Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Bully]

Ridley and Goldstein vs a 123k defender and Gawn

Get Gawn mate, this is the one thing that could come back to bite. At worst he has a couple of stinkers & you can easily downgrade. I'll be using Goldy as a backstop in case Grawndy backfires.

Agreed

Agreed also. Hopefully that rookie goes to the bench with your favored option on field.

I do agree that gawn and grundy are easily the top 2 ruckman. However i do worry that i could spend that money elsewhere and that the gap between gawns and goldys sc averages are likely to become closer, so im really am undecided what i should do

You also need to think about captain's choices & the fact it's damn hard to trade up if you get the decision wrong. Let's face it, Gawn is the one player who could benefit immensely from the new ruck rules, I'd even have him ahead of Grundy at this stage.

[B.]

Hurn v Whitfield v Witherden

Fyfe v Neale v Martin v M Crouch

T Kelly v Mundy v Boak

[Thewizz71]

Hurn v Whitfield v Witherden

Fyfe v Neale v Martin v M Crouch

T Kelly v Mundy v Boak

I've taken Hurn, Martin & Boak at the moment.

[TommyC]

Hurn v Whitfield v Witherden

Fyfe v Neale v Martin v M Crouch

T Kelly v Mundy v Boak

Hurn, Neale, Boak

[LaHug]

Roberton + Witherden vs Moore + Hurn

[Bully]

Roberton + Witherden vs Moore + Hurn

Presuming Robbo fit the first option.

[Jalapeno]

Thanks mate. How come? I feel the new rules will work in Tmacs favour and he might improve his average?

[Jalapeno]

Hurn v Whitfield v Witherden

Fyfe v Neale v Martin v M Crouch

T Kelly v Mundy v Boak

Hurn, Neale, Boak

Whitfield
Fyfe
Mundy

[LaHug]

Roberton + Greene + Oliver + $52k

vs.

Hurn + Moore + Dusty

[Wanderer]

Hurn v Whitfield v Witherden

Fyfe v Neale v Martin v M Crouch

T Kelly v Mundy v Boak

Hurn, Neale, Boak

Whitfield
Fyfe
Mundy

Hurn
Neale
Kelly

[Wanderer]

B.Smith (currently D3) / Mundy (currently F4)

vs

Roberton (D3) / Dusty (M5) with Drew moving to F5 (Setterfield will become F4)

[acroyale]

Hurn & Macrae

vs

Lloyd & Coniglio

[Wanderer]

Hurn & Macrae

vs

Lloyd & Coniglio

Hurn and Macrae only because the difference between Macrae and Coniglio will outweigh the difference between Hurn and Lloyd

[Sven]

B. Smith (D4) + D. Sheed (M5)

vs.

L. McCarthy (F4) + M. Crouch (M5)

[GoLions]

Roberton + Greene + Oliver + $52k

vs.

Hurn + Moore + Dusty

First option if Roberton is ok