Which mid?

Started by quinny88, June 24, 2018, 11:16:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

quinny88

Which mid should I get to complete my side? Can afford anyone. Can't decide between these 3!
My current team is below







Ringo

I would go Kelly, Oliver and Danger in that order. Only concern with Kelly would be with groins they can re-occur so maybe Oliver for safety.

Ricochet

Kelly has been great, but there's the risk of his groins flaring up
Danger has the risk of spending too much time fwd
Oliver is a ranger, but I'd go him mate

Trindacut

Danger has scored 150+ in last three outings against the doggies, but Kelly is a freak.

quinny88

This poll isn't really helping, it's almost dead even haha.

Danger I feel has had a bad wrap this year but he's still gone 100+ in 11/12 games with a low score of 94
Kelly is pure class with the groins the only Worry.
Oliver has been amazing for a 2nd year in a row but is very young.

Tough call to make! Really want to nail this as I already have Coniglio, Crouch and Merrett who aren't in the top tier of mids this year

tommy10

What about now?  ;D Voted Oliver.

no eye deer

#6
With Treloar gone, there might be a bit more interest in the thread now. For me, it’s Oliver or Kelly. Got Danger.

Leaning towards Oliver, only because I started Kelly and don’t want to get burnt twice. ::)

Might throw Neale into the mix as well.

SilverLion

Duncan and Gaff also good options.

ubeaut

I voted Danger. I have all 3, but would pick Danger if I had to choose.
He's got the runs on the board, hasn't gone below 94 despite playing alot of fwd. When Menzel comes back I'm thinking he'll be in the midfield more.

GCSkiwi

So, of course I brought in Treloar to "finish" my midfield last week...

Midfield is Fyfe, Titch, Oliver, Danger, Cripps, Conigs, Dusty, Treloar.

Pretty tempted to swap to Kelly but if the groin flares up again I'll potentially be in trouble. Thoughts on Kelly vs Gaff vs Curnow?

sammy123

I like kelly. But his past 2 scores were huge but against weak opposition in GC and lions. Just some food for thought

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: sammy123 on June 26, 2018, 07:09:52 PM
I like kelly. But his past 2 scores were huge but against weak opposition in GC and lions. Just some food for thought

Yes I have noticed this too. But he is a gun and GWS appearto be hitting their straps.

Bully

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on June 26, 2018, 07:12:15 PM
Quote from: sammy123 on June 26, 2018, 07:09:52 PM
I like kelly. But his past 2 scores were huge but against weak opposition in GC and lions. Just some food for thought

Yes I have noticed this too. But he is a gun and GWS appearto be hitting their straps.

2017 scores

vs Hawks (134)
vs Eagles (101 & 144 & 107)
vs Ess (176)

Anything close to this will see him rocket in price & basically be unaffordable for the rest of the year.

smashbox

Kelly Vs Neale?

Neale plays most of his remaining games in Perth and should go 110-115

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: smashbox on June 26, 2018, 08:10:27 PM
Kelly Vs Neale?

Neale plays most of his remaining games in Perth and should go 110-115

Was thinking the exact same question. Interested to see peoples opinions