Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[RaisyDaisy]

Thanks guys - was leaning that way too, although it's not great for me bye wise

[brano]

Really stuck on this one : M Crouch/ Rocky v Zerrett/ B Crouch

[LaHug]

Really stuck on this one : M Crouch/ Rocky v Zerrett/ B Crouch

How much cash are you short of Crouch + Crouch because I'd be finding that cash. Neither Rocky or Zerrett feel like good picks...

[TommyC]

Really stuck on this one : M Crouch/ Rocky v Zerrett/ B Crouch

How much cash are you short of Crouch + Crouch because I'd be finding that cash. Neither Rocky or Zerrett feel like good picks...

This.
A couple of months ago I was keen on Zerrett but he hasn't ticked enough boxes for me.
Everyone knows the risks with the Pig.

[brano]

Cheers people, yeah could go Crouch x2 but don't like too many players from one team, already have Smith in back line.
Hmmmm decisions.

Edit: Plus I have a gut feeling about Rocky this year, at least for the first 6 or so rounds anyway....I guess I just answered my own question? M Crouch Rocky It is..( with a sick feeling in my stomach ha) 

[TommyC]

Mills or J Higgins  ::)

[GoLions]

Mills or J Higgins  ::)

Mills for me

[GoLions]

Really stuck on this one : M Crouch/ Rocky v Zerrett/ B Crouch

How much cash are you short of Crouch + Crouch because I'd be finding that cash. Neither Rocky or Zerrett feel like good picks...

Rocky has better scoring history than BCrouch, better injury history (somewhat), and is slightly cheaper as well. Brad could end up the better pick, but if I was gonna take the risk on one, it'd be Rocky. I guess the only issue with Rocky is if Port don't play him in the guts full time, but that's the risk you take I guess

[brano]

Really stuck on this one : M Crouch/ Rocky v Zerrett/ B Crouch

How much cash are you short of Crouch + Crouch because I'd be finding that cash. Neither Rocky or Zerrett feel like good picks...

Rocky has better scoring history than BCrouch, better injury history (somewhat), and is slightly cheaper as well. Brad could end up the better pick, but if I was gonna take the risk on one, it'd be Rocky. I guess the only issue with Rocky is if Port don't play him in the guts full time, but that's the risk you take I guess

Yeah agree with you mate. At his price and a great pre-season I'm trying to convince myself not to pick him....Have enough to put him at M6

[Jalapeno]

Hi all. Tossing up between T McDonald and D Smith?

[quinny88]

Hi all. Tossing up between T McDonald and D Smith?

I prefer Smith

[quinny88]

Scrimshaw vs Clark in defence. Both looked good in JLT but can only start 1

[Bully]

Scrimshaw vs Clark in defence. Both looked good in JLT but can only start 1

Really tough question, Clark the better talent but Scrimshaw probably has better job security. I suppose if you have to make a call you go the guy who's been in the system longer.

[hawkers65]

Scrimshaw vs Clark in defence. Both looked good in JLT but can only start 1

Really tough question, Clark the better talent but Scrimshaw probably has better job security. I suppose if you have to make a call you go the guy who's been in the system longer.

Clark the better talent? Odd call so early  ??? Wouldnt say he has the better JS either, both are shaky. Cant even be sure they'll both be there next Thursday let alone 3 weeks on from that

[sammy123]

Zac williams vs brodie smith?