Round 15 Trades

[B.]

With Treloar out now bringing him in last week

[dmac07]

Need some advice guys. Not getting any replies in team advice thread.

Last upgrade is probably Fritsch > Buddy.
2 concerns.
1.) Worth holding off as Fritsch plays Saints and Buddy plays Tiges?

2.) Need a downgrade to fund this, only Dawson,Narkle and J.Smith look like targets. Who would have better JS?
If trading in Smith would have to trade Austin, leaving Ridley and Smith as def cover.
If trading in Dawson/Narkle one of Phillips or Garlett would go

Id probably go Garlett to Dawson, both as likely to play as each other.

I dont know Frisch breakeven but think Buddy's is 50 odd, so I'd back Buddy to  go 80 this week and go up in price regardless of opponent.

[Wanderer]

Need some advice guys. Not getting any replies in team advice thread.

Last upgrade is probably Fritsch > Buddy.
2 concerns.
1.) Worth holding off as Fritsch plays Saints and Buddy plays Tiges?

2.) Need a downgrade to fund this, only Dawson,Narkle and J.Smith look like targets. Who would have better JS?
If trading in Smith would have to trade Austin, leaving Ridley and Smith as def cover.
If trading in Dawson/Narkle one of Phillips or Garlett would go

Fritsch BE is 96

Id probably go Garlett to Dawson, both as likely to play as each other.

I dont know Frisch breakeven but think Buddy's is 50 odd, so I'd back Buddy to  go 80 this week and go up in price regardless of opponent.

[ubeaut]

Need some advice guys. Not getting any replies in team advice thread.

Last upgrade is probably Fritsch > Buddy.
2 concerns.
1.) Worth holding off as Fritsch plays Saints and Buddy plays Tiges?

2.) Need a downgrade to fund this, only Dawson,Narkle and J.Smith look like targets. Who would have better JS?
If trading in Smith would have to trade Austin, leaving Ridley and Smith as def cover.
If trading in Dawson/Narkle one of Phillips or Garlett would go

Id probably go Garlett to Dawson, both as likely to play as each other.

I dont know Frisch breakeven but think Buddy's is 50 odd, so I'd back Buddy to  go 80 this week and go up in price regardless of opponent.

Cheers for the reply.
Problem with Garlett > Dawson is next to no cash left for injury trades.
Wondering if Austin > J.Smith would be better but worried about his JS with Ridley also on def bench.

[petefisker]

Neale - coming off another 150+ game. Brisbane at home this week and lots of games in perth coming up.
I need to trade Treloar and considering: Neale, Danger, Kelly or Higgins. Strongly leaning towards Neale.
Not sold on Kelly just beating up 2 soft teams with GWS tough run coming up and his groin could flare up any moment.

[Woppa15]

Looks like I'm going to have to hold my Fritsch -> TMac trade until bouncedown... should we still pick him up if he plays?

I'm keeping Fritsch
Out Treloar in Neale

Sssshhhhhhh...!!!!
This Treloar business is causing havoc on my POD

[Ricochet]

Looks like I'm going to have to hold my Fritsch -> TMac trade until bouncedown... should we still pick him up if he plays?

I'm keeping Fritsch
Out Treloar in Neale

Sssshhhhhhh...!!!!
This Treloar business is causing havoc on my POD

I'm with ya Woppa. Had Neale from the start and although his first month was shocking, he's really turned it on since

[jbjimmyjb]

Need some advice.
Was originally set to do Holman > Fyfe this week and finish off my team. However because of Holman's 45, I'm literally $900 short, so I can't do that.

Current midfield is:
Titch, Neale, Oliver, Danger, Gibbs, Dustin, Coniglio, Holman (Ahern, Giro, Dawson)

Option 1) Fritsch > Fyfe (via Ahern). Fritsch is my F7, so this would be fine to do. Leaves me with 70k.
Option 2) Holman > Kelly/Treloar. Leaves me with 50k, and Fritsch at F7.

[ubeaut]

Need some advice.
Was originally set to do Holman > Fyfe this week and finish off my team. However because of Holman's 45, I'm literally $900 short, so I can't do that.

Current midfield is:
Titch, Neale, Oliver, Danger, Gibbs, Dustin, Coniglio, Holman (Ahern, Giro, Dawson)

Option 1) Fritsch > Fyfe (via Ahern). Fritsch is my F7, so this would be fine to do. Leaves me with 70k.
Option 2) Holman > Kelly/Treloar. Leaves me with 50k, and Fritsch at F7.

Stick with your original choice. Get Fyfe imo. Highest averaging mid besides the injured Macrae.

[LaHug]

TMac, Buddy, or Gray for last forward...? Leaning towards Gray with his run home but a tough one.

[jbjimmyjb]

With Austin dropped I need new plans.

I can either get Fyfe/Battle or Cripps/Jack Riewoldt.

I have Fritsch at F6, so Jroo would be F7, and I could use Tim Smith (F8) to loophole his score every week except Rnd 17, because Richmond always plays before Melbourne.

Which one?

[Urbaninfinnity]

Thinking of downgrade either one of Austin/Spargo/Smith.

Leaning towards Spargo/Smith to Battle to get some more money so I can upgrade Guelfi next week.

Which one is better to downgrade? Smith is dropped, but lower BE and scores better than Spargo mostly, but Spargo nets me extra cash and I also have Giro and Ahern on the bench for cover.

[jvalles69]

flower you right in the ass Heeney...

[Chrispy75]

Considered trading Fritsch to Buddy, but saving trades.

Was happy with Buddy on 37 nearing 3QT.  Goals either side of the siren and wham he is on 70.  His low score was the only comfort I had with starting Heeney

[SilverLion]

Contemplating Garlett --> Powell

Need the cash to allow me to get a decent M9/F7 next week.

Should I go Powell? or Wilson/England/other cheap donut?

Next week I want to go T. Smith --> Mid/Fwd or Mid or Fwd prem and Duman --> 102k DEF.

Bench as it stands:

D: Witherden, Duman
M: Ahern, Giro, Garlett
R: Olango
F: T. Smith, Battle

Thoughts?