Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Wanderer]

Slightly altered my team from mid rookie to a couple of mid pricers

What combo is better

1. Whitfield (Def) B.Scott (Mid) Burgess (Fwd)

2. B. Smith, J. Cousins, D Moore

Hard to say without seeing the rest of your team.

Option 1 gives you a keeper, so maybe option 1 for that reason. If B.Smith can become top 6 defender then option 2.

[GoLions]

Harris Andrews vs Crisp

Hand

I assume you mean hand as in harris andrews and not hand as in starny93

[sammy123]

Harris Andrews vs Crisp

Crisp

[hawkers65]

Harris Andrews vs Crisp

Hand

I assume you mean hand as in harris andrews and not hand as in starny93

H.ANDrews

[Ringo]

Still a little concerned with the Andrews experiment forward,  Not going away in discussions especially with Gardiner a possibility to line up Rd 1. So Crisp. 

[Commander]

Which combo would you prefer?

Angus Brayshaw M6 T.Greene F3 D.Moore F4

Libba M6 J.Billings F3 Worpel F4

B.Crouch M6 T.Boak F3 D.Moore F4

[LaHug]

Which combo would you prefer?

Angus Brayshaw M6 T.Greene F3 D.Moore F4

Libba M6 J.Billings F3 Worpel F4

B.Crouch M6 T.Boak F3 D.Moore F4

1 slightly better than 3 which is way better than 2. 2 is yuck

[GoLions]

Harris Andrews vs Crisp

Hand

I assume you mean hand as in harris andrews and not hand as in starny93

H.ANDrews

HstArNy93D

[_wato]

Cannot split these two guns.

Fyfe v Oliver

[RoughRed]

Cannot split these two guns.

Fyfe v Oliver

Oliver ... imo,  as said in in many discussion fyfe is prone to missing games ...

[_wato]

Cannot split these two guns.

Fyfe v Oliver

Oliver ... imo,  as said in in many discussion fyfe is prone to missing games ...

Yes but Fyfe's scoring potential is greater than Oliver's and this article has me seriously interested.

https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-03-15/will-fyfes-secret-tweaks-help-him-play-every-game

[RaisyDaisy]

Cannot split these two guns.

Fyfe v Oliver

Oliver ... imo,  as said in in many discussion fyfe is prone to missing games ...

Yes but Fyfe's scoring potential is greater than Oliver's and this article has me seriously interested.

https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-03-15/will-fyfes-secret-tweaks-help-him-play-every-game

Well of course he is going to be optimistic and believe he can play 22, but that doesn't really mean much at the end of the day

Still, super hard choice because a fit Fyfe is close to if not the best player in the game. Has a nice bye too, and for that reason I am looking to bring him in straight after his bye

[tommy10]

Laird & Macrae vs Lloyd & Oliver

[TableKing]

Whitfield v Williams??? Both is not an option

My thoughts
Whitfield has runs on the board and on the up. Could get thrown around the ground this season ie wing and forward. So not sure if this will impact his score.
Williams will av 20 possessions and hit targets across the backline. See him av 90.

Who to select?

[walloo44]

Whitfield v Williams??? Both is not an option

My thoughts
Whitfield has runs on the board and on the up. Could get thrown around the ground this season ie wing and forward. So not sure if this will impact his score.
Williams will av 20 possessions and hit targets across the backline. See him av 90.

Who to select?

If you’ve got the money, Whitfield for me. Safer pick who we know is fit and firing with a better scoring history.