Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[elephants]

Strange, Essendon sort of contradicted themselves. They said its a one weeker but the injury they described is normally more serious. If he plays JLT I'll have to consider him, otherwise upgrade target

[Keeper27]

Mundy vs. Kelly

Both to spend more time in the midfield

[elephants]

Mundy vs. Kelly

Both to spend more time in the midfield

Mundy the safer pick for me, but Kelly could be anything. Went 99 in the second half of the season. I have a nagging feeling he still wants to come home EOS so I worry that Geelong will let that influence what role they give him

Both should be comfortably 90+ though

[Woppa15]

M1 - Macrae vs Fyfe.

Can Macrae back it up? Certainly seems to have the ability, midfield minutes and seems fairly durable (touch wood)

Fyfe is Fyfe, scoring history speaks for itself but so does his injury history. What impact will Neales departure have? 70k cheaper.

[elephants]

M1 - Macrae vs Fyfe.

Can Macrae back it up? Certainly seems to have the ability, midfield minutes and seems fairly durable (touch wood)

Fyfe is Fyfe, scoring history speaks for itself but so does his injury history. What impact will Neales departure have? 70k cheaper.

I lean toward Fyfe, but I do want both in my team come round 1. If I had to choose one though its Fyfe, could go to another level without Neale and that is frightening!

[Sven]

J. Macrae (or any MID) and J. Lukousis

or

A. Miles/T. Liberatore and S. Menegola (or any FWD except Danger)

[Keeper27]

worpel & Coniglio vs. Greene & Fyfe

[IntegralX]

If Chad Wingards latest injury ends me worrying me out of him...

Worpel + Libba vs Walsh + T. Kelly (or any fwd below, would consider Walters here)

Or am I better off trying to find the extra 15-20k for Mundy/McLean/Dunkley?

[Fid]

Ryan V Witherden

[kilbluff1985]

Ryan V Witherden

cant split them imo so pick both  :P

[HappyDEZ]

Ryan V Witherden

Witherden clearly for mine.

[shaker]

Ryan V Witherden

Ryan for me purely because he never really kicked it to himself at fullback where as Witherden did 40 or 50 % of the time so I see more upside for Ryan

[nperera95]

Martin + L.Ryan v Z.Merrett + Whitfield

leaning towards option 1 but a little unsure

[GoLions]

Martin + L.Ryan v Z.Merrett + Whitfield

leaning towards option 1 but a little unsure

Yeah I'd go Dusty and Ryan as well.

[Ringo]

Martin + L.Ryan v Z.Merrett + Whitfield

leaning towards option 1 but a little unsure

Yeah I'd go Dusty and Ryan as well.

Think Dusty and Ryan have the greater upside