Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Jimmykidd]

Mundy gone, was choosing between him and Boak pre-season so leaning to Boak but....

Mundy to Boak or T Kelly?

Boak only because he's cheaper and had the better bye.



Worpel vs. Daniel (Greene replacement if he doesn't get up)

Mundy to Boak/T.Kelly is my decision at the moment too.

Kelly has shown he can match it with the star studded Geelong midfield.

Will Boak drop back to the 80's 90's when Wines returns? only averaged over 100 twice in his career.

[TommyC]

Option 1
Dusty -> Rockliff/Libba
Witherden -> Lloyd

Option 2
Dusty -> Macrae/Fyfe
Heeney -> Worpel

Option 3
Dusty -> Premium (<605k)
Heeney -> Kelly

[Jimmykidd]

Option 1
Dusty -> Rockliff/Libba
Witherden -> Lloyd

Option 2
Dusty -> Macrae/Fyfe
Heeney -> Worpel

Option 3
Dusty -> Premium (<605k)
Heeney -> Kelly

I'd do Option 2

[TommyC]

Option 1
Dusty -> Rockliff/Libba
Witherden -> Lloyd

Option 2
Dusty -> Macrae/Fyfe
Heeney -> Worpel

Option 3
Dusty -> Premium (<605k)
Heeney -> Kelly

I'd do Option 2

That's the one I was thinking, cheers  :)

[smashbox]

Boak vs Kelly or keep Dunkley?

[LaHug]

Boak vs Kelly or keep Dunkley?

Heart says Boak, brain says Kelly. What happens to Boak when Wines comes back in? Geelong mids are full strength right now so Kelly's role has no risk to it. He's simply a gun and I wish I'd started him.

[jfitty]

Boak vs Kelly or keep Dunkley?

I'd save a trade and keep Dunkley personally

[AN1611]

So under the assumption that Greene doesn't play this week, I am looking to move him on.

Have 495k to burn (without using the 2nd trade)

Considering - Boak vs Worpedo vs Caleb Daniels

Daniels - not sure what JJs return will do to his scoring. Will definitely affect his scoring, so probably last on my list
Boak - same as above with Wines
Worpedo - great role, but is only a 2nd year player so can he keep it up for a season

[Ricochet]

So under the assumption that Greene doesn't play this week, I am looking to move him on.

Have 495k to burn (without using the 2nd trade)

Considering - Boak vs Worpedo vs Caleb Daniels

Daniels - not sure what JJs return will do to his scoring. Will definitely affect his scoring, so probably last on my list
Boak - same as above with Wines
Worpedo - great role, but is only a 2nd year player so can he keep it up for a season

Boak

[MontyJnr]

Scrimshaw v Rozee

Whoever I choose will need to be trusted on field for the next few weeks.

[js19]

Scrimshaw v Rozee

Whoever I choose will need to be trusted on field for the next few weeks.

Rozee for mine. Looks the goods

Whitfield or Kelly + Rozee
Vs
Daniel + Newman

[LaHug]

Scrimshaw v Rozee

Whoever I choose will need to be trusted on field for the next few weeks.

Rozee for mine. Looks the goods

Whitfield or Kelly + Rozee
Vs
Daniel + Newman

First one and comfortably too.

[Gambino]

Worpel v Boak?

[TurtlesTerriers]

Crispy vs Rich.
Need to get Mill out of my side ASAP

[Ricochet]

Crispy vs Rich.
Need to get Mill out of my side ASAP

Crisp