Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[bunyips]

Hey all,

McRae and Sam jacobs

Vs

M crouch and Gawn

[GoLions]

Hey all,

McRae and Sam jacobs

Vs

M crouch and Gawn

Crouch and Gawn for sure

[bunyips]

Hey all,

McRae and Sam jacobs

Vs

M crouch and Gawn

Crouch and Gawn for sure

Cool thanks for that. I was leaning towards that but was a bit iffy as Matt can get injured.

[walloo44]

Probably been asked but Grundy v Gawn

I feel gawns game is slightly more sustainable and will average around 110 assuming Preuss doesnt play, But grundy could be anything from 100-120 so finding them very hard to split, and I only want one (refuse to fork out 1.4mil for 2 rucks)

[Keeper27]

pick 2 for M4 & M5
Steele/Lyons/B Crouch/Sheed

[GoLions]

Probably been asked but Grundy v Gawn

I feel gawns game is slightly more sustainable and will average around 110 assuming Preuss doesnt play, But grundy could be anything from 100-120 so finding them very hard to split, and I only want one (refuse to fork out 1.4mil for 2 rucks)

Who is your 2nd ruck? If I was only starting one of them, I'd be leaning towards Grundy, but honestly I can't see either of them dropping back far enough to not comfortably be the top 2 rucks. So unless you're fielding a mid-pricer, gotta go with both.

[frenzy]

pick 2 for M4 & M5
Steele/Lyons/B Crouch/Sheed

I will have 3 of them, you could start Brouch and Steele.

[GoLions]

pick 2 for M4 & M5
Steele/Lyons/B Crouch/Sheed

I will have 3 of them, you could start Brouch and Steele.

Also agree on Steele and BCrouch, Lyons will likely be in that 95-100 range, and whilst Sheed has put together some really good footy recently, I can't see him keeping that up for a whole season. Would rather spend less and go for Libba, or a touch more for Rocky.

[timtim]

Neale or Oliver for M2

[LaHug]

Neale or Oliver for M2

Oliver for mine. I think Neale's new team shouldn't affect him but it could. Meanwhile, Oliver is improving every year, is still young, and has the best ruckman in the league feeding him.

[LaHug]

Pick one mid to get rid of... (Benefits in brackets)

Macrae (Gawn R2 and $53k)
Cripps (Gawn R2 and $11k)
Oliver (Goldy R2 and $130k)
Coniglio (Goldy R2 and $96k)
M.Crouch (Goldy R2 and $58k)

I think Gawn is a better pick than Goldy but, if you think otherwise, the first two give me $197k and $155k, respectively, which I'm sure I could use elsewhere.

[Money Shot]

Pick one mid to get rid of... (Benefits in brackets)

Macrae (Gawn R2 and $53k)
Cripps (Gawn R2 and $11k)
Oliver (Goldy R2 and $130k)
Coniglio (Goldy R2 and $96k)
M.Crouch (Goldy R2 and $58k)

I think Gawn is a better pick than Goldy but, if you think otherwise, the first two give me $197k and $155k, respectively, which I'm sure I could use elsewhere.

You need Gawn in my opinion.

Macrae is the one I would get rid of.

[LaHug]

Pick one mid to get rid of... (Benefits in brackets)

Macrae (Gawn R2 and $53k)
Cripps (Gawn R2 and $11k)
Oliver (Goldy R2 and $130k)
Coniglio (Goldy R2 and $96k)
M.Crouch (Goldy R2 and $58k)

I think Gawn is a better pick than Goldy but, if you think otherwise, the first two give me $197k and $155k, respectively, which I'm sure I could use elsewhere.

You need Gawn in my opinion.

Macrae is the one I would get rid of.

Always nice when the first reply is what I've already done :) Cheers for adding confidence.



More of a unique one. Anyone considering Brayshaw over Oliver to save $100k? It's only JLT but they look like very similar players right now with a big price gap.

[Brikett]

Battle of the mid pricers that will inevitably blow up in my face

Moore and $$$ vs Smith

[tommy10]

Macrae and Libba vs Neale and Sheed