Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[jfitty]

Macrae & B.Crouch (145k in the bank)

vs

Cogs & Dusty (100k in the bank)

I'd go Macrae and Crouch myself

[TommyC]

Macrae & B.Crouch (145k in the bank)

vs

Cogs & Dusty (100k in the bank)

I'd be tempted to go Cogs and Crouch and use the money elsewhere.

If you wouldn't mind looking at my team thread, I just made a new post where I made three trades.
Cheers.

[TommyC]

Macrae & B.Crouch (145k in the bank)

vs

Cogs & Dusty (100k in the bank)

2nd option. Rather have 2 keepers for sure.

This was my thinking.
And I still had enough cash to go Witherden -> Whitfield to strengthen my defense.

[TommyC]

Macrae & B.Crouch (145k in the bank)

vs

Cogs & Dusty (100k in the bank)

I'd go Macrae and Crouch myself

I had this combo for quite awhile but as I have a few uncertainties in other lines I am slightly leaning towards the second option.

[GoLions]

Macrae & B.Crouch (145k in the bank)

vs

Cogs & Dusty (100k in the bank)

I'd go Macrae and Crouch myself

I had this combo for quite awhile but as I have a few uncertainties in other lines I am slightly leaning towards the second option.

Can you go Macrae and Dusty, or just short?

[maygs]

Moore v Collins?

Which will score better and which will make the most money as I don't expect either to be keepers - or am I wrong about that as well?

[imjusflexin]

Moore v Collins?

Which will score better and which will make the most money as I don't expect either to be keepers - or am I wrong about that as well?

Neither keepers unless Moore over-performs..

As for cash generation, if Collins averages 70 until R12, he'll make about 150k. He could definitely score less though and then he'll make less, but he'll still be around 300k which is perfect for downgrading to a rookie mid-season.

If Moore averages 75 (my prediction) up to R12, he'll make 120k. But with his role he could easily average more.. Many have him scoring 80+.

[LaHug]

Macrae & B.Crouch (145k in the bank)

vs

Cogs & Dusty (100k in the bank)

I'd be tempted to go Cogs and Crouch and use the money elsewhere.

If you wouldn't mind looking at my team thread, I just made a new post where I made three trades.
Cheers.

Just had a quick look. I don't think you could use the extra cash of Dusty down to B. Crouch anywhere unless you wanted to upgrade B. Smith to Witherden. I guess that's it's own X vs Y for you... Dusty and Smith or Crouch and Witherden?

[Jalapeno]

Need help for my last couple:

Lyons vs B Crouch vs Steele

Witherden vs Andrews vs Ryan

Thanks guys

B Crouch and Andrews I reckon

Thanks mate

[TommyC]

Macrae & B.Crouch (145k in the bank)

vs

Cogs & Dusty (100k in the bank)

I'd be tempted to go Cogs and Crouch and use the money elsewhere.

If you wouldn't mind looking at my team thread, I just made a new post where I made three trades.
Cheers.

Just had a quick look. I don't think you could use the extra cash of Dusty down to B. Crouch anywhere unless you wanted to upgrade B. Smith to Witherden. I guess that's it's own X vs Y for you... Dusty and Smith or Crouch and Witherden?

I'd probably go Dusty & Smith. Dusty a premo, and smith has the potential for his scoring to increase.
Dusty and Smith seems much safer than two midpricers.
I like Withergoat and I had him in my team for a long time, however I'm just a little uncertain on him.

[TommyC]

Macrae & B.Crouch (145k in the bank)

vs

Cogs & Dusty (100k in the bank)

I'd go Macrae and Crouch myself

I had this combo for quite awhile but as I have a few uncertainties in other lines I am slightly leaning towards the second option.

Can you go Macrae and Dusty, or just short?

I was like $2,000 short  :o

[Holz]

Whitfield + Billings v Witherden + Kelly

[enzedder]

Whitfield + Billings v Witherden + Kelly

Witherden and Kelly. Both are in my team atm as is Whitfield. Billings is risky. The others are safe picks.

[TommyC]

Whitfield + Billings v Witherden + Kelly

Witherden and Kelly. Both are in my team atm as is Whitfield. Billings is risky. The others are safe picks.

[bkimm32]

Whitfield + Billings v Witherden + Kelly

Witherden and Kelly. Both are in my team atm as is Whitfield. Billings is risky. The others are safe picks.

Why is billings risky?