2019 Rookies

[RaisyDaisy]

Watch that cash gen pump now :)

[enzedder]

Double Upgrade week for many coming up.
Two games...
Noah Answerth 117k Def/Mid
Nick Larkey 123k Fwd Scores of 75 & 40
Joshua Corbett 123k Fwd Scores of 55 & 59
Jackson Hately 148k Mid Scores of 95 & 85
Darragh Joyce 123k Def Scores of 67 & 60
Dylan Moore 123k Fwd Scores of 40 & 74
One game...
Declan Keilty 123k Def Score 40
Liam Stocker 126k Mid plays today.
Jonathan Marsh 163k Def Score 56
Isaac Cumming 173k Def Score 37

Answerth looks a monty to come into my team with scores of 69 & 67, DPP link with Lockhart/ Duursma. Probably trading Atkins.
One of Corbett/ Larkey is likely to be my other trade for one of Parker/Petrucelle.

[Bully]

Hately tempting but JS the worry, still not sure if I'll take the plunge. Answerth locked, perfect trade in for Duursma.

[Money Shot]

Hately comes in for me next week if he is named. Perfect M8 for now.

Answorth looks pretty good as well. Could come in for Wilkie.

Going to the game today so will watch Larkey for this week and Stocker for next.

[RaisyDaisy]

Hately clearly the pick of the bunch but I'll probably pass - just like Rotham he's only going to play due to injuries - JS is just too dicey I think

[Bully]

Hately clearly the pick of the bunch but I'll probably pass - just like Rotham he's only going to play due to injuries - JS is just too dicey I think

This could be a big problem over the bye period, I reckon every rookie selection from here needs to be guys with decent long term viability. There's some chance Hately squeezes in 3 price rises leading up to the bye but there's also a chance he gets dropped.

[SilverLion]

Watched Answerth closely in our game, was surprised he got 72. Made some big errors, Papley caught him out twice in the third and got Sydney back into it.

Reckon he needs more time in the NEAFL to hone his craft and could be dropped this week.

[enzedder]

Watched Answerth closely in our game, was surprised he got 72. Made some big errors, Papley caught him out twice in the third and got Sydney back into it.

Reckon he needs more time in the NEAFL to hone his craft and could be dropped this week.

Answerth JS is a worry. Bailey is due back. One bad game?

[SilverLion]

Watched Answerth closely in our game, was surprised he got 72. Made some big errors, Papley caught him out twice in the third and got Sydney back into it.

Reckon he needs more time in the NEAFL to hone his craft and could be dropped this week.

Answerth JS is a worry. Bailey is due back. One bad game?

Yeah if Bailey wasn't available he would probably get another chance, but yeah would be surprised if he didn't come in for him.

[Bully]

Watched Answerth closely in our game, was surprised he got 72. Made some big errors, Papley caught him out twice in the third and got Sydney back into it.

Reckon he needs more time in the NEAFL to hone his craft and could be dropped this week.

Answerth JS is a worry. Bailey is due back. One bad game?

Yeah if Bailey wasn't available he would probably get another chance, but yeah would be surprised if he didn't come in for him.

Think it's pretty remote that there would be too many changes, winning almost guarantees a place. Only 1 clanger for Answerth, 3 free kicks for, none against.

[SilverLion]

Watched Answerth closely in our game, was surprised he got 72. Made some big errors, Papley caught him out twice in the third and got Sydney back into it.

Reckon he needs more time in the NEAFL to hone his craft and could be dropped this week.

Answerth JS is a worry. Bailey is due back. One bad game?

Yeah if Bailey wasn't available he would probably get another chance, but yeah would be surprised if he didn't come in for him.

Think it's pretty remote that there would be too many changes, winning almost guarantees a place. Only 1 clanger for Answerth, 3 free kicks for, none against.

Didn't say he gave away frees, was just caught out of position in a couple of key moments. I'm giving you a supporter's POV, rather than an SC coach's (Ofc I'd love him to hold his spot for SC ;)). Last one in, first one out is generally how it goes and if Bailey's fit he comes in.

FWIW, I think we should drop Rayner too as he's been pretty ordinary all year, but doubt we will.

[RaisyDaisy]

Who do I want? Hately and Answerth

Who will I likely get? Corbett and Joyce

[SilverLion]

Who do I want? Hately and Answerth

Who will I likely get? Corbett and Joyce

[Bully]

Watched Answerth closely in our game, was surprised he got 72. Made some big errors, Papley caught him out twice in the third and got Sydney back into it.

Reckon he needs more time in the NEAFL to hone his craft and could be dropped this week.

Answerth JS is a worry. Bailey is due back. One bad game?

Yeah if Bailey wasn't available he would probably get another chance, but yeah would be surprised if he didn't come in for him.

Think it's pretty remote that there would be too many changes, winning almost guarantees a place. Only 1 clanger for Answerth, 3 free kicks for, none against.

Didn't say he gave away frees, was just caught out of position in a couple of key moments. I'm giving you a supporter's POV, rather than an SC coach's (Ofc I'd love him to hold his spot for SC ;)). Last one in, first one out is generally how it goes and if Bailey's fit he comes in.

FWIW, I think we should drop Rayner too as he's been pretty ordinary all year, but doubt we will.

I saw the game too & I thought the positives definitely outweighed the negatives, commentators also agreed that he acquitted himself well. Will pick him 100% if named.

[Ringo]

Watched Answerth closely in our game, was surprised he got 72. Made some big errors, Papley caught him out twice in the third and got Sydney back into it.

Reckon he needs more time in the NEAFL to hone his craft and could be dropped this week.

Answerth JS is a worry. Bailey is due back. One bad game?

Yeah if Bailey wasn't available he would probably get another chance, but yeah would be surprised if he didn't come in for him.

Think it's pretty remote that there would be too many changes, winning almost guarantees a place. Only 1 clanger for Answerth, 3 free kicks for, none against.

Didn't say he gave away frees, was just caught out of position in a couple of key moments. I'm giving you a supporter's POV, rather than an SC coach's (Ofc I'd love him to hold his spot for SC ;)). Last one in, first one out is generally how it goes and if Bailey's fit he comes in.

FWIW, I think we should drop Rayner too as he's been pretty ordinary all year, but doubt we will.

I saw the game too & I thought the positives definitely outweighed the negatives, commentators also agreed that he acquitted himself well. Will pick him 100% if named.

I was at the game too and know not the coach but I think Witherden also needs a spell in NEAFL. Last year his kicks were spot on finding targets whereas this year he seems to be second guessing a lot and getting ball turned over.
Squizzy still not taking the opportunity so he could go for Bailey instead.
If Hipwood is suspended (and do not think he will be but who knows with the MRP) Wooller will definitely come in. If form shown in NEAFL is carried over real pressure will be put on McStay and Andrews.