Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[tkringle]

Keep Hore or B Smith for D6? One will be turned into Ryan this week.

Thinking Hore as it helps with my round 14 bye situation.

[MontyJnr]

Keep Hore or B Smith for D6? One will be turned into Ryan this week.

Thinking Hore as it helps with my round 14 bye situation.

Hore should go this week - I wouldn't want to keep either as my D6 though.

[MontyJnr]

Sicily or Luke Ryan?

[Bully]

Keep Hore or B Smith for D6? One will be turned into Ryan this week.

Thinking Hore as it helps with my round 14 bye situation.

Hore should go this week - I wouldn't want to keep either as my D6 though.

People so desperate to get rid of Hore? BE of 39 & has dipped below 80 only once in his past 8 games. I'll be holding until I can switch to Hurn, based on projections that may only cost 100k.

[js19]

Keep Hore or B Smith for D6? One will be turned into Ryan this week.

Thinking Hore as it helps with my round 14 bye situation.

Hore should go this week - I wouldn't want to keep either as my D6 though.

People so desperate to get rid of Hore? BE of 39 & has dipped below 80 only once in his past 8 games. I'll be holding until I can switch to Hurn, based on projections that may only cost 100k.

It’s tricky, because keeping Hore would most likely leave me one short this week, and can’t really afford that. Would love to keep him though.

I’ve now only got BSmith to upgrade, although he is quite the liability. Hoping he can hold tight until Whitfield returns.

[tommy10]

Sicily or Luke Ryan?

Am stumped for this one too. Sicily really cheap, Ryan floor is higher  ::)
Thinking Sicily and save the extra $30k

[Hazza09]

if you had 18 exactly this week and that was going Smith - Ryan (keeping Hore) would that be a viable trade?

I see B Smith having to go once the Adelaide bye is over.

I would keep Hore over B Smith in a heartbeat!

[MontyJnr]

if you had 18 exactly this week and that was going Smith - Ryan (keeping Hore) would that be a viable trade?

I see B Smith having to go once the Adelaide bye is over.

I would keep Hore over B Smith in a heartbeat!

Yeah I would keep Hore over Smith if you can still field 18 this week.

I think Hore will start to slow down at some point, but yeah until then just keep him!

[tkringle]

if you had 18 exactly this week and that was going Smith - Ryan (keeping Hore) would that be a viable trade?

I see B Smith having to go once the Adelaide bye is over.

I would keep Hore over B Smith in a heartbeat!

This is the move I am going to make.

[RoughRed]

Sicily or Luke Ryan?

Am stumped for this one too. Sicily really cheap, Ryan floor is higher  ::)
Thinking Sicily and save the extra $30k

I would take Ryan - higher floor and more reliable IMO.
Never sure when Sicily is going to have a brain fade and need a week or two "rest"

[smashbox]

Trade out Will Hayes or Bailey Scott

[Bully]

Trade out Will Hayes or Bailey Scott

Trade the bloke with the highest return (Hayes).

[MontyJnr]

Sicily or Luke Ryan?

Am stumped for this one too. Sicily really cheap, Ryan floor is higher  ::)
Thinking Sicily and save the extra $30k

I would take Ryan - higher floor and more reliable IMO.
Never sure when Sicily is going to have a brain fade and need a week or two "rest"

Tend to agree

How certain are we that Luke Ryan's role won't change with Pearce out of the side though?

[petefisker]

Marshall vs C.Daniel  :o

?

[whynot102]

Dursma to Ryan or BCrouch to Fyfe/Kelly