WXV Round 13: Dublin to tear down Berlin Wall?

[RaisyDaisy]

LOL now Ellis-Yolmen is out - dropping like flies here at NY

New York Revolution

D: Shannon Hurn, Robbie Tarrant, Dan Houston, Reece Conca  :'(
M: Shaun Higgins (CC) Jordan Lewis, Luke Dunstan, Richard Douglas
R: Paddy Ryder
F: Isaac Heeney (CC)  :'(, Jarryd Roughead, Jed Anderson, Kyle Langford
I: Hugh Greenwood, Jack Steele

E: Jade Gresham (F), Alex Sexton (D) Zac Langdon (F)

[Holz]

Apparently Heeney shouldn't have even been sent out in the third - AFL might even look into after Harley basically admitted he was concussed in the 2nd

Reckon we've been screwed on that

Not sure of the rules RD as can not see them in the thread but Heeney had only 44% TOG. Mot sure what happened in furst quarter but was watching his low stats and noticed only 61% TOG for quarter so he may not have been right initially.

Well as far as I understand as long as a player enters the field in the 3rd qtr their score counts

I think we might just get screwed by bad luck because Heeney shouldn't have been sent out on the field in the 3rd but he was, so for that reason I think we have to cop his 17, well 25 as CC  :-X

look on the positive side, at least you dont have HGA or it would have hurt that too.

NY

Conca - injured Q1 DNP
Heeney CC - 27 with CC bonus - injured


Cairo

Vlaustin - 125 hat a jet
Castanga - 29 - ruined Cairo HGA hopefully he is the worst so its 58

27/1.5 v 183/2

big lead for Cairo can they hold it off.


GO CAIRO GO

[Holz]

Rance tmac may davis
Crouch (CC) Jelly (CC) Sloane Dmart
Goldy
Jroo hoff hawkins gunston
Holman Hill

Daw Henry Omac

Geez its nice to have a full bench.

im going the gutless CC option

[GoLions]

Rance tmac may davis
Crouch (CC) Jelly (CC) Sloane Dmart
Goldy
Jroo hoff hawkins gunston
Holman Hill

Daw Henry Omac

Geez its nice to have a full bench.

im going the gutless CC option

Should get done for tanking tbh

[Holz]

Rance tmac may davis
Crouch (CC) Jelly (CC) Sloane Dmart
Goldy
Jroo hoff hawkins gunston
Holman Hill

Daw Henry Omac

Geez its nice to have a full bench.

im going the gutless CC option

Should get done for tanking tbh

well i would drop Dusty but he just edges out Daw, Henry and Omac

111 150 142 119 113 130 146 158 114 150 139 160 93 141 = 125 average back end of last year and first 4 games

91 88 87 64 103 105 85 88 62 = 86 average.

Basically its like losing Fyfe and then getting a spud like Connor Blakely in return.

[GoLions]

Rance tmac may davis
Crouch (CC) Jelly (CC) Sloane Dmart
Goldy
Jroo hoff hawkins gunston
Holman Hill

Daw Henry Omac

Geez its nice to have a full bench.

im going the gutless CC option

Should get done for tanking tbh

well i would drop Dusty but he just edges out Daw, Henry and Omac

111 150 142 119 113 130 146 158 114 150 139 160 93 141 = 125 average back end of last year and first 4 games

91 88 87 64 103 105 85 88 62 = 86 average.

Basically its like losing Fyfe and then getting a spud like Connor Blakely in return.

The flower did you think i was talking about to give that response

[Holz]

Rance tmac may davis
Crouch (CC) Jelly (CC) Sloane Dmart
Goldy
Jroo hoff hawkins gunston
Holman Hill

Daw Henry Omac

Geez its nice to have a full bench.

im going the gutless CC option

Should get done for tanking tbh

well i would drop Dusty but he just edges out Daw, Henry and Omac

111 150 142 119 113 130 146 158 114 150 139 160 93 141 = 125 average back end of last year and first 4 games

91 88 87 64 103 105 85 88 62 = 86 average.

Basically its like losing Fyfe and then getting a spud like Connor Blakely in return.

The flower did you think i was talking about to give that response

I played Dustin Martin

it cant be the CC as that doesn't make sense unless you think Crouch is alot worse then Jelly.

[GoLions]

Rance tmac may davis
Crouch (CC) Jelly (CC) Sloane Dmart
Goldy
Jroo hoff hawkins gunston
Holman Hill

Daw Henry Omac

Geez its nice to have a full bench.

im going the gutless CC option

Should get done for tanking tbh

well i would drop Dusty but he just edges out Daw, Henry and Omac

111 150 142 119 113 130 146 158 114 150 139 160 93 141 = 125 average back end of last year and first 4 games

91 88 87 64 103 105 85 88 62 = 86 average.

Basically its like losing Fyfe and then getting a spud like Connor Blakely in return.

The flower did you think i was talking about to give that response

I played Dustin Martin

it cant be the CC as that doesn't make sense unless you think Crouch is alot worse then Jelly.

Why would i respond to the CC if i wasn't talking about that

Having co-captains means you're a 99.9999% chance of not getting the best captain score possible. If they score equal, you get the same. If they score equal and score an odd number, you gain 1 point. If they don't score equal, you have just lost half the difference between them. Tanking.

[iZander]

Rance tmac may davis
Crouch (CC) Jelly (CC) Sloane Dmart
Goldy
Jroo hoff hawkins gunston
Holman Hill

Daw Henry Omac

Geez its nice to have a full bench.

im going the gutless CC option

Should get done for tanking tbh

well i would drop Dusty but he just edges out Daw, Henry and Omac

111 150 142 119 113 130 146 158 114 150 139 160 93 141 = 125 average back end of last year and first 4 games

91 88 87 64 103 105 85 88 62 = 86 average.

Basically its like losing Fyfe and then getting a spud like Connor Blakely in return.

The flower did you think i was talking about to give that response

I played Dustin Martin

it cant be the CC as that doesn't make sense unless you think Crouch is alot worse then Jelly.

Why would i respond to the CC if i wasn't talking about that

Having co-captains means you're a 99.9999% chance of not getting the best captain score possible. If they score equal, you get the same. If they score equal and score an odd number, you gain 1 point. If they don't score equal, you have just lost half the difference between them. Tanking.

or gained half of the difference between them :P

[GoLions]

Rance tmac may davis
Crouch (CC) Jelly (CC) Sloane Dmart
Goldy
Jroo hoff hawkins gunston
Holman Hill

Daw Henry Omac

Geez its nice to have a full bench.

im going the gutless CC option

Should get done for tanking tbh

well i would drop Dusty but he just edges out Daw, Henry and Omac

111 150 142 119 113 130 146 158 114 150 139 160 93 141 = 125 average back end of last year and first 4 games

91 88 87 64 103 105 85 88 62 = 86 average.

Basically its like losing Fyfe and then getting a spud like Connor Blakely in return.

The flower did you think i was talking about to give that response

I played Dustin Martin

it cant be the CC as that doesn't make sense unless you think Crouch is alot worse then Jelly.

Why would i respond to the CC if i wasn't talking about that

Having co-captains means you're a 99.9999% chance of not getting the best captain score possible. If they score equal, you get the same. If they score equal and score an odd number, you gain 1 point. If they don't score equal, you have just lost half the difference between them. Tanking.

or gained half of the difference between them :P

Only if you're incompetent ;)

[Holz]

Why would i respond to the CC if i wasn't talking about that

Having co-captains means you're a 99.9999% chance of not getting the best captain score possible. If they score equal, you get the same. If they score equal and score an odd number, you gain 1 point. If they don't score equal, you have just lost half the difference between them. Tanking.

or gained half of the difference between them :P

Only if you're incompetent ;)

In fairness you responded to my whole team being named and not just the last line where i was talking about CC.

The flip side to your argument and why many people go for CC is that your far less likely to get a horrible captain score ruining your round.

For example

Heeney CC turned out vastly superior to Heeney C

then i look back at my last few rounds and i haven't picked good captains.

Round 12: Crouch Captain 68 points
Round 11: Crouch Captain 106 points
Round 10: Dusty Captain 105 points
Round 9: Dusty Captain 103 points
Round 8: Crouch Captain 92 points

For me the choice between CC and C comes down to this

1. If you have a guy who is clearly the best option you go C
2. If you think your team is underdogs you go C
3. If you think your team is likely to win easy you should go CC unless you have a clear best option.
4. if you are neither massive under dogs or massive favorites and you have no clear captain then its tough to make a call.

i reckon im in 4.

Dublin i reckon is the toughest team to pick captain at the moment

Tmac - 110 my best player but as a key fwd he is risky and he isnt 100%
Selwood - 107 probably my most solid option but Jelly sometimes chucks in a shocker
Hoff - 104 not a bad option as he has a reasonably high floor
Dusty - 104 normally my go to captain but in shocking form
Crouch - 99 has been incredibly solid except for the 68 he gave me last time i picked him
Goldy - 96 in the best form of any player in my team but a risky option

[RaisyDaisy]

We've gone Heeney C all year

This week I decided to go with CC - glad I did

Still flowered though

[Adamant]

[Jroo]

Mexico City Suns
D: James Sicily (C), Jarryn Geary, Jacob Weitering, Bernie Vince
M: Lachie Hunter (VC), Jared Polec, Jack Graham, Jordan Cunico
R: Billy Longer
F: Christian Petracca, James Harmes, Mason Wood, Jordan Murdoch
U: Aaron Naughton, Mitch Hannan

EMG: Jack Silvagni, Lewis Jetta, Patrick Ambrose
[/quote]

[Nige]

Karen Sanderson

Jeremy McGovern, Shane Savage, Tom Stewart, Nick Vlastuin
Dayne Beams (evc), Taylor Adams (c), Ricky Henderson, Hugh McCluggage
Dawson Simpson
Ben Brown (vc), Mitch Robinson, Rory Lobb, Jason Castagna
Andrew McGrath, Travis Colyer

Shane Kersten, Mark Hutchings, Daniel McKenzie