Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[jbjimmyjb]

Crispy vs Rich.
Need to get Mill out of my side ASAP

Crisp all day.
Never left my team all preseason, is basically a 100k cheaper Lloyd with the benefit of being a POD.
His only flaw is his ball use, sometimes leaves a lot to be desired, but he has a great floor (as do all Collingwood players)

[YoungGun]

Mundy to Boak v Worpel v Daniel

[quinny88]

Mundy to Boak v Worpel v Daniel

Boak. Has history on his side

[js19]

Whitfield v T Kelly?

[Keeper27]

Shaw & Heeney OUT - Lloyd & Dahlhouse/Daniel + $6K

or

Shaw & Heeney OUT - Lloyd & Parker + $307K

(parker the only rookie i dont have)

[frenzy]

Whitfield v T Kelly?

Can't go wrong with either, so what I usually do is pick the one that suits my byes.

would you bring Rocky or Libba in if you had a hole to fill this week. I could turn Ridley into one of these, with a little DPP'ing.

[js19]

Whitfield v T Kelly?

Can't go wrong with either, so what I usually do is pick the one that suits my byes.

would you bring Rocky or Libba in if you had a hole to fill this week. I could turn Ridley into one of these, with a little DPP'ing.

Cheers, I’ll probably have both before the byes (hopefully)!

I’ve got Rocky but would pick Libba tbh. Same injury risk, but Libba’s role is set in stone. Rocky has Wines to come back, and although I don’t think it will kill him it brings some uncertainty.

Libba won’t get tagged, Rocky does, and the extra 105k wouldn’t go astray...

[justaverage]

Libba or LDU

Pretty confident Libba will average around the 100 mark and would still need an upgrade down the track, but should steadily rise in price.

LDU scoring unknown but seems to be tracking nicely, has a great BE and will make the dollars. The big factor here being the $100k left over for first upgrade in a few weeks time.

[Brikett]

Rockliff and 210k or Fyfe

Obviously Fyfe the better player and will average 10+ a game more but Rockliff has looked super impressive in the two games so far.

400k for someone that can potentially get you a 105 average is really tempting

Please someone talk me out of getting him

[Ringo]

Rockliff and 210k or Fyfe

Obviously Fyfe the better player and will average 10+ a game more but Rockliff has looked super impressive in the two games so far.

400k for someone that can potentially get you a 105 average is really tempting

Please someone talk me out of getting him

Rocky may cop a hard run with role from Robbo this week given his start to the season, We seen how he slowed when run with started last week so be wary.

[js19]

Greene replacement?

Rozee v Scrimshaw v Miers?

Will probably need to be fielded for a couple of weeks

[TurtlesTerriers]

Crispy vs Rich.
Need to get Mill out of my side ASAP

Crisp all day.
Never left my team all preseason, is basically a 100k cheaper Lloyd with the benefit of being a POD.
His only flaw is his ball use, sometimes leaves a lot to be desired, but he has a great floor (as do all Collingwood players)

Hmmm good food for thought but to throw a curve ball.
Crispy vs Kelly as I can dpp Moore

[SilverLion]

Mundy gone, was choosing between him and Boak pre-season so leaning to Boak but....

Mundy to Boak or T Kelly?

Boak only because he's cheaper and had the better bye.



Worpel vs. Daniel (Greene replacement if he doesn't get up)

I had Daniel and Boak swapping places all preseason before going with neither of them and getting an extra mid premium. Obviously not the right call with Greene and forward rookies... Because of that, I want to get at least one of them in this week.

For you, SL, I'd go Daniel. Watching today, his role is what I thought it might be when I was considering him and I can't see why he won't average 90.

For me, if I do go for one of Boak/Daniel, which should I get?

Tough one, I'd probably go Daniel, cheaper and not sure the effect that Wines coming back will have on Boak.

[Fid]

Dusty to Macrae with $232,800 in the kitty

or

Dusty to B Crouch with $504,500 in the kitty


Macrae should not vary too much in price after this round

[TomK]

Dusty to Macrae with $232,800 in the kitty

or

Dusty to B Crouch with $504,500 in the kitty


Macrae should not vary too much in price after this round

Macrae