Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Bully]

The difficult F3 spot.

Mundy vs T.Kelly vs Boak

Boak the safest option I think, should play 22 games & will be playing predominantly midfield. Last year averaged 88 with the majority of time up forward.

[frenzy]

More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

I am starting Brayshaw at M5. Mids Macrae, Cripps, Neale, Coniglio and Brayshaw

So either I'm not crazy or we're both crazy!

I too have Brayshaw atm (M4) Jones & Viney to come back in worries me though.

keeping an eye on his brother at Freo, reckon he could spike this season. Should be in line for more midfield minutes with Neale departure and only ave 66% TOG last season.

[justaverage]

Toying with the idea of Bines at R3 for loophole / cover....

F3/F4

Mundy / Lycett or Greene / Hoff

[hawkers65]

Toying with the idea of Bines at R3 for loophole / cover....

F3/F4

Mundy / Lycett or Greene / Hoff

Greene and Hoff

I got an interesting mix of top end players. Cant decide if i want the top end back, mid or ruck

1)Lloyd/Dusty/Gawn

2) Lloyd/Macca/Goldy

3) Andrews/Macca/Gawn

I'm leaning towards 3 cause i think Andrews could push 100 and i see Macca comfortably beating Dusty

[GoLions]

Toying with the idea of Bines at R3 for loophole / cover....

F3/F4

Mundy / Lycett or Greene / Hoff

Greene and Hoff

I got an interesting mix of top end players. Cant decide if i want the top end back, mid or ruck

1)Lloyd/Dusty/Gawn

2) Lloyd/Macca/Goldy

3) Andrews/Macca/Gawn

I'm leaning towards 3 cause i think Andrews could push 100 and i see Macca comfortably beating Dusty

Pick #3 m'lord

[LaHug]

Toying with the idea of Bines at R3 for loophole / cover....

F3/F4

Mundy / Lycett or Greene / Hoff

Greene and Hoff

I got an interesting mix of top end players. Cant decide if i want the top end back, mid or ruck

1)Lloyd/Dusty/Gawn

2) Lloyd/Macca/Goldy

3) Andrews/Macca/Gawn

I'm leaning towards 3 cause i think Andrews could push 100 and i see Macca comfortably beating Dusty

Pick #3 m'lord

Yeah, 3 for sure

[jbjimmyjb]

Laird/Witherden vs Whitfield/Andrews

Currently prefer the look of #2.

[LaHug]

Laird/Witherden vs Whitfield/Andrews

Currently prefer the look of #2.

I like  2 over 1 but I'd be tempted to do Witherden and Andrews...

[tommy10]

More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

Someone pls reply to my potentially stupid question.
[/quote]
Oliver no doubt

[GoLions]

Laird/Witherden vs Whitfield/Andrews

Currently prefer the look of #2.

I like  2 over 1 but I'd be tempted to do Witherden and Andrews...

Withergoat and Andrews is indeed the correct answer

[jbjimmyjb]

More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

Someone pls reply to my potentially stupid question.

Oliver no doubt
[/quote]
100%, Brayshaw is on my watchlist for now, if his disposal efficiency improves throughout the season then I'll pick him up, but as it stands he needs 40+ possessions to score the same as what Oliver does with 25. AF lock, SC wait and see.

[RaisyDaisy]

Conigs + Oliver vs Macrae + Steele/Zorko

[tommy10]

Conigs + Oliver vs Macrae + Steele/Zorko

Conigs and Oliver RD.

[LaHug]

Conigs + Oliver vs Macrae + Steele/Zorko

I'd go the first one. I think Steele and Zorko would need to be keepers at their prices and I doubt they will be. Two definite keepers vs. one and a gamble.

[jbjimmyjb]

Conigs + Oliver vs Macrae + Steele/Zorko

First, Coniglio in his contract year, with no Shiel... 120+ guarunteed  ;)