Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[HappyDEZ]

Pick two out of T.Kelly, Dunkley, Sloan
T.Kelly is my first choice, then it's really out of Dunkley or Sloan I think.

There a probs a fair few MIDs that can match Sloane. Not too many FWDs can match Telly & Dunkley so the 2 x FWDs for mine. Plus the fact Sloane aint playing this week.

[Wanderer]

Pick two out of T.Kelly, Dunkley, Sloan
T.Kelly is my first choice, then it's really out of Dunkley or Sloan I think.

There a probs a fair few MIDs that can match Sloane. Not too many FWDs can match Telly & Dunkley so the 2 x FWDs for mine. Plus the fact Sloane aint playing this week.

Yes, I agree. How about if I was to ask who would average more for the rest of the year, Dunkley or Sloan (forget about Sloane's bye)?

[Ricochet]

Stewart vs Sicily?

Very good question! I’m leaning towards Stewart atm myself .

I'm struggling with this one too and am leaning towards Stewart because Sicily sometimes being asked to play forward.

Sicily forward may be a once off, considering the move completely failed.

yeh Roughy back will = Sic back to def.

I think I'm leaning towards Stewart too

[HappyDEZ]

Pick two out of T.Kelly, Dunkley, Sloan
T.Kelly is my first choice, then it's really out of Dunkley or Sloan I think.

There a probs a fair few MIDs that can match Sloane. Not too many FWDs can match Telly & Dunkley so the 2 x FWDs for mine. Plus the fact Sloane aint playing this week.

Yes, I agree. How about if I was to ask who would average more for the rest of the year, Dunkley or Sloan (forget about Sloane's bye)?

Personally, of the 3, I like Dunkley best. Mainly due to the fact he is the least likely of the 3 to suffer from close attention. Sloane has/will continue to cop it but has coped well thus far + some late goals in recent games has helped. Considering 2 of them are top 6 FWDs & the other is super value atm I don't think you can too far wrong either way.

[_wato]

Marshall v Mundy

[Dmoney$]

Walters Or Caleb Daniel?

[batt]

Walters Or Caleb Daniel?

Walters.  He may have slightly more downside but the upside more than makes up for it.

Marshall v Mundy

Marshall, but for the opposite reasons.  Higher floor.  Mundy's ooooold and has a ginormous BE.

[Bully]

Walters Or Caleb Daniel?

Walters.  He may have slightly more downside but the upside more than makes up for it.

Marshall v Mundy

Marshall, but for the opposite reasons.  Higher floor.  Mundy's ooooold and has a ginormous BE.

Mundy due to drop below 450k, better to wait & perhaps bring in as M9/F7

[Dmoney$]

Clayton Oliver vs Marcus Bontempelli?

[Fid]

Clayton Oliver vs Marcus Bontempelli?

Bont

[dylanclements]

What do people think on ranking Neale, M Crouch, Bont, and Oliver?

Edit: That's M Crouch!

[strikeforce]

What do people think on ranking Neale, Crouch, Bont, and Oliver?

Neale by a mile, Bont, Oliver then a long way down crouch

[MontyJnr]

Walters Or Caleb Daniel?

I've been back and forth on this tough decision all week, but I've settled on Walters - purely for his high scoring ceiling, decent CBA numbers, easy draw and just the fact that he is generally an exciting player to cheer on.

His questionable durability, low scoring floor and the fact he was never averaged over 88 in a season are the risks - but I'm willing to take a punt that he has finally taken that next step to superstar status.

[Wanderer]

Clayton Oliver vs Marcus Bontempelli?

Bont

I would choose Oliver due to being a perma mid vs Bont who will be pushed forward more.

[Bully]

Clayton Oliver vs Marcus Bontempelli?

Bont

I would choose Oliver due to being a perma mid vs Bont who will be pushed forward more.

Tend to agree, with Gardner out & Schache looking like he's out of his depth the chances of a return to the forward line have increased markedly. This was the factor behind my Sloane vs Bont decision.