Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[GoldDigger]

Laird, Crisp, T Kelly, vs Lloyd, Witherden, Heeney

Lloyd, Witherden, Heeney

Lloyd>Laird
Heeney>Kelly
Crisp>Witherden

2 out of 3 wins it

So the gamble here remains about Kelly's preseason.

[Wanderer]

C.Mills + Smith vs Whitfield + Collins

[TommyC]

C.Mills + Smith vs Whitfield + Collins

Maybe be alone with this.
But Mills and Smith.

[walloo44]

Final decision for me:

Fyfe + dusty
Vs
Neale + Coniglio

First one has a massive ceiling but obvious risks, second safer but no where near the same ceiling id think.

Fyfe Dusty easy i reckon, barring injury i see the same floor.

I disagree. Fyfe is a huge injury risk right now leading into Round 1 and, depending on how long it takes Caddy to come back (as well as Lynch probably missing this week), Dusty might play a lot of forward early on in the season. Neale and Cogs seems like a way better call. Cogs should improve again on last year with Shiel gone and Neale shouldn't go backwards at the Lions taking Beams's role.

Welp back to square one

[GoldDigger]

C.Mills + Smith vs Whitfield + Collins

Maybe be alone with this.
...

No help here.

[TommyC]

C.Mills + Smith vs Whitfield + Collins

Maybe be alone with this.
...

No help here.

I gave you an answer:

C.Mills + Smith vs Whitfield + Collins

Maybe be alone with this.
But Mills and Smith.

Here is some reasoning.
Mills should get more midfield minutes. Definitely should increase his average by several points.
Smith has been discussed and dissected in all four corners of the forums. I won't say anything that hasn't already been said.
However, that being said, I believe Smith and Mills will average the same, except Smith is obviously cheaper.
If you can afford, Whitfield + Smith would be the favourable option.

[Rusty00]

This one has probably been done, but Libba vs Greene?

Both have scored well in the past, both have injury issues.

Libba (M6) + Prem (F3) vs Greene (F3) + Prem (M5 - Crouch to M6)

[crowls]

pick 2 for M4 & M5
Steele/Lyons/B Crouch/Sheed

I will have 3 of them, you could start Brouch and Steele.

Also agree on Steele and BCrouch, Lyons will likely be in that 95-100 range, and whilst Sheed has put together some really good footy recently, I can't see him keeping that up for a whole season. Would rather spend less and go for Libba, or a touch more for Rocky.

c'mon gl the mans left qld behind him,  gotta stop the love sometime.   not sure if rockcliff gets back to super prem scoring.   all for those that back him as if he does great outcome for you. 

[frenzy]

C.Mills + Smith vs Whitfield + Collins

whit and collins, 1 genuine keeper and 1 rookie with good JS.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Fyfe and Greene
Vs
B Crouch and any forward (thinking Dunkley)

[Keeper27]

Gawn + Atkins + $45k

Or

Goldy + Libba

[imjusflexin]

Fyfe and Greene
Vs
B Crouch and any forward (thinking Dunkley)

Fyfe & Greene

Gawn + Atkins + $45k

Or

Goldy + Libba

Gawn

[GoLions]

pick 2 for M4 & M5
Steele/Lyons/B Crouch/Sheed

I will have 3 of them, you could start Brouch and Steele.

Also agree on Steele and BCrouch, Lyons will likely be in that 95-100 range, and whilst Sheed has put together some really good footy recently, I can't see him keeping that up for a whole season. Would rather spend less and go for Libba, or a touch more for Rocky.

c'mon gl the mans left qld behind him,  gotta stop the love sometime.   not sure if rockcliff gets back to super prem scoring.   all for those that back him as if he does great outcome for you.

Haha, I'm not touching him in SC, but would comfortably take him over BCrouch if i had to pick one. Better scoring potential, price, bye, injury history.

[B.]

Whitfield + rookie M7
Smith + Cousins M7 or 225k to turn a rookie into something else

[LaHug]

This one has probably been done, but Libba vs Greene?

Both have scored well in the past, both have injury issues.

Libba (M6) + Prem (F3) vs Greene (F3) + Prem (M5 - Crouch to M6)

If you can only have one, I'd pick Greene. More likely to be a keeper.