Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[LaHug]

Has to Sicily right now. Simpson's last two weeks were against inferior opposition in a win and what should have been a win. I don't know if he'll score well in Carlton's losses any more. Age might finally have caught up.

Thinking one this week, one next anyway. To be honest, Simmo hasn't looked bad at all. Newman has been stealing some of his kick-ins and without being able to play a loose as often with the 6-6-6 we can't manufacture him behind the ball as easily. I do think the back 6 are settling in nicely now.

They legit both have the same BE (79), one is just 70k cheaper and both don't have great scoring history against the other team. I'm likely to take your advice because that's where my gut is going for this week as well. No Jed Lamb to make Sicily agro and not concentrate on the ball. It also gives me another week to look at Simmo

If Simmo gets 95+ this week, I'll probably bring him in too tbh. But I'd want to see more than I've seen so far to get him this week...

Another one to add to the mix is Daniel. So Daniel vs Sicily?

Definitely Sicily over Daniel. I'm worried that what your boys did to him last week is going to lead to a role change sooner rather than later...

[Mat0369]

Sweet thanks

[LaHug]

Sweet thanks

Good luck :)

[Mat0369]

Went Sicily in the end

[Money Shot]

Tim Kelly vs Caleb Daniel

[Judd Magic]

Tim Kelly vs Caleb Daniel

T.Kelly imo.

You know what you are going to get with him every week as he is one of Geelongs main mids.

Daniel could have a role change like others have stated.

[Judd Magic]

Sicily vs Laird.  ???

[TommyC]

Tim Kelly vs Caleb Daniel

The one that is giving me headaches, I chose Daniel.
But I'm not 100% as of yet.

[WizzFizz]

Jake Lloyd or Boak in this week,
have same fields regardless of which one i get as moore is the swinger

[Bully]

Jake Lloyd or Boak in this week,
have same fields regardless of which one i get as moore is the swinger

I'd get Lloyd despite the higher BE, think Boak will find it a bit tougher against the Pies.

[HappyDEZ]

Jake Lloyd or Boak in this week,
have same fields regardless of which one i get as moore is the swinger

I would get neither. Must be 5 or 6 players ahead of both. Telly, Fyfe, Caleb, Laird. Ok that's only 4 but still. Rich maybe.

[WizzFizz]

Jake Lloyd or Boak in this week,
have same fields regardless of which one i get as moore is the swinger

I would get neither. Must be 5 or 6 players ahead of both. Telly, Fyfe, Caleb, Laird. Ok that's only 4 but still. Rich maybe.

Dont you think Boak is worth 100k more than rich / daniel?

[HappyDEZ]

Jake Lloyd or Boak in this week,
have same fields regardless of which one i get as moore is the swinger

I would get neither. Must be 5 or 6 players ahead of both. Telly, Fyfe, Caleb, Laird. Ok that's only 4 but still. Rich maybe.

Dont you think Boak is worth 100k more than rich / daniel?

Not sure. Just would not pay absolute peak dollar for Boak that's all.

[coglan13]

Jake Lloyd or Boak in this week,
have same fields regardless of which one i get as moore is the swinger

I would get neither. Must be 5 or 6 players ahead of both. Telly, Fyfe, Caleb, Laird. Ok that's only 4 but still. Rich maybe.

You're kidding right? The top defender and the top forward?

[jfitty]

Jake Lloyd or Boak in this week,
have same fields regardless of which one i get as moore is the swinger

I would get neither. Must be 5 or 6 players ahead of both. Telly, Fyfe, Caleb, Laird. Ok that's only 4 but still. Rich maybe.

You're kidding right? The top defender and the top forward?

I think he's more referring to the value of those listed, over the top dollar price of Lloyd and Boak.

I'd go Lloyd