Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[GoLions]

Brayshaw, Liba and whitfield vs Oliver, B.Crouch and B.Smith

If i choose option 1, ill be starting my team with possibily 4 GWS keepers

What's the best def you could get with Oliver and Libba?

witherden or a ryan/hurley/howe type; although apart from Williams who i already have no one under 500k really appeals to me.

Oliver, Libba, Andrews. Lock it in.

[_wato]

Brayshaw, Liba and whitfield vs Oliver, B.Crouch and B.Smith

If i choose option 1, ill be starting my team with possibily 4 GWS keepers

What's the best def you could get with Oliver and Libba?

witherden or a ryan/hurley/howe type; although apart from Williams who i already have no one under 500k really appeals to me.

Oliver, Libba, Andrews. Lock it in.

What do you see Andrews averaging over a season GL? I'm tempted but just struggle to see him top 6.

[GoLions]

Brayshaw, Liba and whitfield vs Oliver, B.Crouch and B.Smith

If i choose option 1, ill be starting my team with possibily 4 GWS keepers

What's the best def you could get with Oliver and Libba?

witherden or a ryan/hurley/howe type; although apart from Williams who i already have no one under 500k really appeals to me.

Oliver, Libba, Andrews. Lock it in.

What do you see Andrews averaging over a season GL? I'm tempted but just struggle to see him top 6.

95ish

[eaglesman]

Last 2 spots for my side (I think but if balta is names might put him back in)

Tim kelly and Ridley plus $76k ....

Vs

Toby Greene and witherden. (No cash)

A higher scoring keeper and top 6 forwArd and a breakout player vs 2 potential top 10 by position players

[RoughRed]

Last 2 spots for my side (I think but if balta is names might put him back in)

Tim kelly and Ridley plus $76k ....

Vs

Toby Greene and witherden. (No cash)

A higher scoring keeper and top 6 forwArd and a breakout player vs 2 potential top 10 by position players

Kelly plus Ridley and "take the money"... but i am a huge Kelly fan

[jfitty]

This may have been asked, but if you had to pick one, would you go Zac Williams or Brodie Smith?

Not too worried about the price difference, more the scoring.

[Ricochet]

This may have been asked, but if you had to pick one, would you go Zac Williams or Brodie Smith?

Not too worried about the price difference, more the scoring.

Williams

[RaisyDaisy]

Last 2 spots for my side (I think but if balta is names might put him back in)

Tim kelly and Ridley plus $76k ....

Vs

Toby Greene and witherden. (No cash)

A higher scoring keeper and top 6 forwArd and a breakout player vs 2 potential top 10 by position players

Second option for me. We're picking Greene as an undervalued keeper, so 2 keepers vs 1

Not a huge Witherden fan myself, but he'd be picked as a keeper too, so 2 keepers vs 1 gets my vote

[Thewizz71]

Last 2 spots for my side (I think but if balta is names might put him back in)

Tim kelly and Ridley plus $76k ....

Vs

Toby Greene and witherden. (No cash)

A higher scoring keeper and top 6 forwArd and a breakout player vs 2 potential top 10 by position players

Second option for me. We're picking Greene as an undervalued keeper, so 2 keepers vs 1

Not a huge Witherden fan myself, but he'd be picked as a keeper too, so 2 keepers vs 1 gets my vote

Kelly and Ridley for mine.

A Brayshaw v BCrouch?

[jfitty]

Last 2 spots for my side (I think but if balta is names might put him back in)

Tim kelly and Ridley plus $76k ....

Vs

Toby Greene and witherden. (No cash)

A higher scoring keeper and top 6 forwArd and a breakout player vs 2 potential top 10 by position players

Second option for me. We're picking Greene as an undervalued keeper, so 2 keepers vs 1

Not a huge Witherden fan myself, but he'd be picked as a keeper too, so 2 keepers vs 1 gets my vote

Kelly and Ridley for mine.

A Brayshaw v BCrouch?

I’m big on Brad Crouch, if he plays 22 he’ll easily average as much as Brayshaw IMO.

How about Hurn vs Crisp?

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Last 2 spots for my side (I think but if balta is names might put him back in)

Tim kelly and Ridley plus $76k ....

Vs

Toby Greene and witherden. (No cash)

A higher scoring keeper and top 6 forwArd and a breakout player vs 2 potential top 10 by position players

Second option for me. We're picking Greene as an undervalued keeper, so 2 keepers vs 1

Not a huge Witherden fan myself, but he'd be picked as a keeper too, so 2 keepers vs 1 gets my vote

Kelly and Ridley for mine.

A Brayshaw v BCrouch?

I’m big on Brad Crouch, if he plays 22 he’ll easily average as much as Brayshaw IMO.

How about Hurn vs Crisp?

I like Crisp.  Be surprised if either are top 6 though.

[jfitty]

Last 2 spots for my side (I think but if balta is names might put him back in)

Tim kelly and Ridley plus $76k ....

Vs

Toby Greene and witherden. (No cash)

A higher scoring keeper and top 6 forwArd and a breakout player vs 2 potential top 10 by position players

Second option for me. We're picking Greene as an undervalued keeper, so 2 keepers vs 1

Not a huge Witherden fan myself, but he'd be picked as a keeper too, so 2 keepers vs 1 gets my vote

Kelly and Ridley for mine.

A Brayshaw v BCrouch?

I’m big on Brad Crouch, if he plays 22 he’ll easily average as much as Brayshaw IMO.

How about Hurn vs Crisp?

I like Crisp.  Be surprised if either are top 6 though.

Who would you rank above? I feel they’d be pretty close

[RaisyDaisy]

Hurn and Crisp were 6th and 7th last year

Can't see too many guys priced below them that I'd expect to go 95+ and over-take them

Top 10 is fine for DEF too, and I reckon they both land in that

[tkringle]

Steele or Merrett?

[LaHug]

Steele or Merrett?

Honestly prefer Steele. Just can't see Merrett being a top 10 mid in SC scoring whereas at least Steele has the potential for a breakout year.