Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[_wato]

Oliver vs Fyfe for M2

Same question I'm having but for M3. Tough choice.

[AN1611]

Oliver vs Fyfe for M2

Same question I'm having but for M3. Tough choice.

On one hand Fyfe has no preseason behind him but he can still come out and drop monster scores.

Noticed that Oliver was starting to play a lot more up forward towards the backend of the season so not sure if thats something they will explore this year.

[Thewizz71]

Not so much X vs Y, but can we run both Oliver and Brayshaw?
See them being top 3 at Melb (along with Gawn), so am happy to run them both.
If I were to choose one, I would lean towards Oliver and bring IN BCrouch for Brayshaw. Thoughts?

[LaHug]

Andrews vs. Crisp for D2

Any reason why these two over Hurn?

Libba vs cousins

Libba comfortably unless you need the cash

Oliver vs Fyfe for M2

I reckon Oliver. Would rather wait and see on Fyfe's fitness.

Not so much X vs Y, but can we run both Oliver and Brayshaw?
See them being top 3 at Melb (along with Gawn), so am happy to run them both.
If I were to choose one, I would lean towards Oliver and bring IN BCrouch for Brayshaw. Thoughts?

I see no reason not to have both of them if it doesn't destroy your bye structure. I like Brayshaw but prefer Oliver and can't fit in an extra premium right now.

[bkimm32]

Andrews vs. Crisp for D2

I'm struggling on this atm too. That and Crouch v Cogs. The two selections left on my mind. Crisp/Crouch or Andrews/Cogs. Got the first atm

Had the same dilemma. Went with cogs. I just don't know where/how crouch improves on his 2016 average? He averaged like 30 odd disposals for the year? It's highly unlikely he goes much higher. His disposal % is still probably the same. Mostly handball... he isn't gonna kick much more goals.

Where as Conigs looks like he might go one step further increasing his all his raw numbers to become one of the best midfielders in the game if not the best.

That's how I see it anyhow

[AN1611]

Andrews vs. Crisp for D2

I'm struggling on this atm too. That and Crouch v Cogs. The two selections left on my mind. Crisp/Crouch or Andrews/Cogs. Got the first atm

Had the same dilemma. Went with cogs. I just don't know where/how crouch improves on his 2016 average? He averaged like 30 odd disposals for the year? It's highly unlikely he goes much higher. His disposal % is still probably the same. Mostly handball... he isn't gonna kick much more goals.

Where as Conigs looks like he might go one step further increasing his all his raw numbers to become one of the best midfielders in the game if not the best.

That's how I see it anyhow

I'm running cogz at M3 and I reckon he will average 110+. In saying that I have mcrouch at m5 but would pick cogz over mcrouch.

I reckon Crisp has the potential to push 100+ if he cleans up his DE. (Got him at D1 atm)

[strikeforce]

Brayshaw v Taranto v POD Marc Murphy?

I just think without the captaincy that Murphy might just play a quarter back role while still going into the mids. They want the ball in his hands

[TommyC]

Brayshaw v Taranto v POD Marc Murphy?

I just think without the captaincy that Murphy might just play a quarter back role while still going into the mids. They want the ball in his hands

Brayshaw, but I still think he is a much better pick for AF & DT, not SC.

[quinny88]

Laird vs Whitfield?

Both likely top 6 but who is better to start?

[Marstar]

Laird vs Whitfield?

Both likely top 6 but who is better to start?

Going with Laird for quiet comfort. To many whispers Whit could be played in different roles which brings uncertainty to expected output.

[quinny88]

Laird vs Whitfield?

Both likely top 6 but who is better to start?

Going with Laird for quiet comfort. To many whispers Whit could be played in different roles which brings uncertainty to expected output.

Have heard those whispers too but also whispers about Lairds output whit Smith and Milera play down back. Making it a hard call

[Marstar]

Laird vs Whitfield?

Both likely top 6 but who is better to start?

Going with Laird for quiet comfort. To many whispers Whit could be played in different roles which brings uncertainty to expected output.

Have heard those whispers too but also whispers about Lairds output whit Smith and Milera play down back. Making it a hard call

I meant more that Laird playing the same role he’s always played gives me more confidence of expected output (even if he gets some points stolen) than Whits who may play a less SC friendly role for points he won’t be able to make up.

[TexR74]

Josh Kelly vs Coniglio? And JJK vs Greene?

[LaHug]

Josh Kelly vs Coniglio? And JJK vs Greene?

Cogs and Greene

[Wanderer]

Dusty (M5) + Collins (D4 - Smith is D3) vs Libba (M5) + C.Mills (D3 - Smith is D4)

Can be Dusty or M.Crouch, but not enough cash for Coniglio