Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Keeper27]

Billings and Dusty

vs.

Neale and Greene

[enzedder]

Whitfield + Billings v Witherden + Kelly

Witherden and Kelly. Both are in my team atm as is Whitfield. Billings is risky. The others are safe picks.

Why is billings risky?

He didn’t do too well last year and he is no guarantee to play in the midfield.

[Holz]

Whitfield + Billings v Witherden + Kelly

Witherden and Kelly. Both are in my team atm as is Whitfield. Billings is risky. The others are safe picks.

Why is billings risky?

He didn’t do too well last year and he is no guarantee to play in the midfield.

looking at a 3rd option

Whitfield Billings B.Scott v Witherden Kelly B.Scott  v   Witherden, Hore, Sloane

[Holz]

Billings and Dusty

vs.

Neale and Greene

Dusty and Greene and use the cash elsewhere.

[LaHug]

Whitfield + Billings v Witherden + Kelly

Witherden and Kelly. Both are in my team atm as is Whitfield. Billings is risky. The others are safe picks.

Why is billings risky?

He didn’t do too well last year and he is no guarantee to play in the midfield.

looking at a 3rd option

Whitfield Billings B.Scott v Witherden Kelly B.Scott  v   Witherden, Hore, Sloane

Third one by the length of the Flemington straight

[Holz]

Whitfield + Billings v Witherden + Kelly

Witherden and Kelly. Both are in my team atm as is Whitfield. Billings is risky. The others are safe picks.

Why is billings risky?

He didn’t do too well last year and he is no guarantee to play in the midfield.

looking at a 3rd option

Whitfield Billings B.Scott v Witherden Kelly B.Scott  v   Witherden, Hore, Sloane

Third one by the length of the Flemington straight

just need hore to play then im all set. No clue if he does or not.

[LaHug]

Whitfield + Billings v Witherden + Kelly

Witherden and Kelly. Both are in my team atm as is Whitfield. Billings is risky. The others are safe picks.

Why is billings risky?

He didn’t do too well last year and he is no guarantee to play in the midfield.

looking at a 3rd option

Whitfield Billings B.Scott v Witherden Kelly B.Scott  v   Witherden, Hore, Sloane

Third one by the length of the Flemington straight

just need hore to play then im all set. No clue if he does or not.

I think he plays and, barring poor form, holds his spot until Lever comes back.

[walloo44]

Final decision for me:

Fyfe + dusty
Vs
Neale + Coniglio

First one has a massive ceiling but obvious risks, second safer but no where near the same ceiling id think.

[Holz]

Final decision for me:

Fyfe + dusty
Vs
Neale + Coniglio

First one has a massive ceiling but obvious risks, second safer but no where near the same ceiling id think.

Fyfe Dusty easy i reckon, barring injury i see the same floor.

[LaHug]

Final decision for me:

Fyfe + dusty
Vs
Neale + Coniglio

First one has a massive ceiling but obvious risks, second safer but no where near the same ceiling id think.

Fyfe Dusty easy i reckon, barring injury i see the same floor.

I disagree. Fyfe is a huge injury risk right now leading into Round 1 and, depending on how long it takes Caddy to come back (as well as Lynch probably missing this week), Dusty might play a lot of forward early on in the season. Neale and Cogs seems like a way better call. Cogs should improve again on last year with Shiel gone and Neale shouldn't go backwards at the Lions taking Beams's role.

[maygs]

Moore v Collins?

Which will score better and which will make the most money as I don't expect either to be keepers - or am I wrong about that as well?

Neither keepers unless Moore over-performs..

As for cash generation, if Collins averages 70 until R12, he'll make about 150k. He could definitely score less though and then he'll make less, but he'll still be around 300k which is perfect for downgrading to a rookie mid-season.

If Moore averages 75 (my prediction) up to R12, he'll make 120k. But with his role he could easily average more.. Many have him scoring 80+.

Thanks mate

[kilbluff1985]

Laird, Crisp, T Kelly, vs Lloyd, Witherden, Heeney

[GoldDigger]

Laird, Crisp, T Kelly, vs Lloyd, Witherden, Heeney

The first for mine. Llloyd's preseason compromised. May cost a trade. For me that would be enough.

[tommy10]

Final decision for me:

Fyfe + dusty
Vs
Neale + Coniglio

First one has a massive ceiling but obvious risks, second safer but no where near the same ceiling id think.

I would say Neale and Dusty. Dusty will play mostly in the midfield especially with Tom Lynch likely playing round 1.

[Wanderer]

Laird, Crisp, T Kelly, vs Lloyd, Witherden, Heeney

Lloyd, Witherden, Heeney

Lloyd>Laird
Heeney>Kelly
Crisp>Witherden

2 out of 3 wins it