Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[LaHug]

Battle of the mid pricers that will inevitably blow up in my face

Moore and $$$ vs Smith

Really depends on how you use that money. Smith is the better choice than Moore unless you can use the money well enough (e.g. Goldy to Gawn or Rookie to Libba). I'd still probably lean towards Smith tbh.

Macrae and Libba vs Neale and Sheed

Macrae and Libba. Don't like Sheed's awkward price. Macrae a definite Top 10 mid whereas Neale is more in the "highly likely" category.

More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

Someone pls reply to my potentially stupid question.

[walloo44]

Macrae and Libba vs Neale and Sheed

Macrae and Libba for me. Gives u a great captain option each week, and I dont rate sheed much higher than libba especially for the extra money.

[walloo44]

Cogs vs merrett vs M.crouch or any other similar priced player (not interested in dusty though)

[GoLions]

Pick one mid to get rid of... (Benefits in brackets)

Macrae (Gawn R2 and $53k)
Cripps (Gawn R2 and $11k)
Oliver (Goldy R2 and $130k)
Coniglio (Goldy R2 and $96k)
M.Crouch (Goldy R2 and $58k)

I think Gawn is a better pick than Goldy but, if you think otherwise, the first two give me $197k and $155k, respectively, which I'm sure I could use elsewhere.

You need Gawn in my opinion.

Macrae is the one I would get rid of.

Always nice when the first reply is what I've already done :) Cheers for adding confidence.



More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

Oliver ya filthy casul

[GoLions]

Cogs vs merrett vs M.crouch or any other similar priced player (not interested in dusty though)

Crouchhhhh

[GoLions]

Macrae and Libba vs Neale and Sheed

Macrae and Libba for me. Gives u a great captain option each week, and I dont rate sheed much higher than libba especially for the extra money.

Agreed

[LaHug]

Oliver ya filthy casul

Don't call me a casual (casul?) or I'll report you to the mods :'(

But yeah, fair. Interesting that people aren't willing to consider Brayshaw but are willing to consider Steele...

[SilverLion]

Oliver ya filthy casul

Don't call me a casual (casul?) or I'll report you to the mods :'(

But yeah, fair. Interesting that people aren't willing to consider Brayshaw but are willing to consider Steele...

I considered Brayshaw, but reckon I'd go Zorko over both :P

[GoLions]

Oliver ya filthy casul

Don't call me a casual (casul?) or I'll report you to the mods :'(

But yeah, fair. Interesting that people aren't willing to consider Brayshaw but are willing to consider Steele...

casul.

[Ringo]

Pick one mid to get rid of... (Benefits in brackets)

Macrae (Gawn R2 and $53k)
Cripps (Gawn R2 and $11k)
Oliver (Goldy R2 and $130k)
Coniglio (Goldy R2 and $96k)
M.Crouch (Goldy R2 and $58k)

I think Gawn is a better pick than Goldy but, if you think otherwise, the first two give me $197k and $155k, respectively, which I'm sure I could use elsewhere.

You need Gawn in my opinion.

Macrae is the one I would get rid of.

Always nice when the first reply is what I've already done :) Cheers for adding confidence.



More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

I am starting Brayshaw at M5. Mids Macrae, Cripps, Neale, Coniglio and Brayshaw

[LaHug]

More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

I am starting Brayshaw at M5. Mids Macrae, Cripps, Neale, Coniglio and Brayshaw

So either I'm not crazy or we're both crazy!

[HappyDEZ]

More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

I am starting Brayshaw at M5. Mids Macrae, Cripps, Neale, Coniglio and Brayshaw

So either I'm not crazy or we're both crazy!

I too have Brayshaw atm (M4) Jones & Viney to come back in worries me though.

[LaHug]

More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

I am starting Brayshaw at M5. Mids Macrae, Cripps, Neale, Coniglio and Brayshaw

So either I'm not crazy or we're both crazy!

I too have Brayshaw atm (M4) Jones & Viney to come back in worries me though.

I think it'll come down to cash needs. Right now, I can afford Oliver. However, if I end up needing more cash because of team announcements, he might become Brayshaw.

[dmac07]

The difficult F3 spot.

Mundy vs T.Kelly vs Boak

[SilverLion]

The difficult F3 spot.

Mundy vs T.Kelly vs Boak

TK, but if byes are an issue flip a coin on the other two. I'd probably lean towards Mundy just.