Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[tommy10]

Downgrade...
Hurn to Ryan/Andrews/other under $501k
Cogs to Dusty/Pendles/other cheaper
Roberton to Ridley/Collins/Scrimshaw

OR

Just keep Hind/Gibbons as M10/M11 and miss out on Butters?

Can u do just Roberton to Collins and get Butters?

Sorry, the three were all options. So I only need to downgrade one of Hurn, Cogs, or Robbo. So yes, I could do that, but I think Roberton's cash gen and scoring are both much better than Butters so I'm very hesitant.

Have you caught up with the news Roberton is sitting out 2019

Yeah I have now. Gone Robbo to Collins, upgraded Hore to Scrimshaw (good idea?), Hind to Butters, and Gibbons to Atkins (good idea?). Still have cash left over too.

100% I would do that  8)

[SilverLion]

B Smith vs. Hanley vs. Moore (D4)

[LaHug]

B Smith vs. Hanley vs. Moore (D4)

Smith unless you can use the money elsewhere

[Wanderer]

B Smith vs. Hanley vs. Moore (D4)

Smith unless you can use the money elsewhere

+1

[Wanderer]

For my F3 position - T.Kelly vs Boak (+28K and friendlier bye).... already have Danger, Heeney,

With Kelly I would only have 14K left in bank whereas with Boak 42K

The other option around that price is Dunkley or can go lower priced Darling. I can't see anybody else I would take at that price range and I don't want Billings or Greene

[bkimm32]

Macrae & Butters  vs  Dusty & Walsh
I did have option 2 but am now leaning towards option 1 so that I don't have to trade as hard later to get Macrae into my side.

Macrae and butterss easily. Walsh should outscored butterss but both will make the same amount of cash in the end. Macrae will easily outscore dusty, but I don't see dusty as a top scorer meaning you will eventually have to trade him out in the long run anyhow.

I'm torn between neale vs coniglio

[Wanderer]

Macrae & Butters  vs  Dusty & Walsh
I did have option 2 but am now leaning towards option 1 so that I don't have to trade as hard later to get Macrae into my side.

Macrae and butterss easily. Walsh should outscored butterss but both will make the same amount of cash in the end. Macrae will easily outscore dusty, but I don't see dusty as a top scorer meaning you will eventually have to trade him out in the long run anyhow.

I'm torn between neale vs coniglio

Neale based on history, Coniglio based on showing steady improvement and JLT scores, but I would go with the proven premo

[Ringo]

Williams + Libba v Brodie Smith + Brad Crouch.

Think that both options will score similar but Crouch maybe with the injury curse.

[Wanderer]

Williams + Libba v Brodie Smith + Brad Crouch.

Think that both options will score similar but Crouch maybe with the injury curse.

You answered your own question..... B.Crouch is a big risk

[tommy10]

Williams + Libba v Brodie Smith + Brad Crouch.

Think that both options will score similar but Crouch maybe with the injury curse.

Williams and Libba

[Thewizz71]

I know it's been discussed, but,

Sheed v BCrouch v Libba?

Sheed's past form reads putrid (last few games aside).
Crouch could be anything if he stays on the park?
Libba's knees?

All have definite rewards and definite risks associated. Struggling to use the extra cash by taking Libba over either of the other two.

Breakout v soft tissue v wonky knees?

[Wanderer]

I know it's been discussed, but,

Sheed v BCrouch v Libba?

Sheed's past form reads putrid (last few games aside).
Crouch could be anything if he stays on the park?
Libba's knees?

All have definite rewards and definite risks associated. Struggling to use the extra cash by taking Libba over either of the other two.

Breakout v soft tissue v wonky knees?

Libba - if you can invest the extra coin to strengthen your team then get him, and he will make the most money out of the three you would think.

Sheed - isn't injury prone but will only be stepping stone and might not make enough cash.

B.Crouch - is the only one of the two that has a shot at being a keeper and top 10 mid but he is injury prone.

[Ingram]

Oliver + Greene Vs Brayshaw + Billings.

Keep in mind I'm still recovering from the severe burns I sustained last season starting Billings :(

[Ricochet]

Oliver + Greene Vs Brayshaw + Billings.

Keep in mind I'm still recovering from the severe burns I sustained last season starting Billings :(

Oliver Greene would be the 2 i would go for

[GoLions]

Oliver + Greene Vs Brayshaw + Billings.

Keep in mind I'm still recovering from the severe burns I sustained last season starting Billings :(

Oliver Greene would be the 2 i would go for