Sicily replacement??

[quinny88]

Now I can't pick between Brayshaw and Crisp  :'(

Crisp is safer because he doesn't miss games but Brayshaw is in great form and saves me a bit of money that could come in very handy

[dmac07]

I am probably looking at Sicily to Simpson/Brayhaw /Crisp . Only one trade though and have JPK and also hearing rumours Josh Kelly may be out so will wait and see.

If I didn't have Simmo it wouldn't even be a question. I'd just get him in. 3rd highest average in defence, one point behind Lloyd but nearly 50k cheaper.

Im missing Simpson but thinking of going Hurley instead, the extra 100k odd could be handy.

[Woppa15]

Lotta love for Crisp. Any pies fans know why his scores are much better lately than the start of season?
Any change of role/other injured players etc.?

I think in early games we were using Sam Murray to rebound more before we realised his disposal wasn't the best. I think we changed to give it to Crisp more after Murray got dropped due to his better use.

Murray back in this week. You certain they won’t use him to rebound again and flower everyone who brings in crisp this week.....

[BundyOP]

Didn't even consider Luke Ryan but he is fascinating.

4 bad games of 51, 53, 61, 68 that brings his average down.
Then has games of 85, 88, 92, 92, 93 in that mid tier range.
Then his 100's being 106, 106, 114, 121, 125, 136, 140

They are some huge numbers. His OS numbers are 106, 114, 92, 85, 125, 136, 106, 53 and in that 53 he got an early knock so took some time off the ground. 4 out of his last 5 games at OS to come as stated, the tough game will be Geelong down at GMHBA.

Might jump on!!!!

You have sold me.

Need to trade out nicnat and sicily.
Had sinclair and brayshaw locked in.
Can get goldy and ryan!
Done

[Urbaninfinnity]

So this is my forward line atm

Sicily, D Smith, Heeney, Mclean, Gray, Westhoff (Battle, T Smith)

No one really stands out, I have all the players averaging over 100, (not counting reid) and several of the others in the high 90's haven't been in the best form in their recent games. (T Mac, Darling)

On the flipside, looking at Wingard and Hawkins with 3 rd averages of 110+. I'm a bit hesitant to pick up Wingard for the reason that half my forward line would be Port, but at the same time, if Hawkins doesn't kick goals his scoring probably won't be at that standard.

Money's no issue for me, This will be my final trade. Any suggestions?

[Blues Blues Blues]

So this is my forward line atm

Sicily, D Smith, Heeney, Mclean, Gray, Westhoff (Battle, T Smith)

No one really stands out, I have all the players averaging over 100, (not counting reid) and several of the others in the high 90's haven't been in the best form in their recent games. (T Mac, Darling)

On the flipside, looking at Wingard and Hawkins with 3 rd averages of 110+. I'm a bit hesitant to pick up Wingard for the reason that half my forward line would be Port, but at the same time, if Hawkins doesn't kick goals his scoring probably won't be at that standard.

Money's no issue for me, This will be my final trade. Any suggestions?

Buddy

[SilverLion]

Was stuck on Crisp vs. Hurn, but with Murray being named think that's just made the decision easy.

[crowls]

Why did this have to happen !!!!
I have Laird Yeo Simpson and Lloyd
So all the best options, and can’t swing him forward.

Hurn v Brayshaw v Crisp is way too hard and I cannot seperate them.
Brayshaw pops out to me the most but so does his head knocks.. Crisp is most durable but Pies have a tough draw and I feel as if I was to jump on Hurn that he would kill me
And then you add Hurley who will probs pull a heartstring and get told to stop zoning off

Fuaaaark you Sic

I’d go Brayshaw mate. Has changed his game so he doesn’t lead with his head as much anymore meaning he’s no more likely than any other player to get a head knock now. Also playing pure midfield and Viney’s injury means that will definitely continue. I reckon he’s the safest option. I have him already so am going Hurn

[Mongoose528]

Didn't even consider Luke Ryan but he is fascinating.

4 bad games of 51, 53, 61, 68 that brings his average down.
Then has games of 85, 88, 92, 92, 93 in that mid tier range.
Then his 100's being 106, 106, 114, 121, 125, 136, 140

They are some huge numbers. His OS numbers are 106, 114, 92, 85, 125, 136, 106, 53, 140 and in that 53 he got an early knock so took some time off the ground. 106 average at OS. 4 out of his last 5 games at OS to come as stated, the tough game will be Geelong down at GMHBA.

Might jump on!!!!

I think you've convinced me, Ryan seems super tempting.

[North Melbournes Finest]

People really rating Brayshaw above Crisp and Hurn? Maybe when he was high 300k's, not so much now. He's a jet, but consistency is a worry.

[TomK]

People really rating Brayshaw above Crisp and Hurn? Maybe when he was high 300k's, not so much now. He's a jet, but consistency is a worry.

Is it though? Only 2 out of his past 10 games below 89, pretty consistent if you ask me.

[SilverLion]

People really rating Brayshaw above Crisp and Hurn? Maybe when he was high 300k's, not so much now. He's a jet, but consistency is a worry.

Is it though? Only 2 out of his past 10 games below 89, pretty consistent if you ask me.

Crisp 1 game in last 10 below 89 (86).
Hurn also 2 games below 89 (83 and 61)

Agree they seem hard to split.

[jfitty]

I'm looking at a Hibberd replacement, between Crisp and Brayshaw for mine.

Going with Crisp though, played all 22 games in every season at the Pies. With only a couple of trades left, I couldn't deal with Brayshaw getting another head knock or a rest, no matter how well he's playing.

[North Melbournes Finest]

I'm so torn between Crisp and Hurn here.

My one thing is I already have two Collingwood players, and I don't usually like to get a third from one team.

[enzedder]

No need to post who I brought in.