Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[frenzy]

going to struggle with the one all week

Macrae + Parker + 150k in the bank

LDU + Kelly + 250k in the bank

Macrae and Parker, Maca another good capt option + Parker will make good cash

[HappyDEZ]

going to struggle with the one all week

Macrae + Parker + 150k in the bank

LDU + Kelly + 250k in the bank

man that is a tough decision.
both options have keepers in their positions and have plenty of money to make too.
I'd go option A, more points from your keeper and slightly more money from your cash cow

I like Option A too. Only because I think GWS admitted the other day that they have some work to do in the medical/player management space & may err on the side of caution until they catch up a little.

Sorry i should have stated it Tim Kelly the FWD

Oh. I still like option A. Like someone else typed Macrae is a C option. In fact if I had him it would def be Danger into Macrae this week + Parker looks set to make good money. I reckon he might enjoy the hard expanses of Optus for another 70+ against Freo hopefully.

[ubeaut]

going to struggle with the one all week

Macrae + Parker + 150k in the bank

LDU + Kelly + 250k in the bank

It's so close, maybe team structure should decide your answer, and what rookies would be fielded in each scenario.

[_wato]

Whitfield + LDU v Neale + Rozee

Mid and Defender positions

[ubeaut]

Whitfield + LDU v Neale + Rozee

Mid and Defender positions

Again it depends on structure and what rookies are fielded.
Can LDU keep up the scoring? If so option 1 could be better in terms of both cash gen and scoring.
On the other hand he could drop off, and option 2 nets u more points, with maybe slightly less cash gen(depending on Rozee)

I think Neale will beast it this year, and will be harder to get in than Whitfield down the track. So option 2 for me, just.

[_wato]

Whitfield + LDU v Neale + Rozee

Mid and Defender positions

Again it depends on structure and what rookies are fielded.
Can LDU keep up the scoring? If so option 1 could be better in terms of both cash gen and scoring.
On the other hand he could drop off, and option 2 nets u more points, with maybe slightly less cash gen(depending on Rozee)

I think Neale will beast it this year, and will be harder to get in than Whitfield down the track. So option 2 for me, just.

Exact two rookies as named. Rozee fills D4, Neale M3 or Whitfield D1, LDU M7

I agree with you 100%. Rozee probably not as safe but a 68 and 85 is still good scoring for a rookie and Neale outscores Whitfield by 10ppg+

Comes down to what LDU produces. I think he's primed and has a depleted Hawks midfield to play against this week. The 118 will be huge in his rolling average.

Other option I could do and follow the pack

Newman + Rockliff over other 2 options.

[Mongoose528]

Dusty -> LDU + Greene -> Boak/Worpel/Kelly (Any forward)

Vs

Dusty -> Lloyd via Duursma.

[crowls]

Dusty -> LDU + Greene -> Boak/Worpel/Kelly (Any forward)

Vs

Dusty -> Lloyd via Duursma.

option 1 for me.    think green will be managed throughout the year.

[Wanderer]

Mills doesn't look like he will get mid time so want to offload him. I already have Lloyd, Williams, Smith. I can afford any defender.

Laird vs Whitfield vs Crisp vs anybody else

Or should I trade down to one of the rookies I don't have, Scrimshaw or Collins?

[crowls]

Mills doesn't look like he will get mid time so want to offload him. I already have Lloyd, Williams, Smith. I can afford any defender.

Laird vs Whitfield vs Crisp vs anybody else

Or should I trade down to one of the rookies I don't have, Scrimshaw or Collins?

whitfield or crisp for me.  laird still needs watching.   more important to have mid rookies correct,  dont see scrim or collins as must haves

[LaHug]

Mills doesn't look like he will get mid time so want to offload him. I already have Lloyd, Williams, Smith. I can afford any defender.

Laird vs Whitfield vs Crisp vs anybody else

Or should I trade down to one of the rookies I don't have, Scrimshaw or Collins?

whitfield or crisp for me.  laird still needs watching.   more important to have mid rookies correct,  dont see scrim or collins as must haves

Whitfield is better than Crisp imo. They got smashed last week with Hutchings tagging Cogs over Whitfield (something I never thought would happen) and Whitfield scored 123. They now play the Tigers this week (the team that let Crisp score so much) at home. Whitfield will keep going big and won't get tagged going forward. Reckon he'll compete with Lloyd for best defender by year's end.

[miamis_finest]

Devon Dmith > Tim Kelly
Or
Heeney > Tim Kelly
Or
No trade

[LaHug]

Devon Dmith > Tim Kelly
Or
Heeney > Tim Kelly
Or
No trade

I'd trade Heeney out before I traded Smith. Heeney looks unfit, Smith's just playing with a team that doesn't care. Bombers should bounce back eventually and Smith will with them.

[Gambino]

Boak

v

Worpel + 80k in the bank

[HappyDEZ]

Boak

v

Worpel + 80k in the bank

Tough one. Personally I prefer Boak but I don't think you can go too far wrong with Worpel.