2019 Rookies

[IntegralX]

I think I’ll pass on Stack in anticipation of Ross the following week. I’m thinking Jetta might come in for Masten but yes the JS concrrns are there.

That being said, Butters for Rotham looks like the trade. No way Butters survives after his performance today. (Although that’s what we said about Gibbons)

Barley watched the game, but Butters has been excellent the previous 3 weeks. Surprisingly the Port rookies have been really important for them in the first 3 weeks. They won't drop him over 1 where he struggled a bit

He didn’t just “struggle a bit”. He was far and away the worst player on the pitch.

[Rusty00]

I think I’ll pass on Stack in anticipation of Ross the following week. I’m thinking Jetta might come in for Masten but yes the JS concrrns are there.

That being said, Butters for Rotham looks like the trade. No way Butters survives after his performance today. (Although that’s what we said about Gibbons)

Barley watched the game, but Butters has been excellent the previous 3 weeks. Surprisingly the Port rookies have been really important for them in the first 3 weeks. They won't drop him over 1 where he struggled a bit

He didn’t just “struggle a bit”. He was far and away the worst player on the pitch.

He gave away 2-3 really poor free kicks inside attacking 50 in the last quarter that really hurt the team as well

[sammy123]

Well i might look at clark>hore and butters to a mid premo. Would love to get bont or macrae

[RaisyDaisy]

Burgess
Gibbons
Setterfield
Petrucelle

Definitely dumping 2 of these spuds this week

[Mat0369]

Gibbons looked alright. Was a little unlucky and hit the post twice. Setters is a butcher at the minute. Much better than last week getting to the contest. Burgess looks off it at the minute. They swung him around and he is pretty bad. Can't comment on Petrucelle since I haven't watched him enough.

Balta is Relton Roberts bad.

[RaisyDaisy]

I just mentioned those 4 because they are the 4 I have that are candidates to go

All other rookies still have cash to make and are scoring well

A beautifully timed ton by Wilkie and Scrim today is really going to inject their cash rise now so stoked about that

[Locinator]

I just mentioned those 4 because they are the 4 I have that are candidates to go

All other rookies still have cash to make and are scoring well

A beautifully timed ton by Wilkie and Scrim today is really going to inject their cash rise now so stoked about that

Wouldn't be so quick RD. Agree that they all look average at the moment but Wilkie's scores prior to this week would have seen him also on that list had he got another 50.

I suppose what I'm trying to say is you have no idea which rookies might ton up next week. Fritsch was sitting on a 50 odd average after round 4 last year, many made the mistake of trading him out round 5. He averaged 101 up to his bye.

Worth keeping in mind as most rookies are still below 200k. I think Setters and Gibbons definitely have a bit of cash to generate

[RaisyDaisy]

I just mentioned those 4 because they are the 4 I have that are candidates to go

All other rookies still have cash to make and are scoring well

A beautifully timed ton by Wilkie and Scrim today is really going to inject their cash rise now so stoked about that

Wouldn't be so quick RD. Agree that they all look average at the moment but Wilkie's scores prior to this week would have seen him also on that list had he got another 50.

I suppose what I'm trying to say is you have no idea which rookies might ton up next week. Fritsch was sitting on a 50 odd average after round 4 last year, many made the mistake of trading him out round 5. He averaged 101 up to his bye.

Worth keeping in mind as most rookies are still below 200k. I think Setters and Gibbons definitely have a bit of cash to generate

Well when Stack, Clarke, Hore and Rotham are all on the bubble this week - I'm not holding the super spud rookies - need to grab 2 fresh cows

I get your point, and for that reason I might hold Setters just because the position he plays

Burgess and Gibbons are deadweights

[sammy123]

Rotham keep his spot

[MontyJnr]

I just mentioned those 4 because they are the 4 I have that are candidates to go

All other rookies still have cash to make and are scoring well

A beautifully timed ton by Wilkie and Scrim today is really going to inject their cash rise now so stoked about that

Wouldn't be so quick RD. Agree that they all look average at the moment but Wilkie's scores prior to this week would have seen him also on that list had he got another 50.

I suppose what I'm trying to say is you have no idea which rookies might ton up next week. Fritsch was sitting on a 50 odd average after round 4 last year, many made the mistake of trading him out round 5. He averaged 101 up to his bye.

Worth keeping in mind as most rookies are still below 200k. I think Setters and Gibbons definitely have a bit of cash to generate

Well when Stack, Clarke, Hore and Rotham are all on the bubble this week - I'm not holding the super spud rookies - need to grab 2 fresh cows

I get your point, and for that reason I might hold Setters just because the position he plays

Burgess and Gibbons are deadweights

Would love to get fresh cows, but none of them are forwards (which is where Setterfield & Burgess are stuck in my side).

[js19]

I just mentioned those 4 because they are the 4 I have that are candidates to go

All other rookies still have cash to make and are scoring well

A beautifully timed ton by Wilkie and Scrim today is really going to inject their cash rise now so stoked about that

Wouldn't be so quick RD. Agree that they all look average at the moment but Wilkie's scores prior to this week would have seen him also on that list had he got another 50.

I suppose what I'm trying to say is you have no idea which rookies might ton up next week. Fritsch was sitting on a 50 odd average after round 4 last year, many made the mistake of trading him out round 5. He averaged 101 up to his bye.

Worth keeping in mind as most rookies are still below 200k. I think Setters and Gibbons definitely have a bit of cash to generate

Well when Stack, Clarke, Hore and Rotham are all on the bubble this week - I'm not holding the super spud rookies - need to grab 2 fresh cows

I get your point, and for that reason I might hold Setters just because the position he plays

Burgess and Gibbons are deadweights

Would love to get fresh cows, but none of them are forwards (which is where Setterfield & Burgess are stuck in my side).

I’ve got both Moore and Rozee stuck down back, so one of those definitely comes up forward. Parker might need to go now as well. Stalled completely.

[Ricochet]

Yeh I'm thinking fwd rookie out, Moore fwd at this stage

[Locinator]

I just mentioned those 4 because they are the 4 I have that are candidates to go

All other rookies still have cash to make and are scoring well

A beautifully timed ton by Wilkie and Scrim today is really going to inject their cash rise now so stoked about that

Wouldn't be so quick RD. Agree that they all look average at the moment but Wilkie's scores prior to this week would have seen him also on that list had he got another 50.

I suppose what I'm trying to say is you have no idea which rookies might ton up next week. Fritsch was sitting on a 50 odd average after round 4 last year, many made the mistake of trading him out round 5. He averaged 101 up to his bye.

Worth keeping in mind as most rookies are still below 200k. I think Setters and Gibbons definitely have a bit of cash to generate

Well when Stack, Clarke, Hore and Rotham are all on the bubble this week - I'm not holding the super spud rookies - need to grab 2 fresh cows

I get your point, and for that reason I might hold Setters just because the position he plays

Burgess and Gibbons are deadweights

Totally agree with your points, i was just giving a caution.

[Ringo]

Here are mine that may cause concern with the B/E

Burgess B/E 27
Butters B/E 48
Gibbons B/e 16
Scott B/e 24
Setterfield B/e 22
Parker B/e 46
Petrucelle B/E 15

Butters to Stack obviously one and then depending on teams one of Burgess or Parker. Can afford to carry a few on bench as slow burn.

[Bully]

Had earmarked my spare cash for Lloyd but the rookie situation in the forward line would appear to be more pressing. Think I'll also pass on Stack, fingers crossed Rotham is named because he's the guy I want. Next week Constable to Ross on the cards.