2019 Rookies

[YoungGun]

any richmond fans got an opinion on Naish JS?

[jbjimmyjb]

any richmond fans got an opinion on Naish JS?

I can't see him getting any more than 4 games.

Our best 18 (without Rance) is:
FB: Grimes, Astbury, Garthwaite
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Stack
C: Mcintosh, Lambert, Short
HF: Caddy, Lynch, Baker
F: Rioli, Riewoldt, Butler
Foll: Nankervis, Cotchin, Martin
Bench: Balta, Castagna, Prestia, _____.
Which leaves Graham, Ross, Ellis, Naish, Broad, Bolton and Higgins all fighting for one spot.

- Broad and Ellis are both straight back in next week (it's rumoured they were dropped for being drunk in Mildura last week).
- Astbury should be fit for next week too, and Bolton had a very good game in the 2s (25 disposals as a small fwd).
- Lambert and Short will return by Round 16.
- Riewoldt, Ross and Nankervis will also be fit by the end of July.

[YoungGun]

any richmond fans got an opinion on Naish JS?

I can't see him getting any more than 4 games.

Our best 18 (without Rance) is:
FB: Grimes, Astbury, Garthwaite
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Stack
C: Mcintosh, Lambert, Short
HF: Caddy, Lynch, Baker
F: Rioli, Riewoldt, Butler
Foll: Nankervis, Cotchin, Martin
Bench: Balta, Castagna, Prestia, _____.
Which leaves Graham, Ross, Ellis, Naish, Broad, Bolton and Higgins all fighting for one spot.

- Broad and Ellis are both straight back in next week (it's rumoured they were dropped for being drunk in Mildura last week).
- Astbury should be fit for next week too, and Bolton had a very good game in the 2s (25 disposals as a small fwd).
- Lambert and Short will return by Round 16.
- Riewoldt, Ross and Nankervis will also be fit by the end of July.

yep - as feared, think that could be very accurate.

[crowls]

any richmond fans got an opinion on Naish JS?

I can't see him getting any more than 4 games.

Our best 18 (without Rance) is:
FB: Grimes, Astbury, Garthwaite
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Stack
C: Mcintosh, Lambert, Short
HF: Caddy, Lynch, Baker
F: Rioli, Riewoldt, Butler
Foll: Nankervis, Cotchin, Martin
Bench: Balta, Castagna, Prestia, _____.
Which leaves Graham, Ross, Ellis, Naish, Broad, Bolton and Higgins all fighting for one spot.

- Broad and Ellis are both straight back in next week (it's rumoured they were dropped for being drunk in Mildura last week).
- Astbury should be fit for next week too, and Bolton had a very good game in the 2s (25 disposals as a small fwd).
- Lambert and Short will return by Round 16.
- Riewoldt, Ross and Nankervis will also be fit by the end of July.

yep - as feared, think that could be very accurate.

naish will be lucky to get a price rise,  i can add him to my drew scott, hayes rotham bines list of non playing rookies.   good news is corbett and young are playing   .....  whoop de do for me!!!  have you ever seen such a poor bench in your life?    my good rookies are duursma, answerth, setterfield and gardner.   a sad sad sad state of affairs.

[enzedder]

any richmond fans got an opinion on Naish JS?

I can't see him getting any more than 4 games.

Our best 18 (without Rance) is:
FB: Grimes, Astbury, Garthwaite
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Stack
C: Mcintosh, Lambert, Short
HF: Caddy, Lynch, Baker
F: Rioli, Riewoldt, Butler
Foll: Nankervis, Cotchin, Martin
Bench: Balta, Castagna, Prestia, _____.
Which leaves Graham, Ross, Ellis, Naish, Broad, Bolton and Higgins all fighting for one spot.

- Broad and Ellis are both straight back in next week (it's rumoured they were dropped for being drunk in Mildura last week).
- Astbury should be fit for next week too, and Bolton had a very good game in the 2s (25 disposals as a small fwd).
- Lambert and Short will return by Round 16.
- Riewoldt, Ross and Nankervis will also be fit by the end of July.

yep - as feared, think that could be very accurate.

naish will be lucky to get a price rise,  i can add him to my drew scott, hayes rotham bines list of non playing rookies.   good news is corbett and young are playing   .....  whoop de do for me!!!  have you ever seen such a poor bench in your life?    my good rookies are duursma, answerth, setterfield and gardner.   a sad sad sad state of affairs.

As I look at it at least Naish will score points for me this week if I bring him in.
I was considering a non playing Def DPP anyway.
I’m not bothered by a lack of a potential price rise.
I will have a finished team this week with only Duursma as D6 on my field as the only playing rookie if my best team is available. He’s good enough as D6 I think so to me cash generation is no longer that important.
JS will be factored into whoever I bring in but if Naish is the only def rookie named that I can afford I’ll be bringing him in. I already have Gardner. Everything depends on teams but I will bring in a 102k non playing DPP if it comes to that as well.

[sammy123]

Naish played well so i reckon he gets another run at least

[tkringle]

any richmond fans got an opinion on Naish JS?

I can't see him getting any more than 4 games.

Our best 18 (without Rance) is:
FB: Grimes, Astbury, Garthwaite
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Stack
C: Mcintosh, Lambert, Short
HF: Caddy, Lynch, Baker
F: Rioli, Riewoldt, Butler
Foll: Nankervis, Cotchin, Martin
Bench: Balta, Castagna, Prestia, _____.
Which leaves Graham, Ross, Ellis, Naish, Broad, Bolton and Higgins all fighting for one spot.

- Broad and Ellis are both straight back in next week (it's rumoured they were dropped for being drunk in Mildura last week).
- Astbury should be fit for next week too, and Bolton had a very good game in the 2s (25 disposals as a small fwd).
- Lambert and Short will return by Round 16.
- Riewoldt, Ross and Nankervis will also be fit by the end of July.

yep - as feared, think that could be very accurate.

naish will be lucky to get a price rise,  i can add him to my drew scott, hayes rotham bines list of non playing rookies.   good news is corbett and young are playing   .....  whoop de do for me!!!  have you ever seen such a poor bench in your life?    my good rookies are duursma, answerth, setterfield and gardner.   a sad sad sad state of affairs.

As I look at it at least Naish will score points for me this week if I bring him in.
I was considering a non playing Def DPP anyway.
I’m not bothered by a lack of a potential price rise.
I will have a finished team this week with only Duursma as D6 on my field as the only playing rookie if my best team is available. He’s good enough as D6 I think so to me cash generation is no longer that important.
JS will be factored into whoever I bring in but if Naish is the only def rookie named that I can afford I’ll be bringing him in. I already have Gardner. Everything depends on teams but I will bring in a 102k non playing DPP if it comes to that as well.

But Naish is not a DPP.

[quinny88]

I feel you're still needing rookies to come in and make money at this time of year then you're a bit  behind. Most teams will be finished after the byes. I just need Naish to play 1 more game this week to help with the byes then he can rot at D8. Will have either Duursma or Hoare at D7 for cover for the rest of the year

[crowls]

I feel you're still needing rookies to come in and make money at this time of year then you're a bit  behind. Most teams will be finished after the byes. I just need Naish to play 1 more game this week to help with the byes then he can rot at D8. Will have either Duursma or Hoare at D7 for cover for the rest of the year

your right vinny, lack of cash generation coming home to roost.   nothing i can really do about it now except review and learn for next year.   

[enzedder]

any richmond fans got an opinion on Naish JS?

I can't see him getting any more than 4 games.

Our best 18 (without Rance) is:
FB: Grimes, Astbury, Garthwaite
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Stack
C: Mcintosh, Lambert, Short
HF: Caddy, Lynch, Baker
F: Rioli, Riewoldt, Butler
Foll: Nankervis, Cotchin, Martin
Bench: Balta, Castagna, Prestia, _____.
Which leaves Graham, Ross, Ellis, Naish, Broad, Bolton and Higgins all fighting for one spot.

- Broad and Ellis are both straight back in next week (it's rumoured they were dropped for being drunk in Mildura last week).
- Astbury should be fit for next week too, and Bolton had a very good game in the 2s (25 disposals as a small fwd).
- Lambert and Short will return by Round 16.
- Riewoldt, Ross and Nankervis will also be fit by the end of July.

yep - as feared, think that could be very accurate.

naish will be lucky to get a price rise,  i can add him to my drew scott, hayes rotham bines list of non playing rookies.   good news is corbett and young are playing   .....  whoop de do for me!!!  have you ever seen such a poor bench in your life?    my good rookies are duursma, answerth, setterfield and gardner.   a sad sad sad state of affairs.

As I look at it at least Naish will score points for me this week if I bring him in.
I was considering a non playing Def DPP anyway.
I’m not bothered by a lack of a potential price rise.
I will have a finished team this week with only Duursma as D6 on my field as the only playing rookie if my best team is available. He’s good enough as D6 I think so to me cash generation is no longer that important.
JS will be factored into whoever I bring in but if Naish is the only def rookie named that I can afford I’ll be bringing him in. I already have Gardner. Everything depends on teams but I will bring in a 102k non playing DPP if it comes to that as well.

But Naish is not a DPP.

No he’s not. My point is I will happily bring in Naish for points this week. After that I don’t care so JS is not relevant. May as well get a non playing DPP if Naish doesn’t play. Trading regardless to afford two upgrades.

[EA100]

any richmond fans got an opinion on Naish JS?

I can't see him getting any more than 4 games.

Our best 18 (without Rance) is:
FB: Grimes, Astbury, Garthwaite
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Stack
C: Mcintosh, Lambert, Short
HF: Caddy, Lynch, Baker
F: Rioli, Riewoldt, Butler
Foll: Nankervis, Cotchin, Martin
Bench: Balta, Castagna, Prestia, _____.
Which leaves Graham, Ross, Ellis, Naish, Broad, Bolton and Higgins all fighting for one spot.

- Broad and Ellis are both straight back in next week (it's rumoured they were dropped for being drunk in Mildura last week).
- Astbury should be fit for next week too, and Bolton had a very good game in the 2s (25 disposals as a small fwd).
- Lambert and Short will return by Round 16.
- Riewoldt, Ross and Nankervis will also be fit by the end of July.

Please don't mention Dan Butler and best 18 in the same message  :(

[jbjimmyjb]

any richmond fans got an opinion on Naish JS?

I can't see him getting any more than 4 games.

Our best 18 (without Rance) is:
FB: Grimes, Astbury, Garthwaite
HB: Houli, Vlastuin, Stack
C: Mcintosh, Lambert, Short
HF: Caddy, Lynch, Baker
F: Rioli, Riewoldt, Butler
Foll: Nankervis, Cotchin, Martin
Bench: Balta, Castagna, Prestia, _____.
Which leaves Graham, Ross, Ellis, Naish, Broad, Bolton and Higgins all fighting for one spot.

- Broad and Ellis are both straight back in next week (it's rumoured they were dropped for being drunk in Mildura last week).
- Astbury should be fit for next week too, and Bolton had a very good game in the 2s (25 disposals as a small fwd).
- Lambert and Short will return by Round 16.
- Riewoldt, Ross and Nankervis will also be fit by the end of July.

Please don't mention Dan Butler and best 18 in the same message  :(

Trust me, it pains me just as much, but it's more a representation of how Hardwick sees the team than me, although I guess you could say that Higgins has more solid JS than Butler, but in my opinion they've both been terrible this year.

[jfitty]

What's the consensus on Naish now that he's been named?

The Tiges have a few injuries, but reckon he might get a decent go like the rest of Richmond's debutants this year.

[Bully]

What's the consensus on Naish now that he's been named?

The Tiges have a few injuries, but reckon he might get a decent go like the rest of Richmond's debutants this year.

I'm doing the Answerth to Naish trade, reckon Naish has the same prospects, if not better, given Brisbane will have a host of players returning. Last cash grab for a few weeks so want to get in early.

[LaHug]

My concern with Naish is that he's not playing next week because of his bye. I've gotta make sure I've still got a comfortable 19 players next week before trading any Round 14 guys in.