Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[dmac07]

Lloyd vs Macrae? Getting in early for next week. Both should be 590k ish. Will swing Duursma so can get either.

[Qwerty7698]

Caleb daniel vs Zak Jones

[crowls]

Caleb daniel vs Zak Jones

whichever suits your byes.   no point splitting hairs on avgs if you end up with donut over byes

[Rusty00]

Butters, Atkins or Constable - which one to be traded out this week?

[HappyDEZ]

Butters, Atkins or Constable - which one to be traded out this week?

I don't have Butters but I traded out Cons ahead of Atkins. Not that I wanted to but Atkins may still make $10-30K this week & Cons is just a ?

[crowls]

Butters, Atkins or Constable - which one to be traded out this week?

I don't have Butters but I traded out Cons ahead of Atkins. Not that I wanted to but Atkins may still make $10-30K this week & Cons is just a ?

agree,  was trading butters reversed and constable slaughtered.

[TableKing]

Laird v Rich

Ok fanfooty family. Please here me out here.

Rich is the perrenial burner of all coaches out there.

With the new kick in rules, he is the designated taker for Lions and has a license to attack where he can.
6 rounds through and he is averaging a strong 98. Worst game so far is a 76 v essendon. He is currently $50k cheeper to Laird and in the world of SC at this time of year, i could get a Boak in next week if i go down the Rich path.

Dont need to build a case for Laird. He is back jn form now and wigh Mileara out he will hit his 100s.

What are your thought...? Do you think with the rules and the Lions style of play is Rich's 98 ave sustainable?

Only 5% hold Rich as well. Is it too much of a chance maybe...should i just stick to the players we kmow will get us points ie Laird and look to bring in Rich late at the highrr premium??

[crowls]

Laird v Rich

Ok fanfooty family. Please here me out here.

Rich is the perrenial burner of all coaches out there.

With the new kick in rules, he is the designated taker for Lions and has a license to attack where he can.
6 rounds through and he is averaging a strong 98. Worst game so far is a 76 v essendon. He is currently $50k cheeper to Laird and in the world of SC at this time of year, i could get a Boak in next week if i go down the Rich path.

Dont need to build a case for Laird. He is back jn form now and wigh Mileara out he will hit his 100s.

What are your thought...? Do you think with the rules and the Lions style of play is Rich's 98 ave sustainable?

Only 5% hold Rich as well. Is it too much of a chance maybe...should i just stick to the players we kmow will get us points ie Laird and look to bring in Rich late at the highrr premium??

If Rich gets you Boak then that is significant upside over laird.   Milera may be back in 4 weeks and laird goes back to low 90s again and you sacrificed opportunity for Boak.    Rich/Boak has more going for it.

[Thewizz71]

Laird v Rich

Ok fanfooty family. Please here me out here.

Rich is the perrenial burner of all coaches out there.

With the new kick in rules, he is the designated taker for Lions and has a license to attack where he can.
6 rounds through and he is averaging a strong 98. Worst game so far is a 76 v essendon. He is currently $50k cheeper to Laird and in the world of SC at this time of year, i could get a Boak in next week if i go down the Rich path.

Dont need to build a case for Laird. He is back jn form now and wigh Mileara out he will hit his 100s.

What are your thought...? Do you think with the rules and the Lions style of play is Rich's 98 ave sustainable?

Only 5% hold Rich as well. Is it too much of a chance maybe...should i just stick to the players we kmow will get us points ie Laird and look to bring in Rich late at the highrr premium??

If Rich gets you Boak then that is significant upside over laird.   Milera may be back in 4 weeks and laird goes back to low 90s again and you sacrificed opportunity for Boak.    Rich/Boak has more going for it.

What if it were Laird/Caleb?

[Bluesalltheway]

Trade 2 of Constable, Scrimshaw and Collins (trades the same either way)

[whynot102]

Rich vs Daniel

[tommy10]

Rich vs Daniel

Daniel

[jfitty]

I really need to make a defensive downgrade this week, just with my plan for the next fortnight:

Answerth vs Young vs Joyce vs Lockhart?

[imjusflexin]

I really need to make a defensive downgrade this week, just with my plan for the next fortnight:

Answerth vs Young vs Joyce vs Lockhart?

As of right now there is no correct answer.

- Answerth big Q marks because of the injured Lions waiting in the wings
- Young low scoring and although playing fine you can't trust Bevo.
- Joyce very low JS, could stick around but could be out in a week.
- Lockhart honestly should've been dropped already which means maybe they like him a lot, but I have him and I wish I didn't so I wouldn't bring him in.

If I had to pick one it'd be Answerth but I just simply wouldn't. I would kill for a defensive downgrade this week but with these options I just don't want to risk it.

Burgess, Scott, Setterfield, Balta on my bench are killing me, don't want another one.

[jfitty]

Thanks for the input!

Reading those names out again made me nervous, so think I'll do a re-think of the trades and take another look at Answerth in particular. If he survives Andrews coming back next week, happy days.