Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[smashbox]

Worth going Dunkley to Mundy/Billings

[HoleMeal]

Worth going Dunkley to Mundy/Billings

vs the blues this week, give him 1 more week.

[HoleMeal]

Is B Crouch to Whitfield via Duursma a waste?

[Bully]

Is B Crouch to Whitfield via Duursma a waste?

Don't think it's a waste but I'd be more inclined to do Walsh to Whitfield next week, think Brad crouch will be very handy as the season progresses.

[AN1611]

Is B Crouch to Whitfield via Duursma a waste?

Don't think it's a waste but I'd be more inclined to do Walsh to Whitfield next week, think Brad crouch will be very handy as the season progresses.

Bit early to move on Sam Walsh given his scoring and BE I reckon

[Bully]

Is B Crouch to Whitfield via Duursma a waste?

Don't think it's a waste but I'd be more inclined to do Walsh to Whitfield next week, think Brad crouch will be very handy as the season progresses.

Bit early to move on Sam Walsh given his scoring and BE I reckon

BE is negative this week but won't be next week, reckon Walsh hits 450k & then stagnates. If he tons up this week then different story but I'm fully prepared to move him on if he scores around 70-80.

[js19]

Who should come in this week - Heeney vs Whitfield?

[HoleMeal]

Who should come in this week - Heeney vs Whitfield?

[SilverLion]

Greene replacement:

Marshall vs. Worpel vs. Hold and play Petrucelle

[Commander]

Greene replacement:

Marshall vs. Worpel vs. Hold and play Petrucelle

Marshall has more up side. Worpel for the safe 85-95

[no eye deer]

Greene replacement:

Marshall vs. Worpel vs. Hold and play Petrucelle

Marshall has more up side. Worpel for the safe 85-95

I took Worpel for Heeney a couple of weeks ago (yeah, I know!) Sort of wish I went Marshall. Looks good and can’t see Longer coming back. Bad form in the twos, plus Marshall going well.

Same dilemma.

Greene to ROB, Butters to Hore via Duursma, play Parker and Petrol on field until Setters is back.

Or

Greene to Marshall, Parker to ROB, Miss Hore and still play Petrol until Setters is back.

[LaHug]

Or hold Greene? I should have traded to Marshall last week but I'm not trading him now that I didn't. I'm hoping Max destroys Greene in the ruck and he flops big time...

[SilverLion]

Or hold Greene? I should have traded to Marshall last week but I'm not trading him now that I didn't. I'm hoping Max destroys Greene in the ruck and he flops big time...

[tommy10]

Or hold Greene? I should have traded to Marshall last week but I'm not trading him now that I didn't. I'm hoping Max destroys Greene in the ruck and he flops big time...

I’d be trading Maxxy if he doesn’t destroy “Greene” in the ruck  :P

[North Melbournes Finest]

Devon Smith > Heeney (bringing him back jesus) / Marshall / Billings / Daniel

Which one should I bring in? You would think Heeney would be the no brainer but my pride is probably getting in the way there.