2018 Off Season (list changes and trade rumours)

[GoLions]

System is shower, but that's not the annoying thing, it's the hypocritical Cats fans pissing me off...when it was Danger and Ablett who wanted to go home for family reasons, it was fine, Suns and Crows should just let them go...now Kelly saying the same thing and Cats fans are saying no, he's under contract we won't allow it, was 2nd in our B&F so we want overs...they forget Ablett was Suns B&F too, but didn't give 2 showers there.  It is what it is, if we pay overs we pay overs or we just wait till next season.

We will get back the equivalent for Gaff as what Geelong got for Motlop.  Think about that for a sec...

You get the equivalent Hawks got for Buddy. Buddy > Gaff. If anything you're lucky tbqh.

[shaker]

It's very true sometimes it isn't fair what clubs get for there players especially when they turn free agents just read in the AFL site where Freo says pick 4 won't get the Neale trade done and fair enough he is in the super gun class and he is contracted so minimum 2 top 10 picks this year or pick 4 plus Lions 2nd round this year plus another future 2nd round seems about fair for a quality player like Neale.

[AaronKirk]

It's very true sometimes it isn't fair what clubs get for there players especially when they turn free agents just read in the AFL site where Freo says pick 4 won't get the Neale trade done and fair enough he is in the super gun class and he is contracted so minimum 2 top 10 picks this year or pick 4 plus Lions 2nd round this year plus another future 2nd round seems about fair for a quality player like Neale.

Unless Freo take that Brisbane deal for Neale they cannot get Hogan.

Will take 2 first round picks to get Hogan given what they paid for Lever last year. Hogan worth more than Lever.

[shaker]

It's very true sometimes it isn't fair what clubs get for there players especially when they turn free agents just read in the AFL site where Freo says pick 4 won't get the Neale trade done and fair enough he is in the super gun class and he is contracted so minimum 2 top 10 picks this year or pick 4 plus Lions 2nd round this year plus another future 2nd round seems about fair for a quality player like Neale.

Unless Freo take that Brisbane deal for Neale they cannot get Hogan.

Will take 2 first round picks to get Hogan given what they paid for Lever last year. Hogan worth more than Lever.

That's true but Neale is worth way more than just pick 4 Lions have lift there offer or all these trades could fall over

[jvalles69]

System is shower, but that's not the annoying thing, it's the hypocritical Cats fans pissing me off...when it was Danger and Ablett who wanted to go home for family reasons, it was fine, Suns and Crows should just let them go...now Kelly saying the same thing and Cats fans are saying no, he's under contract we won't allow it, was 2nd in our B&F so we want overs...they forget Ablett was Suns B&F too, but didn't give 2 showers there.  It is what it is, if we pay overs we pay overs or we just wait till next season.

We will get back the equivalent for Gaff as what Geelong got for Motlop.  Think about that for a sec...

You get the equivalent Hawks got for Buddy. Buddy > Gaff. If anything you're lucky tbqh.

I don't think we're lucky, I think Hawks got screwed too.

[Ricochet]

It's very true sometimes it isn't fair what clubs get for there players especially when they turn free agents just read in the AFL site where Freo says pick 4 won't get the Neale trade done and fair enough he is in the super gun class and he is contracted so minimum 2 top 10 picks this year or pick 4 plus Lions 2nd round this year plus another future 2nd round seems about fair for a quality player like Neale.

Unless Freo take that Brisbane deal for Neale they cannot get Hogan.

Will take 2 first round picks to get Hogan given what they paid for Lever last year. Hogan worth more than Lever.

This years first and a future pick?

[GoLions]

It's very true sometimes it isn't fair what clubs get for there players especially when they turn free agents just read in the AFL site where Freo says pick 4 won't get the Neale trade done and fair enough he is in the super gun class and he is contracted so minimum 2 top 10 picks this year or pick 4 plus Lions 2nd round this year plus another future 2nd round seems about fair for a quality player like Neale.

Unless Freo take that Brisbane deal for Neale they cannot get Hogan.

Will take 2 first round picks to get Hogan given what they paid for Lever last year. Hogan worth more than Lever.

That's true but Neale is worth way more than just pick 4 Lions have lift there offer or all these trades could fall over

We haven't even made an offer yet afaik. All we've said is that pick 4 is on the table.

[shaker]

It's very true sometimes it isn't fair what clubs get for there players especially when they turn free agents just read in the AFL site where Freo says pick 4 won't get the Neale trade done and fair enough he is in the super gun class and he is contracted so minimum 2 top 10 picks this year or pick 4 plus Lions 2nd round this year plus another future 2nd round seems about fair for a quality player like Neale.

Unless Freo take that Brisbane deal for Neale they cannot get Hogan.

Will take 2 first round picks to get Hogan given what they paid for Lever last year. Hogan worth more than Lever.

That's true but Neale is worth way more than just pick 4 Lions have lift there offer or all these trades could fall over

We haven't even made an offer yet afaik. All we've said is that pick 4 is on the table.

As you posted earlier gotta pay overs for contracted players  ;)

[GoLions]

It's very true sometimes it isn't fair what clubs get for there players especially when they turn free agents just read in the AFL site where Freo says pick 4 won't get the Neale trade done and fair enough he is in the super gun class and he is contracted so minimum 2 top 10 picks this year or pick 4 plus Lions 2nd round this year plus another future 2nd round seems about fair for a quality player like Neale.

Unless Freo take that Brisbane deal for Neale they cannot get Hogan.

Will take 2 first round picks to get Hogan given what they paid for Lever last year. Hogan worth more than Lever.

That's true but Neale is worth way more than just pick 4 Lions have lift there offer or all these trades could fall over

We haven't even made an offer yet afaik. All we've said is that pick 4 is on the table.

As you posted earlier gotta pay overs for contracted players  ;)

Correct. Will be something like pick 4 + next years 2nd rounder.

[shaker]

It's very true sometimes it isn't fair what clubs get for there players especially when they turn free agents just read in the AFL site where Freo says pick 4 won't get the Neale trade done and fair enough he is in the super gun class and he is contracted so minimum 2 top 10 picks this year or pick 4 plus Lions 2nd round this year plus another future 2nd round seems about fair for a quality player like Neale.

Unless Freo take that Brisbane deal for Neale they cannot get Hogan.

Will take 2 first round picks to get Hogan given what they paid for Lever last year. Hogan worth more than Lever.

That's true but Neale is worth way more than just pick 4 Lions have lift there offer or all these trades could fall over

We haven't even made an offer yet afaik. All we've said is that pick 4 is on the table.

As you posted earlier gotta pay overs for contracted players  ;)

Correct. Will be something like pick 4 + next years 2nd rounder.

Ha ha that's still unders for quality player like Neale but I know you have your Lions hat on  ;D

[Ringo]

It's very true sometimes it isn't fair what clubs get for there players especially when they turn free agents just read in the AFL site where Freo says pick 4 won't get the Neale trade done and fair enough he is in the super gun class and he is contracted so minimum 2 top 10 picks this year or pick 4 plus Lions 2nd round this year plus another future 2nd round seems about fair for a quality player like Neale.

Unless Freo take that Brisbane deal for Neale they cannot get Hogan.

Will take 2 first round picks to get Hogan given what they paid for Lever last year. Hogan worth more than Lever.

That's true but Neale is worth way more than just pick 4 Lions have lift there offer or all these trades could fall over

We haven't even made an offer yet afaik. All we've said is that pick 4 is on the table.

As you posted earlier gotta pay overs for contracted players  ;)

Correct. Will be something like pick 4 + next years 2nd rounder.

Ha ha that's still unders for quality player like Neale but I know you have your Lions hat on  ;D

Suspect this will get done as a three way trade with Melbourne with stake knives thrown in to balance.  Do not like it but there has been speculation that Cedric Cox could be added to 4.

[Ringo]

A new one has any one got any info on Tim English possibly going to one of the WA Clubs. Heard a small whisper so do not know if it has legs or not.

[SilverLion]

Assuming GC get Pick 3 as compo for Lynch...

Freo give: Neale + Pick 6
Freo get: Hogan + Pick 11 + Bris Future 2nd

Port give: Polec + Pick 10
Port get: Pick 5

Melbourne give: Hogan
Melbourne get: Pick 6 + Pick 10

Brisbane give: Pick 5 + Future 2nd
Brisbane get: Neale

North give: Pick 11
North get: Polec

Melbourne then could go 6 or 10 + 34 for May if May wants to go there.

Might need something extra to go to Port to make it work, but this would be my ideal 5 way trade.

[RaisyDaisy]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-10-05/dockers-wont-accept-pick-no4-for-neale

[SilverLion]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-10-05/dockers-wont-accept-pick-no4-for-neale

Rosich just using the Weller trade as an unfair precedent :P

But agree he's worth slightly more than 4.