Sicily replacement??

[HappyDEZ]

I have been racking my brain over this for 2 weeks. Sicily is a fwd for me and i really don't want TMac. Currently have
Smith, Westoff, Gray, Mclean, Heeney with Adhern & Langdon on the pine.

I am really thinking of going Wallis. 3 round average 99 and 5 round 97. Good games vs port, stkilda, north, blues & tigers.

Happy to be corrected.

Hard to argue. Has been very solid. I still prefer Menegola at 24K cheaper but he is just as likely to post a 70 odd as Wallis, maybe even more so. Will Bont coming back cost Wallis 10-15 points or is that offset by no Dahl? Franklin also a consideration. So the ups & downs of Buddy/Memegola vs. the consistency of Wallis. 6 of one......

[jfitty]

How about Darling? Bottomed out, was the top forward before his injury

[kilbluff1985]

don't know which fwd to get for Sicily

have 525k and D Smith, Heeney, Gray, Westy, Caddy

considering

McLean
Gresham
Wingard
Taranto

[ubeaut]

don't know which fwd to get for Sicily

have 525k and D Smith, Heeney, Gray, Westy, Caddy

considering

McLean
Gresham
Wingard
Taranto

McLean or Chad.

[nas]

don't know which fwd to get for Sicily

have 525k and D Smith, Heeney, Gray, Westy, Caddy

considering

McLean
Gresham
Wingard
Taranto

have a DPP in Mids? Swap then add a mid?

[kilbluff1985]

don't know which fwd to get for Sicily

have 525k and D Smith, Heeney, Gray, Westy, Caddy

considering

McLean
Gresham
Wingard
Taranto

have a DPP in Mids? Swap then add a mid?

nah

[shaker]

Haven't replaced yet but looking to , what about Aliir Aliir ? 379K , 5 round avg. 94 , 3 round avg. 105 would leave a nice little kitty in the bank for last trade , what do people think ? the only thing is would have to do trade before I see what Mihocek scores

[no eye deer]

Well, with Webster and Austin letting me down (again!), I’m forced to trade Webster. Can’t afford Lloyd and all the other choices didn’t exactly set the world alight last week. Wonder if it’s worth taking the punt on Harris Andrews as a pod?

[ubeaut]

Haven't replaced yet but looking to , what about Aliir Aliir ? 379K , 5 round avg. 94 , 3 round avg. 105 would leave a nice little kitty in the bank for last trade , what do people think ? the only thing is would have to do trade before I see what Mihocek scores

Wouldn't count on Mihocek repeating his performance vs Tiges backline. That said, is Aliir a risk u want to take at this time? He's never had great JS but is playing pretty good footy atm.
If u think he can keep it up, and u can use the left over cash to score more points, could be worth it.
Or wait a week for Webster for same price?

[shaker]

Haven't replaced yet but looking to , what about Aliir Aliir ? 379K , 5 round avg. 94 , 3 round avg. 105 would leave a nice little kitty in the bank for last trade , what do people think ? the only thing is would have to do trade before I see what Mihocek scores

Wouldn't count on Mihocek repeating his performance vs Tiges backline. That said, is Aliir a risk u want to take at this time? He's never had great JS but is playing pretty good footy atm.
If u think he can keep it up, and u can use the left over cash to score more points, could be worth it.
Or wait a week for Webster for same price?

Agree about Mihocek also have Richards but his last score looked a bit like he has hit the rookie wall , Aliir is a risk maybe see what Mihocek gets and can always grab Luke Ryan in the last game but Aliir is tempting would allow me to get another gun fwd for cover fwd and mid , as for Webster think I'll steer clear of him any more groin issues will probably see him shelved for the year  ;)