Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Bully]

Marshall v Gray

Both really solid selections IMO, probably grab Marshall as the known quantity, sole ruck duties won't be changing anytime soon. High ceiling & high floor, hard to see any downside. He's also played his Gawn/Grundy matches so things should get a bit easier.

[Bones Bombers]

Marshall v Gray

Both really solid selections IMO, probably grab Marshall as the known quantity, sole ruck duties won't be changing anytime soon. High ceiling & high floor, hard to see any downside. He's also played his Gawn/Grundy matches so things should get a bit easier.

+1 for Marshall. Should be more consistent.

Wilkie to Cunnington
Or
Hore to Josh Kelly

Won’t know if Hore is named till after Cunnington plays. He could then be a late out anyway, who knows.
I’d have 18 if I traded Hore, 19 if I keep him.
Whichever one I keep this week will most likely be traded to Bewley next week anyway.

Really keen on Kelly but Cunnington could possibly match him for the rest of the season anyway.
Doing my head in so any help would be appreciated.

[Bully]

Marshall v Gray

Both really solid selections IMO, probably grab Marshall as the known quantity, sole ruck duties won't be changing anytime soon. High ceiling & high floor, hard to see any downside. He's also played his Gawn/Grundy matches so things should get a bit easier.

+1 for Marshall. Should be more consistent.

Wilkie to Cunnington
Or
Hore to Josh Kelly

Won’t know if Hore is named till after Cunnington plays. He could then be a late out anyway, who knows.
I’d have 18 if I traded Hore, 19 if I keep him.
Whichever one I keep this week will most likely be traded to Bewley next week anyway.

Really keen on Kelly but Cunnington could possibly match him for the rest of the season anyway.
Doing my head in so any help would be appreciated.

Grab Kelly, much bigger upside, wouldn't surprise to see another big 150+ around the corner.

[Bones Bombers]

Marshall v Gray

Both really solid selections IMO, probably grab Marshall as the known quantity, sole ruck duties won't be changing anytime soon. High ceiling & high floor, hard to see any downside. He's also played his Gawn/Grundy matches so things should get a bit easier.

+1 for Marshall. Should be more consistent.

Wilkie to Cunnington
Or
Hore to Josh Kelly

Won’t know if Hore is named till after Cunnington plays. He could then be a late out anyway, who knows.
I’d have 18 if I traded Hore, 19 if I keep him.
Whichever one I keep this week will most likely be traded to Bewley next week anyway.

Really keen on Kelly but Cunnington could possibly match him for the rest of the season anyway.
Doing my head in so any help would be appreciated.

Grab Kelly, much bigger upside, wouldn't surprise to see another big 150+ around the corner.

Those big scores would look really good in my side.
Have got the ranking up to 365 so thinking I should try to bring in the best from here.

[js19]

Marshall v Gray

Both really solid selections IMO, probably grab Marshall as the known quantity, sole ruck duties won't be changing anytime soon. High ceiling & high floor, hard to see any downside. He's also played his Gawn/Grundy matches so things should get a bit easier.

+1 for Marshall. Should be more consistent.

Wilkie to Cunnington
Or
Hore to Josh Kelly

Won’t know if Hore is named till after Cunnington plays. He could then be a late out anyway, who knows.
I’d have 18 if I traded Hore, 19 if I keep him.
Whichever one I keep this week will most likely be traded to Bewley next week anyway.

Really keen on Kelly but Cunnington could possibly match him for the rest of the season anyway.
Doing my head in so any help would be appreciated.

Grab Kelly, much bigger upside, wouldn't surprise to see another big 150+ around the corner.

Those big scores would look really good in my side.
Have got the ranking up to 365 so thinking I should try to bring in the best from here.

Yeah, I’m worried about Kelly’s durability, but can’t look past the big scores. Kelly and Neale come in for me this week

[Bones Bombers]

Marshall v Gray

Both really solid selections IMO, probably grab Marshall as the known quantity, sole ruck duties won't be changing anytime soon. High ceiling & high floor, hard to see any downside. He's also played his Gawn/Grundy matches so things should get a bit easier.

+1 for Marshall. Should be more consistent.

Wilkie to Cunnington
Or
Hore to Josh Kelly

Won’t know if Hore is named till after Cunnington plays. He could then be a late out anyway, who knows.
I’d have 18 if I traded Hore, 19 if I keep him.
Whichever one I keep this week will most likely be traded to Bewley next week anyway.

Really keen on Kelly but Cunnington could possibly match him for the rest of the season anyway.
Doing my head in so any help would be appreciated.

Grab Kelly, much bigger upside, wouldn't surprise to see another big 150+ around the corner.

Those big scores would look really good in my side.
Have got the ranking up to 365 so thinking I should try to bring in the best from here.

Yeah, I’m worried about Kelly’s durability, but can’t look past the big scores. Kelly and Neale come in for me this week

Yeah that's something I've thought about. Spending the extra 100k and then having him get injured. The interview the other day didn't really make it any easier. Saying they are managing his load. Cunnington may be durable but his scoring history is no where near Kelly's.

[whynot102]

Cunnington or Pendles

[Bones Bombers]

Cunnington or Pendles

I'd say Cunnington.
How are you for the round 13 bye if you went Pendles?

[batt]

Not really a player one so prepared for it to be deleted:

Come out of the byes with Clarke/Baker M8 but hit the rest of my upgrade targets (Lloyd, Neale the main ones)

vs

Come out of the byes full "premo" but take 3 or 4 cheaper options.

[Bones Bombers]

Not really a player one so prepared for it to be deleted:

Come out of the byes with Clarke/Baker M8 but hit the rest of my upgrade targets (Lloyd, Neale the main ones)

vs

Come out of the byes full "premo" but take 3 or 4 cheaper options.

Lloyd and Neale. Long way to go yet.

[frenzy]

Not really a player one so prepared for it to be deleted:

Come out of the byes with Clarke/Baker M8 but hit the rest of my upgrade targets (Lloyd, Neale the main ones)

vs

Come out of the byes full "premo" but take 3 or 4 cheaper options.

option2, there's some great value to be had.

[whynot102]

At this stage with Cunnington 17 17 prior to trades not ideal

Cunnington or Pendles

I'd say Cunnington.
How are you for the round 13 bye if you went Pendles?

[Bully]

Not really a player one so prepared for it to be deleted:

Come out of the byes with Clarke/Baker M8 but hit the rest of my upgrade targets (Lloyd, Neale the main ones)

vs

Come out of the byes full "premo" but take 3 or 4 cheaper options.

Hmmm, I'm not an advocate of having a rookie at M8 so I'd be inclined to take option 2, but in saying that you would need to stipulate the cheapies you are chasing. The guys I have on the shortlist are Bont, Sloane, Mundy (in 2 weeks), Gray & Sicily. If you grab 3 of those guys I think you win in the short run.

[Rusty00]

Trade Hayes or B Scott?

[Bully]

Trade Hayes or B Scott?

Hayes, the extra $$ could enable an extra upgrade.