Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[LaHug]

Jake Lloyd or Boak in this week,
have same fields regardless of which one i get as moore is the swinger

I would get neither. Must be 5 or 6 players ahead of both. Telly, Fyfe, Caleb, Laird. Ok that's only 4 but still. Rich maybe.

You're kidding right? The top defender and the top forward?

I think he's more referring to the value of those listed, over the top dollar price of Lloyd and Boak.

I'd go Lloyd

I think it depends on if you're going for league or overall. I wouldn't get either of them right now if chasing overall and having ground to make up because they teams ahead of you already have them (and got them cheaper). However, if you're just trying to win league matches or you're already near the top of overall, they make the most sense.

I only care about overall and my team has sucked to start the year so I'm going PODs as an all or nothing approach. For me, it makes no sense to get Lloyd or Boak until they're at their cheapest. I should've gone Daniel last week but went Walters for the really big POD and it looks poor after one week... Tempted by Rich this week but might just get Laird as the top teams typically went Lloyd and Whitfield over Laird.

[HappyDEZ]

Jake Lloyd or Boak in this week,
have same fields regardless of which one i get as moore is the swinger

I would get neither. Must be 5 or 6 players ahead of both. Telly, Fyfe, Caleb, Laird. Ok that's only 4 but still. Rich maybe.

You're kidding right? The top defender and the top forward?

I think he's more referring to the value of those listed, over the top dollar price of Lloyd and Boak.

I'd go Lloyd

Yeah I did mean in relation to value. Cheers jfitty. I probably shouldn't post 1/2 cut.

[Hazza09]

What about Fyfe (564K) or T Kelly (476K)

Both have lowish Breakevens!

Finding it hard to decide!

[HappyDEZ]

What about Fyfe (564K) or T Kelly (476K)

Both have lowish Breakevens!

Finding it hard to decide!

Yep tough decision. Both appear the best trade in targets for their position this week along with Laird in DEF. My decision was between Laird & Telly & I have gone with Telly at this stage because it better suits my 22 so I suppose it may come down to how many  spuddish rooks you have on field & where best to turf one.

[Hazza09]

What about Fyfe (564K) or T Kelly (476K)

Both have lowish Breakevens!

Finding it hard to decide!

Yep tough decision. Both appear the best trade in targets for their position this week along with Laird in DEF. My decision was between Laird & Telly & I have gone with Telly at this stage because it better suits my 22 so I suppose it may come down to how many  spuddish rooks you have on field & where best to turf one.

Cheers mate!

Well it comes down to this. Schrimshaw would have to go for Answerth to bring in Fyfe and Atkins would have to go for T Kelly.
Cousins is going regardless as the other trade.

Team is

Whitfield, Smith, Williams, Laird, Duursma, Hore ( Schrimshaw, Burgess )
Cripps, Neale, Oliver, Coniglio, Sheed, Walsh, Constable, Ross ( Cousins, Atkins, Scott )
Gawn, Grundy, ( ROB )
Danger, Heeney, Boak, Moore, Rooze, Drew ( Pettretuelle, Bines )

[HappyDEZ]

Front 6 looks decent so I reckon Fyfe. Also gives decent cover on the bench if Conigs doesn't get up or even maybe a Ross/Cons loophole if Cogs plays & Scott doesn't come back in. I would consider looping Rozee or Drew (probs Rozee) too only because Ports have Coll away & Petrol has GC at home.

[Judd Magic]

Hurn, Sicily or Laird?  ???

[HoleMeal]

Hurn, Sicily or Laird?  ???

[tommy10]

Hurn, Sicily or Laird?  ???

Hurn

[Mongoose528]

Answerth Vs Young (To downgrade Clark)

[westfisker]

Caleb vs J.Cameron

[GoLions]

Answerth Vs Young (To downgrade Clark)

Wait a week on Answerth

[GoLions]

Caleb vs J.Cameron

I'd go Caleb

[LaHug]

Caleb vs J.Cameron

I'd go Caleb

With GWS's run into the byes, Cameron could be an incredible POD. Of course, he has the same bye as a lot of premiums while Daniel doesn't but I could see him averaging 110+ over the next 6 weeks.

[strikeforce]

Caleb vs J.Cameron

I'd go Caleb

With GWS's run into the byes, Cameron could be an incredible POD. Of course, he has the same bye as a lot of premiums while Daniel doesn't but I could see him averaging 110+ over the next 6 weeks.

Im grabbing Cameron this week. Like you said, look at his run. Josh kelly @ 575 wil come in net week also