Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Hawka]

Im most likely picking both cause im a bias cow but interested on non hawks fans opinion
Wingard >( probs higher priced rookie)
Worp > mid price middie (Libba, Miles etc)

really wanna start both though :(

[Bluesman]

Some opinions/advice would be appreciated

A) Sicily + Macrae + Walsh + 123k Forward rookie  (High end premos and rookie )

vs

B) Z.Williams (D4) + Zerrett + 117K rookie + Gray (F4)

Get more depth with the second option and limit on field rookies. Provides risk in my backline though as D1 is Whitfield then D2 Blakely and D3 Witherden.

B... IMO

[Bluesman]

Can't decide between slightly different structures...although I'm leaning towards a 'GnR' a bit more (option A):
Option A: S.Walsh, Grundy, Rankine
vs
Option B: Libba/Miles, Kreuzer, JJ Kennedy

Feedback most welcome

[TommyC]

Can't decide between slightly different structures...although I'm leaning towards a 'GnR' a bit more (option A):
Option A: S.Walsh, Grundy, Rankine
vs
Option B: Libba/Miles, Kreuzer, JJ Kennedy

Feedback most welcome

Option A... just
Don't trust Kreuzer's body and JJ Kennedy could be a bit hit or miss. I do like Miles though.
Grundy is an easy R1 lock and two rookies should hopefully perform well.

[Southstorm]

Can't decide between slightly different structures...although I'm leaning towards a 'GnR' a bit more (option A):
Option A: S.Walsh, Grundy, Rankine
vs
Option B: Libba/Miles, Kreuzer, JJ Kennedy

Feedback most welcome

Option A, but you could probably find cheaper and better rookies than Walsh and Rankine before Rd. 1 anyway.

[ubeaut]

Can't decide between slightly different structures...although I'm leaning towards a 'GnR' a bit more (option A):
Option A: S.Walsh, Grundy, Rankine
vs
Option B: Libba/Miles, Kreuzer, JJ Kennedy

Feedback most welcome

Option A, but you could probably find cheaper and better rookies than Walsh and Rankine before Rd. 1 anyway.

Yeah Grundy and 2 rookies the go. Walsh may be an OK option but I think there will be far better value options than Rankine in the GC fwd line.
You could also have Kreuz to partner Grundy and/or find a way to fit Libba/Miles in.

[Mantis]

Can't decide between slightly different structures...although I'm leaning towards a 'GnR' a bit more (option A):
Option A: S.Walsh, Grundy, Rankine
vs
Option B: Libba/Miles, Kreuzer, JJ Kennedy

Feedback most welcome

I think Grundy is a must so would go option A. I do have kruezer at R2 though but happy to take a risk for that spot. Also a lot of injury risk with all of those in B.


Cripps + Wingard
Vs
Neale + Dunkley

[Keeper27]

Miles (M6) & Greene (F4) vs. Libba (M6) & JJK (F4)

[TommyC]

Can't decide between slightly different structures...although I'm leaning towards a 'GnR' a bit more (option A):
Option A: S.Walsh, Grundy, Rankine
vs
Option B: Libba/Miles, Kreuzer, JJ Kennedy

Feedback most welcome

I think Grundy is a must so would go option A. I do have kruezer at R2 though but happy to take a risk for that spot. Also a lot of injury risk with all of those in B.


Cripps + Wingard
Vs
Neale + Dunkley

Cripps and Wingard
Cripps is a gun and I am very keen on Wingard.

[TommyC]

Miles (M6) & Greene (F4) vs. Libba (M6) & JJK (F4)

Miles and Greene, both have great potential.
Libba risky and JJK hit and miss.

[Keeper27]

Miles (M6) & Greene (F4) vs. Libba (M6) & JJK (F4)

Miles and Greene, both have great potential.
Libba risky and JJK hit and miss.

JJK is a 90 point player though

[TommyC]

Miles (M6) & Greene (F4) vs. Libba (M6) & JJK (F4)

Miles and Greene, both have great potential.
Libba risky and JJK hit and miss.

JJK is a 90 point player though

If he doesn't kick goals he doesn't score well, averaged 73 from 11 games last year.
However, he has a big ceiling and can pump out big scores.
Hence my hit or miss comment, could either be a great pick, or could be too inconsistent.

[Ringo]

Miles (M6) & Greene (F4) vs. Libba (M6) & JJK (F4)

Miles and Greene, both have great potential.
Libba risky and JJK hit and miss.

JJK is a 90 point player though

If he doesn't kick goals he doesn't score well, averaged 73 from 11 games last year.
However, he has a big ceiling and can pump out big scores.
Hence my hit or miss comment, could either be a great pick, or could be too inconsistent.

Yerp JJK is hit and miss Has played 28 games for 2017/18 and has only 8 scores more than 100 but 13 below 80 so risk there. Does not seem to have gotten back to his 2016 highs.

[PassivePenguin]

Grundy + Kreuzer vs S.Martin + Goldstein

[TommyC]

Grundy + Kreuzer vs S.Martin + Goldstein

Grundy + Kreuzer
Grundy is a must have.
I also prefer Kreuzer over Goldstein.