowns.

Also throwing Taranto into the mix to consider with those two..

yeah hes another option not to bad with both kelly and cogs out.

Another question I have is degoey vs mundy/greene (have limited cash and will only have 1 trade left after this week). If I do with one of mundy or greene it means i wont be able to afford JPK

[dylanclements]

Another question I have is degoey vs mundy/greene (have limited cash and will only have 1 trade left after this week). If I do with one of mundy or greene it means i wont be able to afford JPK

Depends on who you get instead of JPK. Henderson and Mundy is what I'd probably do - suspect that won't be a popular opinion  ;D

[Samsturmfels]

Another question I have is degoey vs mundy/greene (have limited cash and will only have 1 trade left after this week). If I do with one of mundy or greene it means i wont be able to afford JPK

Depends on who you get instead of JPK. Henderson and Mundy is what I'd probably do - suspect that won't be a popular opinion  ;D

id get one of duncan or taranto if I were to get one of mundy/greene. However i am worried about both mundy and greene because mundy hasnt scored over 92 in his last 7 games and greene is highly unreliable

[dylanclements]

Another question I have is degoey vs mundy/greene (have limited cash and will only have 1 trade left after this week). If I do with one of mundy or greene it means i wont be able to afford JPK

Depends on who you get instead of JPK. Henderson and Mundy is what I'd probably do - suspect that won't be a popular opinion  ;D

id get one of duncan or taranto if I were to get one of mundy/greene. However i am worried about both mundy and greene because mundy hasnt scored over 92 in his last 7 games and greene is highly unreliable

Mundy is a bit of a concern, but I wouldn't go Greene. As likely as not to miss games even with only a handful left

[tommy10]

Duncan vs JPK?

Duncan imo. JPK may miss games

Extending on that Would you pay an extra 50k + for a Shuey or Treloar type over Duncan or Merrett for that matter?

Yeah I would go Treloar for that matter...but needs 40 touches for a decent score. Been pretty solid though.

[dylanclements]

I've just about decided on trading J Kelly. Have the DPP and need a fwd, so who's the pick:

Dunkley v Marshall