Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Ringo]

BCrouch and Dunkley
Vs
Coniglio and Greene + 100k?

Coniglio and Greene+100k.  The 100k could be handy for corrective trades which I usually do Rd 3.

[TommyC]

BCrouch and Dunkley
Vs
Coniglio and Greene + 100k?

Coniglio and Greene+100k.  The 100k could be handy for corrective trades which I usually do Rd 3.

[juzztheball]

Wilkie vs Joyce vs McKay for last rookie spot in Defence???

[HoleMeal]

Wilkie vs Joyce vs McKay for last rookie spot in Defence???

[HoleMeal]

J Elliot and L Ryan vs Balta and Lloyd

[juzztheball]

Wilkie vs Joyce vs McKay for last rookie spot in Defence???

S Thompson to come back in next week though??

[westfisker]

Heath Shaw & scrimshaw
Vs
Z.williams and Ridley

Have already taken way too many risks and thinking of going gun rookie.

[Mat0369]

I prefer Ridley to Scrimshaw and Shaw to Williams. I think Williams/Ridley probably gives you more flexibility. Worst case you can always downgrade to Scrimshaw if he goes nuts.

[Mat0369]

Laird, Williams, Scrimshaw and 80k

vs

Hurn, Shaw, Scrimshaw and 60k

vs

Laird, Shaw, Duursma and 15k

vs

Shaw, Witherden, Scrimshaw and 128k

I'm probably leaning towards option 2 after watching how the kick ins were able to boost Moore's score last night. Shaw and Hurn will be the dedicated kick in guys, although I really do want to keep Laird...

[tommy10]

Laird, Williams, Scrimshaw and 80k

vs

Hurn, Shaw, Scrimshaw and 60k

vs

Laird, Shaw, Duursma and 15k

vs

Shaw, Witherden, Scrimshaw and 128k

I'm probably leaning towards option 2 after watching how the kick ins were able to boost Moore's score last night. Shaw and Hurn will be the dedicated kick in guys, although I really do want to keep Laird...

I’d go option 1 mate

[Wanderer]

Option 1: Coniglio (M5) + Collins (D4) + only $5k left in kitty
Option 2: Libba (M5) + Mills (D3) + $54k left in kitty

[AN1611]

Need to pick 2 out of Burgess vs scrimshaw vs hore

Have moore up forward as well

[Mat0369]

I’d go option 1 mate

Any particular reasoning?

Option 1: Coniglio (M5) + Collins (D4) + only $5k left in kitty
Option 2: Libba (M5) + Mills (D3) + $54k left in kitty

I think you probably need a bit more than 5k in the bank so I'll say option 2. I do like Mills, don't like Libba, but I think you have more flexibility in that instance with the cash.

Need to pick 2 out of Burgess vs scrimshaw vs hore

Have moore up forward as well

If Moore was in defense I would have said Burgess. Forward rookies are weak and I don't think Burgess scores well. I'd probably lean towards locking in Scrimshaw and grabbing Hore.

[tommy10]

I’d go option 1 mate

Any particular reasoning?

Just don’t like Shaw but that’s my personal opinion. Don’t think he’ll be top 6 defender imo. You could get Witherden as an option though...

[westfisker]

I’d go option 1 mate

Any particular reasoning?

Just don’t like Shaw but that’s my personal opinion. Don’t think he’ll be top 6 defender imo. You could get Witherden as an option though...

After watching Shaw have his standard 23 kicks jlt 1 with William's playing I want to start him. But it means I cant start Ridley.
Or.. libba vs Cousins?
hawks have got a pretty soft opening 4-5games