Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[TommyC]

Dusty to Macrae with $232,800 in the kitty

or

Dusty to B Crouch with $504,500 in the kitty


Macrae should not vary too much in price after this round

Macrae

[walloo44]

Asked a million times but Boak v Kelly. I’m leaning kelly because he’s shown he can do it in a full strength Geelong, but how does he cope with the tag? As for boak there’s the wines question not that I think wines will have a huge effect, but how big will that effect be.
Can even throw Warpel into the mix, locked into hawks midfield and if he averages 95 an absolute steal at the price

[Fid]

Asked a million times but Boak v Kelly. I’m leaning kelly because he’s shown he can do it in a full strength Geelong, but how does he cope with the tag? As for boak there’s the wines question not that I think wines will have a huge effect, but how big will that effect be.
Can even throw Warpel into the mix, locked into hawks midfield and if he averages 95 an absolute steal at the price

I've got both, but Kelly over Boak imo

[Bully]

Asked a million times but Boak v Kelly. I’m leaning kelly because he’s shown he can do it in a full strength Geelong, but how does he cope with the tag? As for boak there’s the wines question not that I think wines will have a huge effect, but how big will that effect be.
Can even throw Warpel into the mix, locked into hawks midfield and if he averages 95 an absolute steal at the price

Tough one but Boak has shown he can hit 100 (with Wines in the side), Kelly has only delivered one season at 93, Boak is also cheaper & has a smaller BE. Then there's the ownership 15% (Kelly) vs 3% (Boak).

[tommy10]

Dusty to Sloane, Greene (F4) to Worpel plus $35k
Or
Dusty to Rocky, Greene to Worpel plus $154k
Or
Dusty to Rocky, Greene to Kelly plus $40k

[crowls]

Asked a million times but Boak v Kelly. I’m leaning kelly because he’s shown he can do it in a full strength Geelong, but how does he cope with the tag? As for boak there’s the wines question not that I think wines will have a huge effect, but how big will that effect be.
Can even throw Warpel into the mix, locked into hawks midfield and if he averages 95 an absolute steal at the price

Tough one but Boak has shown he can hit 100 (with Wines in the side), Kelly has only delivered one season at 93, Boak is also cheaper & has a smaller BE. Then there's the ownership 15% (Kelly) vs 3% (Boak).

leave my mate boak alone.    very happy boak starter

[Keeper27]

Boak + Whitfield + $12K

or

Lloyd + Parker +$305K

[Mongoose528]

Boak + Whitfield + $12K

or

Lloyd + Parker +$305K

Lloyd + Parker. At this stage of the competition, I'd favour money generation and hence pick Parker, who's about to make some serious coin.

[no eye deer]

Greetings to all for another season of madness!  ;D


Worpel vs Daniel?

[LaHug]

Greetings to all for another season of madness!  ;D


Worpel vs Daniel?

Worpel. As much as I'd love to say Daniel, there are concerns around his role when JJ comes back.

[Holz]

going to struggle with the one all week

Macrae + Parker + 150k in the bank

LDU + Kelly + 250k in the bank

[Keeper27]

going to struggle with the one all week

Macrae + Parker + 150k in the bank

LDU + Kelly + 250k in the bank

man that is a tough decision.
both options have keepers in their positions and have plenty of money to make too.
I'd go option A, more points from your keeper and slightly more money from your cash cow

[HappyDEZ]

going to struggle with the one all week

Macrae + Parker + 150k in the bank

LDU + Kelly + 250k in the bank

man that is a tough decision.
both options have keepers in their positions and have plenty of money to make too.
I'd go option A, more points from your keeper and slightly more money from your cash cow

I like Option A too. Only because I think GWS admitted the other day that they have some work to do in the medical/player management space & may err on the side of caution until they catch up a little.

[Holz]

going to struggle with the one all week

Macrae + Parker + 150k in the bank

LDU + Kelly + 250k in the bank

man that is a tough decision.
both options have keepers in their positions and have plenty of money to make too.
I'd go option A, more points from your keeper and slightly more money from your cash cow

I like Option A too. Only because I think GWS admitted the other day that they have some work to do in the medical/player management space & may err on the side of caution until they catch up a little.

Sorry i should have stated it Tim Kelly the FWD

[no eye deer]

going to struggle with the one all week

Macrae + Parker + 150k in the bank

LDU + Kelly + 250k in the bank

man that is a tough decision.
both options have keepers in their positions and have plenty of money to make too.
I'd go option A, more points from your keeper and slightly more money from your cash cow

I like Option A too. Only because I think GWS admitted the other day that they have some work to do in the medical/player management space & may err on the side of caution until they catch up a little.

Sorry i should have stated it Tim Kelly the FWD

Still option A, unless you have a plan in place for the extra 100k option B will get you. More money to be made off Parker and Macrae a captains option also.