Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[jvalles69]

Macrae/Lloyd/Walsh vs Neale/Witherden/Libba

Wouldnt you have the cash to go Macrae in both options?

Lean to Lloyd/Walsh atm but as mentioned before, keep an eye on Libba again next week

Very possibly, will have to check.

[Sven]

Mumford/R2 and Neale

vs.

Grundy and Walsh/mid rookie

[GoLions]

Mumford/R2 and Neale

vs.

Grundy and Walsh/mid rookie

Grundy and Walsh, not even considering Mummy as he won't play the first 2 games

[GoLions]

Macrae/Lloyd/Walsh vs Neale/Witherden/Libba

Wouldnt you have the cash to go Macrae in both options?

Lean to Lloyd/Walsh atm but as mentioned before, keep an eye on Libba again next week

Very possibly, will have to check.

Well like I mean, Walsh is 90k less than Libba, Lloyd is 150k more than WitherGOAT, so going Lloyd down and Walsh up should mean you can keep Macrae and bank an extra 60k

[Sven]

Mumford/R2 and Neale

vs.

Grundy and Walsh/mid rookie

Grundy and Walsh, not even considering Mummy as he won't play the first 2 games

And if you were only focussed on league wins?

[GoLions]

Mumford/R2 and Neale

vs.

Grundy and Walsh/mid rookie

Grundy and Walsh, not even considering Mummy as he won't play the first 2 games

And if you were only focussed on league wins?

Would still go Grundy and Walsh, because it's much easier to trade in someone like Neale than it will be to bring in Grundy. Should get more cash gen from Walsh than Mummy as well imo (and quicker). We don't know how Mummy will return after a lot of time out of the game.

[RoughRed]

Roberton & Goldstein vs Quaynor & Gawn

&

Fyfe vs Yeo? Cash not an issue.
I like Yeo as a POD, and worried about Fyfe's durability but will hurt when he's banging out 150s at Optus..

I would be Roberton & goldy but then I am one who likes consistency.

Roberton conservatively say 85 = keeper
Goldstein say 100 = Keeper
185

Quaynor = 70 = trade
Gawn = 120 = keeper
190

Line ball but Quaynor is not a keeper! So one more trade = X.

Yeo Yeo Yeo ... both have high ceilings, are mildly erratic but IMO Yeo is more durable (touch wood)

[imjusflexin]

Roberton & Goldstein vs Quaynor & Gawn

&

Fyfe vs Yeo? Cash not an issue.
I like Yeo as a POD, and worried about Fyfe's durability but will hurt when he's banging out 150s at Optus..

I would be Roberton & goldy but then I am one who likes consistency.

Roberton conservatively say 85 = keeper
Goldstein say 100 = Keeper
185

Quaynor = 70 = trade
Gawn = 120 = keeper
190

Line ball but Quaynor is not a keeper! So one more trade = X.

Yeo Yeo Yeo ... both have high ceilings, are mildly erratic but IMO Yeo is more durable (touch wood)

Cheers, I think I'll go Gawn/Quaynor. Not that flush on locking in Roberton as my D6, would rather avoid and have one of the other various option.

[IntegralX]

Whitfield + Collins vs Mills + Roberton?

[enzedder]

Whitfield + Collins vs Mills + Roberton?

Whitfield + Collins
Whitfield will be one of the elite defenders. Mills might be; he has risk written all over him.
Collins is a good starting pick.
You miss out on Roberton but I wouldn’t be happy with Mills to get him.

[TommyC]

Mumford/R2 and Neale

vs.

Grundy and Walsh/mid rookie

Grundy and Walsh, not even considering Mummy as he won't play the first 2 games

+1

[Bully]

Roberton & Goldstein vs Quaynor & Gawn

&

Fyfe vs Yeo? Cash not an issue.
I like Yeo as a POD, and worried about Fyfe's durability but will hurt when he's banging out 150s at Optus..

I would be Roberton & goldy but then I am one who likes consistency.

Roberton conservatively say 85 = keeper
Goldstein say 100 = Keeper
185

Quaynor = 70 = trade
Gawn = 120 = keeper
190

Line ball but Quaynor is not a keeper! So one more trade = X.

Yeo Yeo Yeo ... both have high ceilings, are mildly erratic but IMO Yeo is more durable (touch wood)

Quaynor 70? Reckon that's pretty optimistic for a first year player, Ed Richards who had a stellar debut season only averaged 58, think people need to hose down expectations.

[Keeper27]

Roberton & Goldstein vs Quaynor & Gawn

&

Fyfe vs Yeo? Cash not an issue.
I like Yeo as a POD, and worried about Fyfe's durability but will hurt when he's banging out 150s at Optus..

I would be Roberton & goldy but then I am one who likes consistency.

Roberton conservatively say 85 = keeper
Goldstein say 100 = Keeper
185

Quaynor = 70 = trade
Gawn = 120 = keeper
190

Line ball but Quaynor is not a keeper! So one more trade = X.

Yeo Yeo Yeo ... both have high ceilings, are mildly erratic but IMO Yeo is more durable (touch wood)

Quaynor 70? Reckon that's pretty optimistic for a first year player, Ed Richards who had a stellar debut season only averaged 58, think people need to hose down expectations.

exactly, some people reckon some rookies will avg super high scores when realistically its the opposite,
Mid rookies (even the likes of Walsh) give em a 70, DEF rookies a 60 at best
if they go over, then thats great

[hawkboy80]

M Crouch & Brayshaw

Vs

Oliver & B Crouch

2nd EZ, cause i got them ;)

+1

[hawkboy80]

Macrae & Butters  vs  Dusty & Walsh
I did have option 2 but am now leaning towards option 1 so that I don't have to trade as hard later to get Macrae into my side.