Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Thewizz71]

Martin + L.Ryan v Z.Merrett + Whitfield

leaning towards option 1 but a little unsure

Yeah I'd go Dusty and Ryan as well.

Think Dusty and Ryan have the greater upside

I think so too.
Gawn/BCrouch vs Goldy/Zerrett?

Think Goldy is primed for a good year and Zerrett is seriously under priced. Also think if Crouch gets a good run at it, could be a potential bargain M8.

[shaker]

Martin + L.Ryan v Z.Merrett + Whitfield

leaning towards option 1 but a little unsure

Yeah I'd go Dusty and Ryan as well.

Think Dusty and Ryan have the greater upside

I think so too.
Gawn/BCrouch vs Goldy/Zerrett?

Think Goldy is primed for a good year and Zerrett is seriously under priced. Also think if Crouch gets a good run at it, could be a potential bargain M8.

Goldy and Zerrett for me B Crouch needs prove he can stay on the field before I would pick him

[frenzy]

Greene vs Miles

greene prob ave 5-10 more than miles, but is a hand grenade, thoughts pls.

[Big Mac]

Greene vs Miles

greene prob ave 5-10 more than miles, but is a hand grenade, thoughts pls.

I'd put Miles 5-10 ppg ahead of Greene given he's a midfielder and has had a better preseason

[shaker]

Greene vs Miles

greene prob ave 5-10 more than miles, but is a hand grenade, thoughts pls.

If Greene can have a trouble free run till the start of the season him easily Miles is a good pick as well but there are reasons he did not get a game at the Tiges , a bit one dimensional and his disposal can be a bit iffy it will be interesting to see him play at GC but probably looking to have both myself  ;)

[_wato]

Gawn and Rocky v Goldy and Zerrett.

Think it could go awfully tight, currently have the second option.

[shaker]

Gawn and Rocky v Goldy and Zerrett.

Think it could go awfully tight, currently have the second option.

Yep option 2 for me only because of Rocky's past year or 2 but he was a super gun and sought of thinking in the back of my mind that he could turn it on again.

[Thewizz71]

Gawn and Rocky v Goldy and Zerrett.

Think it could go awfully tight, currently have the second option.

Yep option 2 for me only because of Rocky's past year or 2 but he was a super gun and sought of thinking in the back of my mind that he could turn it on again.

Currently running with the 2nd option as well.

[TableKing]

Tossing up Worpel v Merritt
Player for player im sure all agree Merritt is well established and proven. Reason i have put it up...Worpel has been killing it in training and he will be having increased Mid minutes.
Merritt is a gun but when tagged can go missing. Not sure if Shiel coming over will make a difference. I would still expect the tag to head to Merritt.

Anyways they are my thoughts...would love to know yours

[shaker]

Tossing up Worpel v Merritt
Player for player im sure all agree Merritt is well established and proven. Reason i have put it up...Worpel has been killing it in training and he will be having increased Mid minutes.
Merritt is a gun but when tagged can go missing. Not sure if Shiel coming over will make a difference. I would still expect the tag to head to Merritt.

Anyways they are my thoughts...would love to know yours

With Mitchell going down someone has to get a lot of extra mid time so Worpel could be the man but we have a very small sample size of him so far so Merrett has to be the one

[jfitty]

Tossing up Worpel v Merritt
Player for player im sure all agree Merritt is well established and proven. Reason i have put it up...Worpel has been killing it in training and he will be having increased Mid minutes.
Merritt is a gun but when tagged can go missing. Not sure if Shiel coming over will make a difference. I would still expect the tag to head to Merritt.

Anyways they are my thoughts...would love to know yours

Easy, pick Worpel forward and Merrett in the midfield!

Otherwise, it's Merrett for sure. Already has runs on the board, and with Shiel around him for support I can't see him not improving.

[Keeper27]

Lloyd, Rozee, Worpel vs. Williams, Roberton, Greene

[ubeaut]

Lloyd, Rozee, Worpel vs. Williams, Roberton, Greene

I can't justify spending the extra 200k on Lloyd over Williams for 10-15 extra points. So option 2, should have change left too.

[quinny88]

Tossing up Worpel v Merritt
Player for player im sure all agree Merritt is well established and proven. Reason i have put it up...Worpel has been killing it in training and he will be having increased Mid minutes.
Merritt is a gun but when tagged can go missing. Not sure if Shiel coming over will make a difference. I would still expect the tag to head to Merritt.

Anyways they are my thoughts...would love to know yours

Merret by an absolute mile.

I can't understand the Worpel hype at all. The kids played 12 games. Getting extra midfield time won't automatically turn him into a premium. Will average 90 at absolute best where as Merrett will average 100 at worst

[ben_020285]

Tossing up Worpel v Merritt
Player for player im sure all agree Merritt is well established and proven. Reason i have put it up...Worpel has been killing it in training and he will be having increased Mid minutes.
Merritt is a gun but when tagged can go missing. Not sure if Shiel coming over will make a difference. I would still expect the tag to head to Merritt.

Anyways they are my thoughts...would love to know yours

Merret by an absolute mile.

I can't understand the Worpel hype at all. The kids played 12 games. Getting extra midfield time won't automatically turn him into a premium. Will average 90 at absolute best where as Merrett will average 100 at worst

The same could be said about Oliver at the start of 2017.

It’s rare that a player does it in his second year but the scene is set for Worpel as the way he plays suits SC plus obviously the injury to Mitchell helps a great deal.

Not expecting a 110 average like Clarry the GOAT did in his second year but I can see him going 95+