Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Daicos.]

Beams/B.Smith vs Miles/Whitfield

Already have Lloyd, Laird, Williams in defence.
Midfield has 4 other premos besides Beams.

[sidvicious]

Beams/B.Smith vs Miles/Whitfield

Already have Lloyd, Laird, Williams in defence.
Midfield has 4 other premos besides Beams.

miles/whitfield less injury risk

[AaronKirk]

Beams/B.Smith vs Miles/Whitfield

Already have Lloyd, Laird, Williams in defence.
Midfield has 4 other premos besides Beams.

miles/whitfield less injury risk

Depends if you think Smith is going to be a defensive keeper.

If not then it is simple. Miles IMO is likely to make more cash than Smith. Whitfield more likely to be a top 6 in his position then Beams is.

Miles/Whitfield for me is the better option.

[ubeaut]

Beams/B.Smith vs Miles/Whitfield

Already have Lloyd, Laird, Williams in defence.
Midfield has 4 other premos besides Beams.

Having Whitfield on top of the 3 u have is over spending in the back line imo.

[Keeper27]

Mills & Wingard vs. Whitfield & Greene

[GoLions]

Mills & Wingard vs. Whitfield & Greene

If all fit and ready to go rd1 then probably Whitfield and Greene, but that's a decent if for Greene and Wingard, especially Greene

[GoLions]

Lloyd vs Laird
Ryan vs WitherGOAT

Both doing my head in atm. And don't get me started on M4.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Lloyd vs Laird
Ryan vs WitherGOAT

Both doing my head in atm. And don't get me started on M4.

Laird and I think there is more improvement to come from Withers than Ryan. Can see why they're doing your head in. Closest thing to a double dead heat possible. Any pick definitely only provisional until we see from the JLT, what, if any, effect the new rules have on their scoring.

Dylan  Roberton   V   Hunter  Clark.    Both Saints, both available as defenders, and both priced within  4k of each other.

[Ringo]

Lloyd vs Laird
Ryan vs WitherGOAT

Both doing my head in atm. And don't get me started on M4.

Laird and I think there is more improvement to come from Withers than Ryan. Can see why they're doing your head in. Closest thing to a double dead heat possible. Any pick definitely only provisional until we see from the JLT, what, if any, effect the new rules have on their scoring.

Dylan  Roberton   V   Hunter  Clark.    Both Saints, both available as defenders, and both priced within  4k of each other.

Toss a coin between Lloyd and Laird. Lloyd may benefit more from the new rules but watch JLT.
Injury to Blakely has muddied the choice between Withers and Ryan so again watch JLT
Going Laird and Withers though gives you an extra 50k which may help gain another premium.

Roberton for me as has been reported prior to injury he was 4 in AFL for playing on and if used in that role again he has a higher ceiling but again watch through JLT.

[elephants]

Mills & Wingard vs. Whitfield & Greene

Whitfield and Greene for me. Greene is one of the only players in the AFL I would consider picking off a limited preseason, absolute magnet and should continue to get supply

Lloyd vs Laird
Ryan vs WitherGOAT

Both doing my head in atm. And don't get me started on M4.

Lloyd and Withergoat by a street for me. Wouldn't be shocked to see Lloyd go 110+ and Withers 100 with the new kick-in rules.

Lloyd vs Laird
Ryan vs WitherGOAT

Both doing my head in atm. And don't get me started on M4.

Laird and I think there is more improvement to come from Withers than Ryan. Can see why they're doing your head in. Closest thing to a double dead heat possible. Any pick definitely only provisional until we see from the JLT, what, if any, effect the new rules have on their scoring.

Dylan  Roberton   V   Hunter  Clark.    Both Saints, both available as defenders, and both priced within  4k of each other.

Roberton for me too here, just more proven and I'm not really about picking 2nd year players. Wouldn't be shocked to see both average 80s but I deem Roberton doing it a fair bit more likely

[frenzy]

Lloyd vs Laird
Ryan vs WitherGOAT

Both doing my head in atm. And don't get me started on M4.

Laird for his consistantly higher numbers, Lloyd only 1 year in the elite three figures.

And can't split the other two, so why not both.

[Keeper27]

Macrae(M1)/Rookie (M5)/Gray (F2) + $67K vs. Zerrett (M4)/Gray (M5)/Greene (F4) + $3k

thoughts??

[frenzy]

Macrae(M1)/Rookie (M5)/Gray (F2) + $67K vs. Zerrett (M4)/Gray (M5)/Greene (F4) + $3k

thoughts??

Cant do Macrae, Zerrett and Rookie?

I want Devon S vs Mundy.

[RaisyDaisy]

I want Devon S vs Mundy.

Should average the same and share the same bye

As close as it gets to a coin flip

Smith much younger, but I reckon Mundy has the better ceiling and chance to average a couple of points more

Can't go wrong with either

[frenzy]

I want Devon S vs Mundy.

Should average the same and share the same bye

As close as it gets to a coin flip

Smith much older, but I reckon Mundy has the better ceiling and chance to average a couple of points more

Can't go wrong with either
[/quote

Im going Mundy, because after the stellar year 2018 Devon had, still didn't ton up and I'm not sure he has too much more in him.
Also see he's now got a bicep injury which just means pick Mundy. Thanks RD.