Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[tommy10]

Hind vs Naish

[LaHug]

Hind vs Naish

Obviously wait for teams with some Tigers set to come back in but I would be leaning more towards Naish right now. Different positions though so the most important factor should be what leaves you with the best team setup (in terms of cover and DPP flexibility).

[TommyC]

Hind vs Naish

Obviously wait for teams with some Tigers set to come back in but I would be leaning more towards Naish right now. Different positions though so the most important factor should be what leaves you with the best team setup (in terms of cover and DPP flexibility).

[enzedder]

Hind vs Naish

Hind was one of only three Saints to publically get a pass from the coach.
Will have solid JS I'd say. He's come straight in and impressed from the go. Won't kick three goals each game obviously but should provide okay bench cover.
Naish has less JS according to some posters here with astute knowledge of the Tigers' best 22 and who's coming back into the team.

For that reason I'd say Hind but as a Naish owner I'm hopeful he'll stay around as my defensive cover is reliant on his shoulders now Gardner has found himself on the outs.

[AN1611]

Sloane vs bont vs treloar

Looking to replace rocky if he misses this week (unless dylan clark goes 80+)

[Bully]

Sloane vs bont vs treloar

Looking to replace rocky if he misses this week (unless dylan clark goes 80+)

Sloane

[RoughRed]

Sloane vs bont vs treloar

Looking to replace rocky if he misses this week (unless dylan clark goes 80+)

Sloane

Sloane on those

My dilemma is Sloane v Henderson v Merrett for my final mid

Have Cripps Cogs, Fyfe, Macrae, Neale, Oliver and Sheed and 8 trades after this week (2)

Thoughts

[Blues Blues Blues]

Trade Hore or Brodie Smith to Logue?

[Bully]

Trade Hore or Brodie Smith to Logue?

Hore, at least we know Smith is good for 85, can't say for sure Hore can maintain that average.

[tommy10]

Obviously wait for teams with some Tigers set to come back in but I would be leaning more towards Naish right now. Different positions though so the most important factor should be what leaves you with the best team setup (in terms of cover and DPP flexibility).
[/quote]

[/quote]
Hind was one of only three Saints to publically get a pass from the coach.
Will have solid JS I'd say. He's come straight in and impressed from the go. Won't kick three goals each game obviously but should provide okay bench cover.
Naish has less JS according to some posters here with astute knowledge of the Tigers' best 22 and who's coming back into the team.

For that reason I'd say Hind but as a Naish owner I'm hopeful he'll stay around as my defensive cover is reliant on his shoulders now Gardner has found himself on the outs.

[/quote]
Thanks fellas. Was leaning towards Naish too but will wait on teams obviously and make a decision.

[Wanderer]

Trade Hore or Brodie Smith to Logue?

Hore, at least we know Smith is good for 85, can't say for sure Hore can maintain that average.

Hore was the front runner last few weeks and was touted as a potential D6 but after one average game people are jumping off.

[Bully]

Trade Hore or Brodie Smith to Logue?

Hore, at least we know Smith is good for 85, can't say for sure Hore can maintain that average.

Hore was the front runner last few weeks and was touted as a potential D6 but after one average game people are jumping off.

Still a very small sample size for Hore, always a risk holding. Could turn out ok but he might also lose a truckload of cash.

[Wanderer]

Trade Hore or Brodie Smith to Logue?

Hore, at least we know Smith is good for 85, can't say for sure Hore can maintain that average.

Hore was the front runner last few weeks and was touted as a potential D6 but after one average game people are jumping off.

Still a very small sample size for Hore, always a risk holding. Could turn out ok but he might also lose a truckload of cash.

I'm not advocating to keep Hore, but if it was between him and Smith, isn't Smith forecasted to bleed more cash this week?

[Bully]

Trade Hore or Brodie Smith to Logue?

Hore, at least we know Smith is good for 85, can't say for sure Hore can maintain that average.

Hore was the front runner last few weeks and was touted as a potential D6 but after one average game people are jumping off.

Still a very small sample size for Hore, always a risk holding. Could turn out ok but he might also lose a truckload of cash.

I'm not advocating to keep Hore, but if it was between him and Smith, isn't Smith forecasted to bleed more cash this week?

Both due to bleed cash so pick your poison, I'm ditching both this week & rolling the dice with Logue at D6 for a few weeks.

[Wanderer]

Trade Hore or Brodie Smith to Logue?

Hore, at least we know Smith is good for 85, can't say for sure Hore can maintain that average.

Hore was the front runner last few weeks and was touted as a potential D6 but after one average game people are jumping off.

Still a very small sample size for Hore, always a risk holding. Could turn out ok but he might also lose a truckload of cash.

I'm not advocating to keep Hore, but if it was between him and Smith, isn't Smith forecasted to bleed more cash this week?

Both due to bleed cash so pick your poison, I'm ditching both this week & rolling the dice with Logue at D6 for a few weeks.

I ditched Smith last week and considering Hore to Logue this week.