Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[quinny88]

Zac williams vs brodie smith?

Zac Williams comfortably for mine

[Bully]

Scrimshaw vs Clark in defence. Both looked good in JLT but can only start 1

Really tough question, Clark the better talent but Scrimshaw probably has better job security. I suppose if you have to make a call you go the guy who's been in the system longer.

Clark the better talent? Odd call so early  ??? Wouldnt say he has the better JS either, both are shaky. Cant even be sure they'll both be there next Thursday let alone 3 weeks on from that

Hardly odd when Scrimshaw was effectively booted from GC, was eventually traded for chump change. Clark has outstanding skills & has the professionalism to match. Scrimshaw was berated by teammates for playing Tetris in the stands while his teammates were busting a gut on the field. You'd expect he got the message but he's no Brendan Goddard, my hunch is Hawthorn will be keen to make their list managers look good, hence the job security, but like I said, tough call, Geelong have a few to come back.

[westfisker]

Not sold on Brayshaw, his DE isnt the greatest. His ceiling isnt high enough, has scored over 130 about about once. Probably priced about right.

Who has had the better pre season / fully fit of Sloane and M.Crouch?

[TomK]

Who has had the better pre season / fully fit of Sloane and M.Crouch?

Both have had a full preseason, don't think you can split them from that, but I'd take Matt due to consistency.

[walloo44]

M.Crouch v Coniglio

need one to fill my m4 spot. Brad and Libba m5/m6 already

[Bully]

M.Crouch v Coniglio

need one to fill my m4 spot. Brad and Libba m5/m6 already

M.Crouch is cheaper but I think they're similar with ceiling & consistency. I also think the Crows will bounce back strongly this year.

[Money Shot]

Macrae and Greene vs Crouch and Kelly

[Samsturmfels]

Macrae and Greene vs Crouch and Kelly

depends on which Crouch and Kelly.

Id assume you mean Matt Crouch and Tim Kelly, if so id go them. Both of them are more likely to be keepers. If greene can bounce back from last year and average 90+, Macrae and Greene would easily win

[kilbluff1985]

andy McGrath/Lyons vs Libba/Laird or LLoyd

[GoLions]

andy McGrath/Lyons vs Libba/Laird or LLoyd

Well, McGrath doesn't start with an L, so has to be Libba and Laird surely

[Bully]

andy McGrath/Lyons vs Libba/Laird or LLoyd

Second option

[kilbluff1985]

i guess i just give Lyons and mcgrath a chance at having big years

[Bully]

i guess i just give Lyons and mcgrath a chance at having big years

Think you need to use the wait & see approach with those two.

[Samsturmfels]

Ridley and Goldstein vs a 123k defender and Gawn

[kilbluff1985]

Ridley and Goldstein vs a 123k defender and Gawn

Ridley and Goldstein

Ridley can easily avg 20 more then the rookie and unlikely Gawn averages 20 more than Goldy