Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[smashbox]

I’ve lost sleep over this decision.
Bont or Treloar!

[Woppa15]

I’ve lost sleep over this decision.
Bont or Treloar!

I have been stuck on this also, decided to go with the Bont simply because of the lower price. Not much else splitting them otherwise, almost went Zorko purely because of the lower ownership

[smashbox]

Me to I went Bont essentially for that as well, and allowed me to bring Kelly in next week for crouch if he returns

[Hazza09]

So I have a real tough decision to make this week, Zorko has to go with his hammy and I’m officially done with Sheed.

Bont & Dusty

Or

Treloar & R Gray

[Thewizz71]

So I have a real tough decision to make this week, Zorko has to go with his hammy and I’m officially done with Sheed.

Bont & Dusty

Or

Treloar & R Gray

Bont and Dusty.

Whitfield or Williams?

[Hazza09]

So I have a real tough decision to make this week, Zorko has to go with his hammy and I’m officially done with Sheed.

Bont & Dusty

Or

Treloar & R Gray

Bont and Dusty.

Whitfield or Williams?

Cheers mate!

Both are quality, but Whitfield, can play all over the ground and has the potential to go large.

[tommy10]

So I have a real tough decision to make this week, Zorko has to go with his hammy and I’m officially done with Sheed.

Bont & Dusty

Or

Treloar & R Gray

Bont and Dusty.

Whitfield or Williams?

Bont & Dusty for me too.

Williams has been great this year but would go Whitfield.

[Blues Blues Blues]

So I have a real tough decision to make this week, Zorko has to go with his hammy and I’m officially done with Sheed.

Bont & Dusty

Or

Treloar & R Gray

Bont and Dusty for sure

[Blues Blues Blues]

Sloane vs Dusty

I have Sloane, thinking of using last trade to turn him into Dusty.

Sloane has shat me all year since I grabbed him. Dusty has 3 games at the G coming and looks in good form.

[enzedder]

Last trade.
Daniel to >

Robinson (3 over 100 in last four games). DPP too but with only three games left probably won't need it. 2.4% POD
Westhoff (Ruck cover - Bines DPP in Rucks) Gawn and Grundy insurance. 7.4% POD
Hawkins (massive ceiling) Next opponents and most recent two scores against NM- 127,100, Bris- 105, 151, Carl- 192, 84. 4.3% POD

All have risk. Cons
Robinson - inconsistent 60s -120s
Westhoff - likely 70s-80s
Hawkins - KPP dud score... R15/16  50s

As I have JCameron as F7 I'm hopeful he'll play and score well. I can loophole him with Daniel and save the trade. That's my first play.
Leaning towards Hawkins otherwise. Not 100% on it though.

[enzedder]

Sloane vs Dusty

I have Sloane, thinking of using last trade to turn him into Dusty.

Sloane has shat me all year since I grabbed him. Dusty has 3 games at the G coming and looks in good form.

Depends on your cover situation.
If you have an unexpected out and end up copping doughnut(s) in R22/23 you are worse off on what you could gain.
No guarantee Dusty will outscore Sloane.
Sloane is playing.


All reasons I wouldn't do it. Last trade is precious with games to come.

[tkringle]

Last trade.
Daniel to >

Robinson (3 over 100 in last four games). DPP too but with only three games left probably won't need it. 2.4% POD
Westhoff (Ruck cover - Bines DPP in Rucks) Gawn and Grundy insurance. 7.4% POD
Hawkins (massive ceiling) Next opponents and most recent two scores against NM- 127,100, Bris- 105, 151, Carl- 192, 84. 4.3% POD

All have risk. Cons
Robinson - inconsistent 60s -120s
Westhoff - likely 70s-80s
Hawkins - KPP dud score... R15/16  50s

As I have JCameron as F7 I'm hopeful he'll play and score well. I can loophole him with Daniel and save the trade. That's my first play.
Leaning towards Hawkins otherwise. Not 100% on it though.

Westhoff for the insurance. Hopefully you can loop him and Cameron if he is back as well

[enzedder]

Last trade.
Daniel to >

Robinson (3 over 100 in last four games). DPP too but with only three games left probably won't need it. 2.4% POD
Westhoff (Ruck cover - Bines DPP in Rucks) Gawn and Grundy insurance. 7.4% POD
Hawkins (massive ceiling) Next opponents and most recent two scores against NM- 127,100, Bris- 105, 151, Carl- 192, 84. 4.3% POD

All have risk. Cons
Robinson - inconsistent 60s -120s
Westhoff - likely 70s-80s
Hawkins - KPP dud score... R15/16  50s

As I have JCameron as F7 I'm hopeful he'll play and score well. I can loophole him with Daniel and save the trade. That's my first play.
Leaning towards Hawkins otherwise. Not 100% on it though.

Westhoff for the insurance. Hopefully you can loop him and Cameron if he is back as well

Other options are defensive ones: Stewart/Simpson/Rich/Sicily/Crisp. I can move Dunkley to fwds, Duursma to mids. Essentially no worse off.
Hopper is probably the best mid on offer. Rocky is never again haha.
So Stewart (96.6) v Hopper (95.8 ) v Westhoff (78.8 ) v Hawkins (89.7 )
Leaning towards Stewart now.

[strikeforce]

Last trade.
Daniel to >

Robinson (3 over 100 in last four games). DPP too but with only three games left probably won't need it. 2.4% POD
Westhoff (Ruck cover - Bines DPP in Rucks) Gawn and Grundy insurance. 7.4% POD
Hawkins (massive ceiling) Next opponents and most recent two scores against NM- 127,100, Bris- 105, 151, Carl- 192, 84. 4.3% POD

All have risk. Cons
Robinson - inconsistent 60s -120s
Westhoff - likely 70s-80s
Hawkins - KPP dud score... R15/16  50s

As I have JCameron as F7 I'm hopeful he'll play and score well. I can loophole him with Daniel and save the trade. That's my first play.
Leaning towards Hawkins otherwise. Not 100% on it though.

Westhoff for the insurance. Hopefully you can loop him and Cameron if he is back as well

Other options are defensive ones: Stewart/Simpson/Rich/Sicily/Crisp. I can move Dunkley to fwds, Duursma to mids. Essentially no worse off.
Hopper is probably the best mid on offer. Rocky is never again haha.
So Stewart (96.6) v Hopper (95.8 ) v Westhoff (78.8 ) v Hawkins (89.7 )
Leaning towards Stewart now.

The little master

[enzedder]

Considered him. Certainly a POD and now like a box of Chocolates you never know who you are going to get. The little master or Forest Gump.