Player X vs Player Y - 2019

[Wanderer]

Walters Or Caleb Daniel?

I've been back and forth on this tough decision all week, but I've settled on Walters - purely for his high scoring ceiling, decent CBA numbers, easy draw and just the fact that he is generally an exciting player to cheer on.

His questionable durability, low scoring floor and the fact he was never averaged over 88 in a season are the risks - but I'm willing to take a punt that he has finally taken that next step to superstar status.

If you need to take a risk to move up the rankings then Walters, but if you are in a strong position at this stage of the year then go Daniel and consolidate your position with less risk.

[MontyJnr]

What do people think on ranking Neale, Crouch, Bont, and Oliver?

Neale by a mile, Bont, Oliver then a long way down crouch

Is Matt Crouch really a long way off Oliver this year? Take out the Port game where he didn't play the 2nd half due to injury and he is averaging 107.3, which would place him higher than Oliver's 106.8 average.

[GoLions]

Will chuck this here as well

Baker to Dunkley, Setters/Young on bench

or

Setters to Rowan/Walters, Baker/Young on bench

Feel like Dunkley is a must, but expensive and dont wanna rely on Setters as cover aha. Already have: Danger, Boak, TKelly, Caleb, Heeney

Thoughts?

[Dmoney$]

Clayton Oliver vs Marcus Bontempelli?

Bont

I would choose Oliver due to being a perma mid vs Bont who will be pushed forward more.

Tend to agree, with Gardner out & Schache looking like he's out of his depth the chances of a return to the forward line have increased markedly. This was the factor behind my Sloane vs Bont decision.

Thanks guys

[LaHug]

Can people not get Walters please? He's literally the only good thing going for my team as a POD...



Due to not having any players or any cash this week, I need to bring in and field one of Rhylee West and Nick Hind. Who scores more? If they get dropped next week, it doesn't really matter...

[HappyDEZ]

Can people not get Walters please? He's literally the only good thing going for my team as a POD...



Due to not having any players or any cash this week, I need to bring in and field one of Rhylee West and Nick Hind. Who scores more? If they get dropped next week, it doesn't really matter...

If West makes the 22 it has to be West. If he is half as good as his old man he may even be a keeper. Seriously tho, def West of those 2.

[Wanderer]

Can people not get Walters please? He's literally the only good thing going for my team as a POD...



Due to not having any players or any cash this week, I need to bring in and field one of Rhylee West and Nick Hind. Who scores more? If they get dropped next week, it doesn't really matter...

If West makes the 22 it has to be West. If he is half as good as his old man he may even be a keeper. Seriously tho, def West of those 2.

West is best.

[Wanderer]

Dunkley vs T.Kelly

[no eye deer]

Dunkley vs T.Kelly

Kelly just.

Seriously considering going Oliver instead of Neale this week. Cash saved, Neale seems to have slowed, tagged out of it last game, Oliver ramping up.

Head says Neale though. Talk me out of it!

[LaHug]

Can people not get Walters please? He's literally the only good thing going for my team as a POD...



Due to not having any players or any cash this week, I need to bring in and field one of Rhylee West and Nick Hind. Who scores more? If they get dropped next week, it doesn't really matter...

If West makes the 22 it has to be West. If he is half as good as his old man he may even be a keeper. Seriously tho, def West of those 2.

West is best.

And he wasn't named :( Bring on a 40 from Hind!

[Thewizz71]

Can people not get Walters please? He's literally the only good thing going for my team as a POD...



Due to not having any players or any cash this week, I need to bring in and field one of Rhylee West and Nick Hind. Who scores more? If they get dropped next week, it doesn't really matter...

If West makes the 22 it has to be West. If he is half as good as his old man he may even be a keeper. Seriously tho, def West of those 2.

West is best.

And he wasn't named :( Bring on a 40 from Hind!

Hind early vs Bewley late?

[YoungGun]

T Kelly v C Daniel

[tkringle]

T Kelly v C Daniel

Daniel it pains me to say as a Kelly owner.. reckon teams are going to clamp down on Kelly more in the tail end of the year.

[Thewizz71]

T Kelly v C Daniel

Daniel it pains me to say as a Kelly owner.. reckon teams are going to clamp down on Kelly more in the tail end of the year.

Have both.
Kelly = tag. Daniel = needs lots of it.
Daniel for me. More consistent.

Sloane v Merret v Bont. See all being very similar for the rest of the year. Might save some $$$ by going Sloane.

[RoughRed]

T Kelly v C Daniel

Daniel it pains me to say as a Kelly owner.. reckon teams are going to clamp down on Kelly more in the tail end of the year.

Have both.
Kelly = tag. Daniel = needs lots of it.
Daniel for me. More consistent.

Sloane v Merret v Bont. See all being very similar for the rest of the year. Might save some $$$ by going Sloane.

I think Sloane>Bont>Merret
No real science to my selection but Adelaide have the better ruck so that's just gotta help