Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[GoLions]

Tim Kelly vs Robbie Gray

Here's my take, Kelly probably spends more time in the guts with Ablett playing forward although there might be some readjustment if Geelong slides & Kelly still wants out. This has always been my concern. Robbie Gray has stated his midfield minutes will increase but with Boak & Rocky spending more time in the middle who knows really. Quite torn on this but have given the slightest edge to Kelly on the grounds he's cheaper. Thoughts?

I'm currently on Kelly. Tempted by Boak a bit more than Gray at this stage tbh

[Bully]

Tim Kelly vs Robbie Gray

Here's my take, Kelly probably spends more time in the guts with Ablett playing forward although there might be some readjustment if Geelong slides & Kelly still wants out. This has always been my concern. Robbie Gray has stated his midfield minutes will increase but with Boak & Rocky spending more time in the middle who knows really. Quite torn on this but have given the slightest edge to Kelly on the grounds he's cheaper. Thoughts?

I'm currently on Kelly. Tempted by Boak a bit more than Gray at this stage tbh

Boak a pretty safe selection, not sure about upside, probably around the 90 mark which is solid for a bloke who rarely misses any football. Certainly one to consider.

[crowls]

Boak vs Mundy

I actually don't mind going both. Its boring and not very flashy but both are teeing up a big ramp up in midifeld time. Wouldn't be shocked to see both finish with high 90s averages - Boak for me if I had to choose

had both at different stages in preseason.  starting boak atm

[walloo44]

couple of 50/50's I need a second opinion on:

1. Hurn v Harris Andrews

2. M.crouch v Neale

3. Boak v Kelly

[hawkers65]

couple of 50/50's I need a second opinion on:

1. Hurn v Harris Andrews

2. M.crouch v Neale

3. Boak v Kelly

Andrews, Crouch, Kelly

[crowls]

couple of 50/50's I need a second opinion on:

1. Hurn v Harris Andrews

2. M.crouch v Neale

3. Boak v Kelly

Andrews, Crouch, Kelly

hurn, and others so 50/50 go with best bye structure or cash option

[B.]

Coniglio v Martin v Neale v M Crouch ???

[crowls]

Coniglio v Martin v Neale v M Crouch ???

all been in my team at one stage.   Gone Neale,     if rating them Neale, Crouch, Cogs and Martin

[Thewizz71]

Coniglio v Martin v Neale v M Crouch ???

all been in my team at one stage.   Gone Neale,     if rating them Neale, Crouch, Cogs and Martin

Running with Cogs and Crouch atm.

B Crouch v Sheed.

Also still flipping between Mundy v Boak?

[jfitty]

This would have been asked in some form I’m sure, but struggling to pick 2 between Fyfe, Neale and Kelly.

Just can’t split them!

[hawkers65]

This would have been asked in some form I’m sure, but struggling to pick 2 between Fyfe, Neale and Kelly.

Just can’t split them!

Fyfe and Neale

[_wato]

This would have been asked in some form I’m sure, but struggling to pick 2 between Fyfe, Neale and Kelly.

Just can’t split them!

Fyfe and Neale

Surely can't pick Kelly after everything that happened last year. Literally a ghost in preseason again, nobody knows anything.

[walloo44]

2 alternatives:

a) Hurn + Boak + Gawn

b) Laird + menegola + Goldy

also is miles to B.crouch worth downgrading laird or gola to boak or hurn respectively.

[Money Shot]

2 alternatives:

a) Hurn + Boak + Gawn

b) Laird + menegola + Goldy

also is miles to B.crouch worth downgrading laird or gola to boak or hurn respectively.

Option A for me. Would definitely try and get Crouch in over Miles though. Otherwise Libba.

[Money Shot]

Brad vs Matt who will average more? Is Matt the obvious choice if I can find the funds?